Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Rimfires Buckmark Or Ruger.

As a lifelong fan of the Ruger 22 auto pistol, I've become a Buckmark convert recently.

If talking new vs new production, I'll take the Buckmark 10 times out of 10.




Dave

You couldn't give me a Buckmark. My 5 1/2" stainless 22/45 does all one needs.

I have had a few different Ruger mk 2 ad Mk1, a browning buckmark, I sold when I had vehicle issues, the browning was lighter, easier to disassemble and re-assemble, more accurate for my form of plinting, that said, I feel ruger would hold up longer, but thats an opinion, not a fact., you'd do ok with either.

My buddy was using his buckmark the other day. It was a jamming sob (probably just dirty). Nonetheless, he left his ruger mkII at home. Different strokes for different folks, but give me my Ruger any day over the buckmark..

Never owned a Buckmark. I have 3 mark 2's. They digest any thing I feed them. No need to change. Hasbeen

I've owned the 22/45, MKII, and Buckmark. Factory barrels, as well as Pac-Lites on each. I think they're about the same in terms of reliability. Rugers seemed to shoot better, but might have been the sight radius, or some difference in sight design that my eyes preferred.

As a side note, the Pac-Lite barrels took a beating on the alloy breech face. I wouldn't buy another and would just get the factory 22/45 Lite instead.

I never cared for the Ruger bolt that you need to pinch, or the goofy grab-ons. The Browning slidebar is a little better in terms of replicating a centerfire pistol for overhand manipulation. You may not care about that aspect, but I was shooting the MKII a lot for awhile and when I switched to my centerfires I found myself pinching the slide and thumbing the heel for mag changes I was shooting the MKII a ton but it was still embarrassing as hell.

For riding in the truck, I got a Charger. It's been a hoot. And I wouldn't mind trying the M&P 22lr Compact. Based on the reports it seems like it's more reliable than the Rugers or Brownings that I've owned and shot.

Buck Mark.

I chose Ruger. But you can't go wrong with either.

Been a MKII fan for 34 years, tried a SS Camper 5 1/2" and really like it. Not a fan of the MKIII, but these folks always putting up Porn pics....like above!

I like my Ruger MKII's but recently acquired a WaltherPPQ..fine auto, accurate and great trigger. Seen them on GunBroker for around $250 will probably sell one of the Rugers for another WaltherPPQ

I like the Buckmark better. The ergonomics make it feel better in my hand. The trigger seems better also. I shot my buddies Ruger and I have a Buckmark. The Ruger is still a nice piece.

What he said. Always been a Ruger guy, especially Mk II, but the new Smith looks like a winner. Got one on layaway at Whittakers.

Pal at the range has a Buckmark and the trigger on his is exceptional. Don't think I've seen it jam, but ammo can make a huge difference. My 22/45 eats about everything, but Fed 550 misfires a good bit. Think I paid about $13.50 so can't complain too much.

New S&W

^redefines rimfire ugly, but it looks to run well from my limited experience watching one at a steel challenge. Hard to beat a Buck Mark or a Ruger for reliability and accuracy, so the Smith has to have ergos you really like to get you to buy one over the Ruger or Browning.

I plan to try one of these in next year or so. I dont care much for the buckmark or the ruger 22/45. The victory seems to combine shooting quantities I prefer with easy take down. It is new, so; fan boys are limited.

The Ruger works out much nicer for QD scope mounting for range time and back to irons in the field. If I could only have one it would be some version of MkIII.

I like the feel and pointing of the Ruger MkII & III and the older Browning's like the challenger and high standard. FWIW, I also like the Luger P08 feel and pointing over the 1911. The 1911 is more durable, just prefer the ergonomics.

This is a common question and lots of fun to read and contribute. The real answer is the OP should sample both if he can or hold and aim both or just go try one. Because - reasonable and reliable, they ALL are that. Truck gun, consider a single 6,7,9, or 10 ruger revolver for the glove box.

not a fan of the ruger because of the cocking 'ears'. Not conducive to shoulder holster carry...





And if red dots and suppressors aren't needed/wanted, THIS kicks ALL their azzes.....

It ain't beautiful, but the easy take-down is a big plus. The trigger is good to go as is. The mag disconnect can be pulled out in about 2 minutes without any permanent modification. Accessory barrels are a part, not a "firearm" like the Ruger, and are available from Volquartsen now for as little as $215. The scope rail has a fixed sight and exchanges with the adjustable sight in seconds with one screw. All in all, there's a lot you can do with minimal fuss.

I like the way my 22/45 shoots, but it's fussy about feeding the first round, the trigger is only fair, and the having to hold the slide release to drop the slide on a loaded mag is a pointless pain in the ass. If the new Smith is as good as its press, the Ruger's going down the road.

If going Ruger, I'd recommend the regular Mk II, if you can find one.

My Micro Buckmark with a custom compensator put a whoopin' on many a Ruger at bowling pin matches. Tried a couple Rugers for pins but would frequently jam or not reset the trigger in rapid fire. Maybe it was just me but it was not an issue after switching to the Browning.
For target shooting or plinking either is fine in my book but I do like the Buckmark ergonomics better.

Kenoh2: I have been on Gopher Safari all week and had occasion to run 200 rounds (Winchester 40 grain Power-Points) through my Ruger MK-III Hunter with red dot sight and 100 rounds (Winchester 40 grain Power-Points) through my Browning BuckMark Gold 5 1/2" barrel with optical scope sight.
I never had a misfire, jam or failure to eject in all 300 rounds.
And accuracy was comparable along with the triggers being equally pleasing.
Longest Gopher kill shot so far this year with the rimfire pistols has been right at 60 yards.
My longest laser confirmed kill shot on Gophers was with my Ruger MK-III and that was 72 yards year before last.
I "carry" both pistols in zippered pistol "rugs" with pockets for ammo and Allen wrench's etc.
Guys, I am so happy with all my Rugers and BuckMarks that I call it a tie from my experiences.
Hold into the wind
VarmintGuy

I wasn't meaning to say that Rugers have a jamming or trigger issue in regular use. The problem was probably my "technique" when trying to go warp speed. I haven't shot pins in years... er.. decades and doubt if I have the ability to go that fast anymore anyhow.

Actually, A MKIII Hunter is on my want list unless I can find a reasonably priced Buckmark Varmint or Silhouette in like new condition.