Hornady 17 Hornet Brass quality report. - 05/08/15
Hello all
I started off with this 17 Hornet experience when brass was in short supply, essentially only option was through Gun -broker at prices I could not justify. As I understood the quality factory brass being obtained at that time left a lot to be desired.
So I went ahead and formed my own brass from Privi 22 Hornet brass and was very pleased with the outcome of what I felt was some pretty good quality brass. Only issue I had was the brass varied in weight a little over 3 grains. Not a problem Ill just sort my brass, and so I did.
As a comparison I just formed some 17 Fireball brass from Lapua 221 Fireball brass and only complaint I may of had with the Lapua brass was the weight variation which ran roughly 3 grains here as well.
Accuracy proved very satisfying to me in the CZ 527 American rifle with the 17 Hornet Fire-forming loads as well as the fire formed brass. Typical accuracy experienced came in at anywhere from .5" to .8" with both the fire forming loads as well as the fire formed brass when the wind would cooperate. Not a lot of variable wind required to open up a half moa group up to 1&1/2 moa group.
Then I Got my hands on some factory Ammo and soon therafter some virgin Hornady 17 Hornet brass at a price I could live with. Well I was having such a good experience with the home rolled brass I left the Hornady brass alone while I was still experimenting with bullets powder and primers in the fire-formed Privi brass. Lack of sub MOA accuracy with the factory 17 hornet ammo never helped spark my intrest in working more with the factory brass at that time. Perhaps the factory ammo may prove more accurate in warmer weather. My initial test took place in sub zero to 30 above weather.
This week I finally got around to working with the Hornady 17 Hornet Brass purchased back in December of 2014. This brass is proving to be very good quality. Weighed out 150 pieces of virgin brass and all of this brass fell within 6 tenths of a grain, most fell within two tenths of a grain
Primer pockets are nice and snug and very uniform and the same uniformity follows through with every other feature on this brass. I can be quite critical and I must say No fault to be found with this brass.
Brass from the once fired factory ammo came in nearly as uniform with a few pieces exceeding 1 grain variation.
Will be interesting to see how accuracy works out with the factory 17 Hornet brass.
As well as the home formed 17 hornet, from the 22 Hornet worked out, Ill be surprised if this proves much if any more accurate.
Seems like all is falling into plan. The factory brass should work great from the bench and perhaps the prairie dog fields where keeping track of brass can be very controlled.
The Privi brass will be great for when out calling predators and other field work. Wont feel quit as bad when loosing a few pieces of the fire formed brass. Have a little over a quarter a piece into that brass and a fair amount of sweat to boot. Well good therapy to take my mind off some of life's other concerns for a while.
Looking forward to a few more days when the wind is not blowing 10 to 25 MPH to test these loads in the factory 17 Hornet brass. Unfortunately calm days even mornings or evenings are a rarity in this area I call home.
I started off with this 17 Hornet experience when brass was in short supply, essentially only option was through Gun -broker at prices I could not justify. As I understood the quality factory brass being obtained at that time left a lot to be desired.
So I went ahead and formed my own brass from Privi 22 Hornet brass and was very pleased with the outcome of what I felt was some pretty good quality brass. Only issue I had was the brass varied in weight a little over 3 grains. Not a problem Ill just sort my brass, and so I did.
As a comparison I just formed some 17 Fireball brass from Lapua 221 Fireball brass and only complaint I may of had with the Lapua brass was the weight variation which ran roughly 3 grains here as well.
Accuracy proved very satisfying to me in the CZ 527 American rifle with the 17 Hornet Fire-forming loads as well as the fire formed brass. Typical accuracy experienced came in at anywhere from .5" to .8" with both the fire forming loads as well as the fire formed brass when the wind would cooperate. Not a lot of variable wind required to open up a half moa group up to 1&1/2 moa group.
Then I Got my hands on some factory Ammo and soon therafter some virgin Hornady 17 Hornet brass at a price I could live with. Well I was having such a good experience with the home rolled brass I left the Hornady brass alone while I was still experimenting with bullets powder and primers in the fire-formed Privi brass. Lack of sub MOA accuracy with the factory 17 hornet ammo never helped spark my intrest in working more with the factory brass at that time. Perhaps the factory ammo may prove more accurate in warmer weather. My initial test took place in sub zero to 30 above weather.
This week I finally got around to working with the Hornady 17 Hornet Brass purchased back in December of 2014. This brass is proving to be very good quality. Weighed out 150 pieces of virgin brass and all of this brass fell within 6 tenths of a grain, most fell within two tenths of a grain
Primer pockets are nice and snug and very uniform and the same uniformity follows through with every other feature on this brass. I can be quite critical and I must say No fault to be found with this brass.Brass from the once fired factory ammo came in nearly as uniform with a few pieces exceeding 1 grain variation.
Will be interesting to see how accuracy works out with the factory 17 Hornet brass.
As well as the home formed 17 hornet, from the 22 Hornet worked out, Ill be surprised if this proves much if any more accurate.
Seems like all is falling into plan. The factory brass should work great from the bench and perhaps the prairie dog fields where keeping track of brass can be very controlled.
The Privi brass will be great for when out calling predators and other field work. Wont feel quit as bad when loosing a few pieces of the fire formed brass. Have a little over a quarter a piece into that brass and a fair amount of sweat to boot. Well good therapy to take my mind off some of life's other concerns for a while.
Looking forward to a few more days when the wind is not blowing 10 to 25 MPH to test these loads in the factory 17 Hornet brass. Unfortunately calm days even mornings or evenings are a rarity in this area I call home.
