Yellowstone's zone of death - 02/05/22
This is a new one on me but the problem is 150 years old. Yellowstone NP is in 3 states. The part in Idaho is only about 1% of the park's total. Apparently there's a legal black hole there. When the park was created, WY was given the authority to try and convict when a crime was committed within the park. However, the constitution says that crimes must be tried in the state where they're committed and by a jury of their peers within the region. In theory, a crime committed in that part of the park in Idaho can't be prosecuted because there are zero people living in that part of the park to form a jury. This has never been tested in court, though.
A lawmaker in Idaho is trying to close the hole. It requires an act of congress, though, since the park is controlled by a federal agency.
REBECCA BOONE Associated Press
BOISE — A panel of Idaho lawmakers is recommending the Legislature ask Congress to fix a legal loophole that has some calling a portion of Yellowstone National Park the “Zone of Death,” where crimes could arguably go unprosecuted.
The vast majority of the 3,471-square-mile (8,990-square-kilometer) park sits in Wyoming, but about 3% of it stretches into Montana and 1% of the park is in eastern Idaho. When Congress created the park in 1872, the federal court in the District of Wyoming was given jurisdiction over the crimes committed within park borders.
Boise Democratic Rep. Colin Nash, an attorney, told the House Judiciary and Rules Committee on Thursday that he first learned about the “zone of death” in law school. The phrase refers to a legal theory advanced by Michigan State Law professor Brian Kalt in 2005, which says a jurisdictional loophole could force the federal government to dismiss charges against anyone accused of committing a federal crime in the Idaho portion of the park.
In an academic paper titled “The Perfect Crime,” Kalt noted the Sixth Amendment says that people charged with crimes have a right to be tried by a jury of their peers, selected from the state and region where the crime took place.
That’s a problem for Yellowstone, because the only beings living in Idaho’s roughly 50-square-mile portion of Yellowstone are grizzly bears, elk and other wildlife — and they aren’t eligible for jury duty. Kalt theorized that someone who committed a murder in Idaho’s portion of Yellowstone could get away with it, since the federal government would be unable to seat a constitutionally sound jury.
Nash is sponsoring a joint memorial to formally ask Congress to close the loophole.
“No crimes have been committed, that I’m aware of, and gone unprosecuted,” Nash told the committee. “But every time there’s a high-profile disappearance in this area, I think about this — and there were two last year.”
During the months-long search for 16-year-old Tylee Ryan and her little brother, 7-year-old JJ Vallow, law enforcement authorities said they’d obtained video and photo evidence that the children had entered Yellowstone National Park with their mother Lori Vallow Daybell, but no evidence was found showing Tylee ever left the park. The bodies of both children were later found buried in the back yard of an eastern Idaho home owned by their mother’s new husband, Chad Daybell. Lori and Chad Daybell were subsequently charged with several crimes in Idaho state court.
When 22-year-old Gabby Petito disappeared last year shortly after calling her family from Grand Teton National Park — which borders Yellowstone — theories about the “zone of death” again came to the fore. Petito’s body was found in the Wyoming portion of the park, and authorities pinned the blame on her boyfriend Brian Laundrie, who was later found dead in a Florida swamp.
Congress could change the law to make the Idaho and Montana portions of Yellowstone subject to the jurisdictions of the District of Idaho and the District of Montana. Nash’s memorial would urge Congress to do just that, at least for Idaho.
Nash acknowledged that it’s not clear if Congress will actually do anything, since it’s long been a known issue.
“We can try our darnedest,” he told the committee, prompting some rueful laughter in the room.
The committee agreed on a voice vote to recommend that the full House of Representatives approve the resolution.
A lawmaker in Idaho is trying to close the hole. It requires an act of congress, though, since the park is controlled by a federal agency.
REBECCA BOONE Associated Press
BOISE — A panel of Idaho lawmakers is recommending the Legislature ask Congress to fix a legal loophole that has some calling a portion of Yellowstone National Park the “Zone of Death,” where crimes could arguably go unprosecuted.
The vast majority of the 3,471-square-mile (8,990-square-kilometer) park sits in Wyoming, but about 3% of it stretches into Montana and 1% of the park is in eastern Idaho. When Congress created the park in 1872, the federal court in the District of Wyoming was given jurisdiction over the crimes committed within park borders.
Boise Democratic Rep. Colin Nash, an attorney, told the House Judiciary and Rules Committee on Thursday that he first learned about the “zone of death” in law school. The phrase refers to a legal theory advanced by Michigan State Law professor Brian Kalt in 2005, which says a jurisdictional loophole could force the federal government to dismiss charges against anyone accused of committing a federal crime in the Idaho portion of the park.
In an academic paper titled “The Perfect Crime,” Kalt noted the Sixth Amendment says that people charged with crimes have a right to be tried by a jury of their peers, selected from the state and region where the crime took place.
That’s a problem for Yellowstone, because the only beings living in Idaho’s roughly 50-square-mile portion of Yellowstone are grizzly bears, elk and other wildlife — and they aren’t eligible for jury duty. Kalt theorized that someone who committed a murder in Idaho’s portion of Yellowstone could get away with it, since the federal government would be unable to seat a constitutionally sound jury.
Nash is sponsoring a joint memorial to formally ask Congress to close the loophole.
“No crimes have been committed, that I’m aware of, and gone unprosecuted,” Nash told the committee. “But every time there’s a high-profile disappearance in this area, I think about this — and there were two last year.”
During the months-long search for 16-year-old Tylee Ryan and her little brother, 7-year-old JJ Vallow, law enforcement authorities said they’d obtained video and photo evidence that the children had entered Yellowstone National Park with their mother Lori Vallow Daybell, but no evidence was found showing Tylee ever left the park. The bodies of both children were later found buried in the back yard of an eastern Idaho home owned by their mother’s new husband, Chad Daybell. Lori and Chad Daybell were subsequently charged with several crimes in Idaho state court.
When 22-year-old Gabby Petito disappeared last year shortly after calling her family from Grand Teton National Park — which borders Yellowstone — theories about the “zone of death” again came to the fore. Petito’s body was found in the Wyoming portion of the park, and authorities pinned the blame on her boyfriend Brian Laundrie, who was later found dead in a Florida swamp.
Congress could change the law to make the Idaho and Montana portions of Yellowstone subject to the jurisdictions of the District of Idaho and the District of Montana. Nash’s memorial would urge Congress to do just that, at least for Idaho.
Nash acknowledged that it’s not clear if Congress will actually do anything, since it’s long been a known issue.
“We can try our darnedest,” he told the committee, prompting some rueful laughter in the room.
The committee agreed on a voice vote to recommend that the full House of Representatives approve the resolution.
