Home
Posted By: hunter4623 Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Took a boat ride this morning to recover a stump for a client. Found a nice log that I just had to have. Not sure what this is but I believe it might be locust. Super dense, rich yellow interior. No bark since it’s been washing in the river for quite a while. Anyone have a guess or confirm what it is?

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: dale06 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Maybe Osage orange aka hedge.
Posted By: yobuck Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Id have to be able to smell it before i could give an accurate opinion.
Im actually very good at determining various types of wood that way.
I was stuck one time however.
A guy handed me a small piece and i was unable to give him an answer right off like i usually can.
So in order to further humiliate me he asked me to take a guess.
So i told him that it was either a scrap of wood from an old outhouse, or a piece of pussy willow.
Posted By: Ray_Herbert Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Hornbeam?
Posted By: wabigoon Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Dale could be correct.[Linked Image from img1.etsystatic.com]
Posted By: hunter4623 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
It was a straight trunk about 25’ long. Eliminates any Osage orange ive ever seen around here
Posted By: slumlord Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Looks a lot like locust to me.

That’s what sawn locust looks like here.

Bodock, O-orange/ hedge apple is little more orange. Orange-yellow.

Locust here is green-yellow

Bark...that’s a toss up, looks slightly more on the locust to me.

I’ve cut hundreds of locust poles for fencing. I might know at least a little about it.
Posted By: hunter4623 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: Orion2000 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Cross section in OP looks very similar to the Black Locust we have in Northern KY. As noted above, Osage Orange seldom has a very long straight section to the stem.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Is black locust that rough on the exterior?
Posted By: kwg020 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Mulberry or hedge. I don't remember locust being that yellow. You would have to cut it to get a good smell of it.

kwg
Posted By: gregintenn Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Looks like Black Locust to me.
Posted By: dassa Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
Posted By: rem141r Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
i'd say locust from the color, grain and length of trunk.
Posted By: CWT Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
What state Hunter 4623????? and in what area of that state?
Posted By: hunter4623 Re: Wood ID help - 07/21/21
South Jersey. Across from Philadelphia international Airport
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Non-native where I used to live and recall black locust to look like this web image. I cut some, geeze that was 7 years ago, and milled into a few boards... Some dense stuff.
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]



Exterior did not look like the OP's top pic - that I recall, it was much smoother.

Such as. (web images)


[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: Txwildman Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Cut some shavings off it and see if it smells like juniper or cedar. Could be black locust as well.
Posted By: StGeorger Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
If it doesn't float, then Natalie wood.
Posted By: dassa Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Originally Posted by StGeorger
If it doesn't float, then Natalie wood.

You and I are going to burn in he'll for that. You posting it, and me laughing.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Originally Posted by dassa
Originally Posted by StGeorger
If it doesn't float, then Natalie wood.

You and I are going to burn in he'll for that. You posting it, and me laughing.

Well, I Googled it...
Posted By: kingston Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Looks like Black Locust to me.

Where are you located?
Posted By: lostsixgunner Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Black locust. Very good firewood. It doesn't rot.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Originally Posted by dale06
Maybe Osage orange aka hedge.

More likely imo than black locust to have the rougher convoluted trunk as shown. References say it'll grow "straigher" in bottomland when in tight clumping rather than very crooked in open settings.
Posted By: WV_Airedale Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Locust would be my guess
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
It is locust. I burn lots of it here in the NC mountains.
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Originally Posted by StGeorger
If it doesn't float, then Natalie wood.



You are not a well man. That is sick, sick.
It is funny, though.
Posted By: hosfly Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Ive seen pecan that color
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Dead horse aside. Provide one picture of a barkless black locust log that looks like the OP, picture number one. Anyone?
Posted By: hunter4623 Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Took it to a local old timer that’s a wood guy. He said probably locust but he didn’t discount mulberry. Difficult to identify because it’s been rolling around in the water and on the beach for a long time. He thinks the softer parts of the trunk eroded away and left behind the unique look. Either way,it’s cool and I’ll make something even cooler out of it at some point.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
Saw somewhere if you were to cut a fresh (? for drift wood) piece out and place in water, osage will color the water and black locust will not. Have fun with it.


PS Encouraging. I hope to get out and find some local wood for a little project, possibly mountain mahogany.
Posted By: navlav8r Re: Wood ID help - 07/22/21
It would make a good background for some duck, squirrel, bird, body mounts
Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
To prove locust put it under a blacklight. It will shine brilliant yellow. My bet is it will glow.

Osage extractive are yellow, so that would prove osage, if the wood seems to be lighter, mulberry.
Posted By: Oldman03 Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
Several people mentioned mulberry..... that's my guess.
Posted By: Caplock Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
My bets on osage orange.
Posted By: poboy Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
This looks to be an old thread (1yr.). He ought to know by now.
Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
Originally Posted by MtnBoomer
Saw somewhere if you were to cut a fresh (? for drift wood) piece out and place in water, osage will color the water and black locust will not. Have fun with it.


PS Encouraging. I hope to get out and find some local wood for a little project, possibly mountain mahogany.
Bring extra chains for the saw! Man is that stuff hard!
Posted By: TheLastLemming76 Re: Wood ID help - 08/20/22
Looks like locust to me.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 08/21/22
I haven't gotten over the convoluted exterior, yet, nor am I highly likely to! LOL
Posted By: shootem Re: Wood ID help - 08/21/22
Originally Posted by Sitka deer
Originally Posted by MtnBoomer
Saw somewhere if you were to cut a fresh (? for drift wood) piece out and place in water, osage will color the water and black locust will not. Have fun with it.


PS Encouraging. I hope to get out and find some local wood for a little project, possibly mountain mahogany.
Bring extra chains for the saw! Man is that stuff hard!

When it’s good & dry on the outside hit it with a chainsaw. If it throws sparks you can see in the daytime bet on locust.
Posted By: Bristoe Re: Wood ID help - 08/21/22
Poplar
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Wood ID help - 08/21/22
Locust, 100 percent guaranteed.
Posted By: Idaho_Shooter Re: Wood ID help - 08/21/22
It does resemble black locust. And like Slummy, I have planted hundreds if not thousands of them as fence posts, sawed out of groves on the farm.

But I have not seen a black locust free of bore holes in over forty years.

That alone would disqualify the piece as locust to me. Perhaps locust borers refuse to live in Jersey.
Posted By: MtnBoomer Re: Wood ID help - 08/23/22
I searched the world over and found pics aplenty of non-smooth looking black locust logs as well as straightish osage orange logs that I am going with the majority for once... LOL

Pretty groovy. I have some black locust at home incorporated into my loading "desk" and will try it when I get a chance with a correct light.
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: Valsdad Re: Wood ID help - 08/23/22
Well, I would never have guessed osage orange would grow in NJ, but apparently from what I was able to find it does.


That changes my thinking a bit as to what those logs are.
Posted By: WV_Airedale Re: Wood ID help - 08/23/22
Looks like locust
Posted By: Raeford Re: Wood ID help - 08/23/22
Originally Posted by simonkenton7
Locust, 100 percent guaranteed.

This^^^
© 24hourcampfire