Now after being in the field, I could see NO difference between either of them, well perhaps just a tad in a very low light situation but come on hunters, how many shoot deer in the dark? I just don't need that extra 2 to 5 minutes of being able to see in the field.
The simple fact is that many deer and elk are killed during the first and last few minutes of legal light.And legal light is from one hour before sunrise until one hour after sunset in some locations.
For years I was not what I would call a "low light" hunter,because I climbed,and walked pretty constantly,shot much of my game in full daylight,or otherwise pretty favorable light conditions,etc.So a scope's low light performance was not very important to me,and te emphasis for me was on light carry weight and enough power to get the job done....
But.....the last few years finds me spending more time in Alberta each season;some of this hunting still involves the same kind of hunting I always did;however,much of the hunting(the really important times of the day)are generally done under declining light conditions;and mature Canadian bucks of either species tend to be VERY nocturnal,sneak out into those fields at the very last moment available,and it seems the bigger they are,the later they show.....
...to the point where inability to see has cost a buddy a chance at a couplke of real muy grandes that he could not see well enough to shoot......
My best Alberta buck was taken at last light,but running across a field against snow....I could have killed him through a coke bottle....but next time, I might not have snow,and I might not get so lucky.....
I am paying more attention to low light performance now,than I did in years past....so I agree with Stubblejumper on this issue....he lives where I go to hunt.....