Home
Posted By: TXbluelacy H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
Kinda looking for a one size fits all powder for several rifles, and these two powders both appear to be reasonable/good choices for the 30-06, 243,and 300win mag. Also interested in the 308, but I have some Re15 for it. Re15 also appears to be a good choice for 30-06 with 150gr bullets.

Any experience or preference with one over the other?
Posted By: Eremicus Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
I much prefer H4350 over IMR 4831. Meters better and it's temperature stable whereas IMR 4831 is not. Like it better than IMR 4350 for the same reasons. E
Posted By: RDFinn Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
You mean the SC version of H4350 meters better which it does.
Posted By: mathman Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
I think that's the only one available now. They don't even call it SC anymore.
Posted By: Ron_T Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
H4350 is hard to beat... works well for full loads in my Ruger #1 in 7x57mm as well. It's a good "all-around" powder for a good many calibers... and, as Eremicus mentions, it's one of Hodgdon's "EXTREME" powders which Hodgdon claims is not sensitive to temperatures.

I have found this claim to be true which makes H4350 a powder that one can work up loads with in the heat of Summer and enjoy the SAME muzzle velocity and, thus, the same point-of-impact in the dead of Winter as you got in the heat of Summer which takes all the "guess-work" out of sighting over long distances.

It meters well through my Lyman 505 powder measure too. smile


Strength & Honor...

Ron T.
Posted By: mathman Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/21/11
Quote
It meters well through my Lyman 505 powder measure too.


It does fine in my Redding BR-30. I don't weigh H4350 charges for my 243, and it's under MOA to 300 yards (five shot groups) with very little load development.
Either one should work plenty good in all 3 rounds. The 308's on it's own though..grin

Dober
Posted By: Elkmen Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
I use H-4350 in several calibers. 06, 300WM, 280, 7mmRM. 7X57.
Posted By: bsa1917hunter Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
Originally Posted by Eremicus
I much prefer H4350 over IMR 4831. Meters better and it's temperature stable whereas IMR 4831 is not. Like it better than IMR 4350 for the same reasons. E


+1
Posted By: bsa1917hunter Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
Originally Posted by mathman
I think that's the only one available now. They don't even call it SC anymore.


I think mathman is correct about this. It meters great through the uni-flo but the IMR doesn't mad
Posted By: gorskij Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
Originally Posted by TXpitdog
Kinda looking for a one size fits all powder for several rifles, and these two powders both appear to be reasonable/good choices for the 30-06, 243,and 300win mag. Also interested in the 308, but I have some Re15 for it. Re15 also appears to be a good choice for 30-06 with 150gr bullets.

Any experience or preference with one over the other?

You want a powder that meters very well and very close to H4350 in burn rate, and works well in '06, 243 & 300WM, look at PP4000MR, like Dobey said, 308 is on its own, RE15 will fit that bill. Example of what 4000MR does in my '06.
[Linked Image]
Posted By: bsa1917hunter Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
Originally Posted by gorskij
Originally Posted by TXpitdog
Kinda looking for a one size fits all powder for several rifles, and these two powders both appear to be reasonable/good choices for the 30-06, 243,and 300win mag. Also interested in the 308, but I have some Re15 for it. Re15 also appears to be a good choice for 30-06 with 150gr bullets.

Any experience or preference with one over the other?

You want a powder that meters very well and very close to H4350 in burn rate, and works well in '06, 243 & 300WM, look at PP4000MR, like Dobey said, 308 is on its own, RE15 will fit that bill. Example of what 4000MR does in my '06.
[Linked Image]


Gorskij, ol buddy ol pal. I just switched to H4350 or I'd be all over that pp4000mr stuff. blush Great shootin too by the way.
Posted By: gorskij Re: H4350 or IMR-4831? - 09/22/11
Originally Posted by bsa1917hunter
Originally Posted by gorskij
Originally Posted by TXpitdog
Kinda looking for a one size fits all powder for several rifles, and these two powders both appear to be reasonable/good choices for the 30-06, 243,and 300win mag. Also interested in the 308, but I have some Re15 for it. Re15 also appears to be a good choice for 30-06 with 150gr bullets.

Any experience or preference with one over the other?

You want a powder that meters very well and very close to H4350 in burn rate, and works well in '06, 243 & 300WM, look at PP4000MR, like Dobey said, 308 is on its own, RE15 will fit that bill. Example of what 4000MR does in my '06.
[Linked Image]


Gorskij, ol buddy ol pal. I just switched to H4350 or I'd be all over that pp4000mr stuff. blush Great shootin too by the way.

Thanks BSA, dont get me wrong, H4350 shoots very well, too.
[Linked Image]
And it flows almost like water thru my Hornady measure.
© 24hourcampfire