Home
Posted By: BrotherBart Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
H.R.258 - Stolen Valor Act of 2013
I hope that we all understand how serious this really is.
The reason this is law is because there are good folks that have to put up with imbeciles that want to piggy back off of those that did their duty and nothing else.
Beware 4321. You are known to the good people that defend and take this law seriously.
Glenn Holcomb will be in a world of hurt if he keeps on being a pain in the collective Campfire's ass.
And the Stolen Valor Act will make things right.
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart
H.R.258 - Stolen Valor Act of 2013
I hope that we all understand how serious this really is.
The reason this is law is because there are good folks that have to put up with imbeciles that want to piggy back off of those that did their duty and nothing else.
Beware 4321. You are known to the good people that defend and take this law seriously.
Glenn Holcomb will be in a world of hurt if he keeps on being a pain in the collective Campfire's ass.
And the Stolen Valor Act will make things right.



Umm, SCOTUS ruled it unconstitutional a few years ago.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG

Umm, SCOTUS ruled it unconstitutional a few years ago.


H.R. 258: Stolen Valor Act of 2013

Introduced:
Jan 15, 2013 (113th Congress, 2013�2015)
Status:
Enacted � Signed by the President on Jun 3, 2013
Law:
This bill became the law numbered Pub.L. 113-12.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
On June 3, President Barack Obama signed into law The American Legion-backed Stolen Valor Act of 2013, which now makes it a "federal crime for an individual to fraudulently hold oneself out to be a recipient of any of several specified military decorations or medals with the intent to obtain money, property, or other tangible benefit."

The U.S. Supreme Court overturned the original Stolen Valor Act of 2005, deeming it unconstitutional because it was, in the justices� opinion, too broad in scope and violated the right of free speech. The Legion passed Resolution 283 during its 2012 National Convention, calling on Congress to amend the Stolen Valor Act of 2005, to provide that the elements of fraud be incorporated into previous Stolen Valor legislation. U.S. Rep. Joe Heck, R-Nev., and the Legion worked together to draft a new Stolen Valor Act that included this legal language in effort to meet the Supreme Court�s objections to the old Stolen Valor Act.

On Jan. 15, 2013, Heck introduced H.R.258, the Stolen Valor Act of 2013. The bill also criminalized the act of lying to gain unearned veterans health-care benefits or other rewards, such as employment reserved for veterans. And on May 20, the House of Representatives passed Heck�s bill by a vote of 390 to 3. Legion Commander James E. Koutz praised the overwhelming, bipartisan vote.

"The American Legion is impressed with Congress today," he said. "Those who deliberately lie about military service, wear medals they did not earn or make claims of combat heroism they did not achieve are more than just liars. They are perpetrators of the worst kind of fraud. Their lies are an insult to all who have truly stood in harm�s way and earned their decorations. We raised this issue at our national convention, and the House acted."

On May 22, the Senate passed the legislation by unanimous consent. Senators Dean Heller, R-Nev., and Jon Tester, D-Mont., introduced the Senate companion bill (S. 210).

Both Heck and Heller rejoiced at the president�s signature. "I�m pleased that the valor and integrity of our military awards, along with the men and women who have earned them, are once again protected by law," Heck said. "It has been an incredibly rewarding process, and I thank all of those who have helped along the way in making this bill a law."

"I�m pleased that President Obama signed the Stolen Valor Act into law," Heller said. "The brave acts of the men and women in our military should be honored and protected. Thanks to the hard work of Rep. Heck and those who joined us in support of this issue, the recognition that these men and women earned will be preserved."
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Has he claimed to have been awarded a CMH or a Navy Cross?
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG

Umm, SCOTUS ruled it unconstitutional a few years ago.

I'd like to know when that happened.
I'm just a regular guy from Texas that had something to do with the Stolen Valor Project and I didn't hear about all of our hard work flushed down the Supreme Court's toilet.
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
He can be prosecuted for wearing the following;

a Medal of Honor,
a Distinguished Service Cross,
a Navy Cross,
an Air Force Cross,
a Silver Star,
a Purple Heart,
a Combat Infantryman's Badge,
a Combat Action Badge,
a Combat Medical Badge,
a Combat Action Ribbon,
a Combat Action Medal, or
any replacement or duplicate medal for such medal as authorized by law.

And uses it for financial gain.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart

The U.S. Supreme Court overturned the original Stolen Valor Act of 2005, deeming it unconstitutional because it was, in the justices� opinion, too broad in scope and violated the right of free speech.

There is a difference between 2005 and 2013.
Why do I have to do this?
The dates are damned easy to know the difference from.
Look it up. I did. Ain't going to do it for you again.
Posted By: RichardAustin Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart
H.R.258 - Stolen Valor Act of 2013
I hope that we all understand how serious this really is.
The reason this is law is because there are good folks that have to put up with imbeciles that want to piggy back off of those that did their duty and nothing else.
Beware 4321. You are known to the good people that defend and take this law seriously.
Glenn Holcomb will be in a world of hurt if he keeps on being a pain in the collective Campfire's ass.
And the Stolen Valor Act will make things right.



Wonder how it compares to say stalking, harassment, defamation, or slander? As long as you're certain, probably nothing to worry about.
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
The section I posted was taken directly from the act of 2013.

Pretty narrow in scope, I haven't read much of his cr@p to see if he's violated my post above.
Posted By: Snyper Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by RichardAustin

Wonder how it compares to say stalking, harassment, defamation, or slander? As long as you're certain, probably nothing to worry about.


One ass stinks the same as the other
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by RichardAustin

Wonder how it compares to say stalking, harassment, defamation, or slander?

I don't know Richard.
Who have you stalked?
Who have you harassed?
Who's character have you defamed?
Who have you slandered?
Interesting questions if you want to be honest.
Posted By: Barkoff Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14

Unless something new happened that I have not heard about...


http://www.news-reporter.com/news/2...ays_its_okay_to_lie_about_military_.html

http://www.military.com/daily-news/2012/06/28/supreme-court-strikes-down-stolen-valor-act.html

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...urt-ruling-on-false-military-medals.html
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14

And I guess everyone will suck it up and praise these turds.
Posted By: Barkoff Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart


No, I think it is just another case of a Supreme Court ruling against the will of about 80% of Americans who thinks it's bullschitt.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
So...
What do you really think?
Posted By: Barkoff Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
What do you mean?

I think it should be a crime, so did Congress, but some slap-happy judge thought it equated to freedom of speech.

Walk around in a policeman's uniform and watch what happens.
Posted By: okok Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Dude, you really need to get a life, you take this internet way too seriously. Get a hobby or something...cooking chili obviously is not the answer to fulfill your time. If you don't like this guy just put him on ignore or simply don't read his posts...it's really that simple.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Posting about something as important as Stolen Valor must have hit a nerve with you.
I'm not surprised.
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by okok
If you don't like this guy just put him on ignore

Tell me who to put on ignore.
Posted By: okok Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart
Posting about something as important as Stolen Valor must have hit a nerve with you.
I'm not surprised.

I'm not sticking up for this guy, sounds like a blow hard. I doubt he's doing anything for profit, just trolling.
Posted By: okok Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Ignore him and he will go away. wink
Posted By: Barkoff Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Now I'm confused. crazy
Posted By: Mannlicher Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
me too. Are we talking about a 'fire poster here?
Posted By: MadMooner Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Take a knee, or 4321 as he now logs in under, has on many occasions alluded to his service experience and training. He's kinda an azz.

Bart is gonna call the poleece on 'em.

Just another episode of As The Campfire Burns......

Posted By: Rancho_Loco Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
this is getting gooood..
Posted By: Mannlicher Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
ahhhh. It all becomes clear. Or sorta clear. Or maybe not.
Posted By: MadMooner Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Clear as mud.
Posted By: toad Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by okok
Originally Posted by BrotherBart
Posting about something as important as Stolen Valor must have hit a nerve with you.
I'm not surprised.

I'm not sticking up for this guy, sounds like a blow hard. I doubt he's doing anything for profit, just trolling.


unless he uses stolen valor as qualification for his supposed 'shooting classes'

but I'm not accusing him of being anything other than a dumbass.
Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
I can't believe some people actually think internet forums are reality, and then they react/respond with the same flawed premise.

Internet forum's are little more than personalized portions of Fantasy Island.

Get over it.
Posted By: Stan V Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Yep. It doesn't really matter which blowhard blows...they still blow.

Posted By: djs Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG
He can be prosecuted for wearing the following;

a Medal of Honor,
a Distinguished Service Cross,
a Navy Cross,
an Air Force Cross,
a Silver Star,
a Purple Heart,
a Combat Infantryman's Badge,
a Combat Action Badge,
a Combat Medical Badge,
a Combat Action Ribbon,
a Combat Action Medal, or
any replacement or duplicate medal for such medal as authorized by law.

And uses it for financial gain.


WOW!!! This guy was one busy SOB. He apparently served in the US Army, US Navy, US Air Force and, maybe in the US Marines. Gotta admire him! (NAH) frown
Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
It appears you refuse to take this issue seriously,

We'll see who's laughing when the Authorities are busting down your door in the next few minutes,

Even the Supreme Court is involved here, You have no idea...........
Posted By: efw Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...
Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
We'll, now there are vehicles headed to your location also,

Warned ya!
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by efw
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...



IIRC the penalty for putting beans in chili is the offender is to be smothered in molasses and then staked over an ant hill.
Posted By: mathman Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG
Originally Posted by efw
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...



IIRC the penalty for putting beans in chili is the offender is to be smothered in molasses and then staked over an ant hill.


What's the penalty for icing down sipping whiskey? A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
While I obviously think he's as big of a dumbass as anyone, I doubt if his conduct on here is for his financial gain, and thus rises to the threshold of the 2013 law.

Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by mathman
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG
Originally Posted by efw
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...



IIRC the penalty for putting beans in chili is the offender is to be smothered in molasses and then staked over an ant hill.


What's the penalty for icing down sipping whiskey? A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?


grin
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by mathman
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG
Originally Posted by efw
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...



IIRC the penalty for putting beans in chili is the offender is to be smothered in molasses and then staked over an ant hill.


What's the penalty for icing down sipping whiskey? A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?


I like ONE cube in mine, but I'm a yankee.....
Posted By: mathman Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by mathman
Originally Posted by AJ300MAG
Originally Posted by efw
Oh c'mon... Ain't like he put beans in his chili or ice in his bourbon...



IIRC the penalty for putting beans in chili is the offender is to be smothered in molasses and then staked over an ant hill.


What's the penalty for icing down sipping whiskey? A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?


I like ONE cube in mine, but I'm a yankee.....


Try a small amount of still spring water instead.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
I make the cube out of Fiji water. I started doing that with certain scotch a few years ago, and it carried over to bourbon.

Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by mathman

A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?


You worked Guantanomo?
Posted By: mathman Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
It's not the water that's bad, it's the chill.
Posted By: mathman Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by Kenneth
Originally Posted by mathman

A chunk of dry ice in the jock strap maybe?


You worked Guantanomo?


When they figured out I hunted whiskey icers, they said I was too mean for their facility. grin
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by mathman
It's not the water that's bad, it's the chill.


Aaaaah. I will have to try just a splash of the Fiji water warm.
Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Water-boarding seems like child's play compared to your play book.

Do you have a tracer bug that tracks the key words, " Ice, Whiskey"?

it's uncanny........
Posted By: mathman Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by Kenneth
Water-boarding seems like child's play compared to your play book.

Do you have a tracer bug that tracks the key words, " Ice, Whiskey"?

it's uncanny........


I just "luck" into these things.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Hey, at least this thread "evolved" instead of "devolved."

Everyone who isn't a moron has to agree that drinking good bourbon better > some potential stolon valor douche.

Posted By: Wtxj Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Thought I would add this article before thread goes downhill to far. I go to this gun store once in a while. Don't know if I have ever met this guy or not. He was arrested for his acts of receiving a reward from LGS that cared a lot for vets.

http://www.weatherforddemocrat.com/...97e40fe-692e-11e4-a142-5f4b2f85c499.html
Posted By: Deerwhacker444 Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
This was the latest one making the rounds...





Reminds me of...


Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by Wtxj
Thought I would add this article before thread goes downhill to far. I go to this gun store once in a while. Don't know if I have ever met this guy or not. He was arrested for his acts of receiving a reward from LGS that cared a lot for vets.

http://www.weatherforddemocrat.com/...97e40fe-692e-11e4-a142-5f4b2f85c499.html


Kinda hoping they took a detour on their way to the jail. Then again ifin you're good you don't leave a bruise...
Posted By: Kenneth Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
The alleged "perp" tried to convince me/us that I needed to have a waterproof,sealed Backpack while I'm drowning when crossing raging whitewater rivers,

He didn't try to sell me one, Which is why I find this thread, and the "perp" complete comedy.

YMMV.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
You guys realize you are interfering with my acquisition of bourbon-drinking tips, right?!!?!?!
Posted By: slumlord Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by goalie
While I obviously think he's as big of a dumbass as anyone, I doubt if his conduct on here is for his financial gain, and thus rises to the threshold of the 2013 law.

which dumb ass are we talking about ? Bart ?? Or this other guy that's playing all these fools like a cheap fiddle??

HAHAHAHAHAHA

Posted By: slumlord Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Hijack warning in effect:

laugh laugh laugh
Posted By: efw Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Please don't hijack; this stuff about beans in chili and ice in whiskey is important stuff that needs to be discussed.
Posted By: slumlord Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
[Linked Image]
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by efw
Please don't hijack; this stuff about beans in chili and ice in whiskey is important stuff that needs to be discussed.


No kidding. And, pray tell, what do you call it when I make venison "chili" but it has beans?????
Posted By: calikooknic Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Deerlicious
Posted By: AJ300MAG Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by efw
Please don't hijack; this stuff about beans in chili and ice in whiskey is important stuff that needs to be discussed.


No kidding. And, pray tell, what do you call it when I make venison "chili" but it has beans?????


A sacrilege...
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
The neighbors didn't think so. Crock pot from full to "THERE IS NONE LEFT?!?!?!" in 30 minutes......
Posted By: W7ACT Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by Barkoff
Originally Posted by BrotherBart


No, I think it is just another case of a Supreme Court ruling against the will of about 80% of Americans who thinks it's bullschitt.


So he has nothing to worry about.

He's just another John Kerry!!!!! sick
Posted By: poboy Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
It's okay, you can call the stuff whatever you want.
Posted By: SmokeEater2 Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by efw
Please don't hijack; this stuff about beans in chili and ice in whiskey is important stuff that needs to be discussed.


No kidding. And, pray tell, what do you call it when I make venison "chili" but it has beans?????



That's the way I make it. But then I like an ice cube in my Old Weller Antique too. whistle
Posted By: 2ndwind Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
I'm pro Bart for both his chili recipe AND his distain for posers...
Posted By: byc Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by slumlord
[Linked Image]


That's GREAT!!! LMAO!
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by SmokeEater2
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by efw
Please don't hijack; this stuff about beans in chili and ice in whiskey is important stuff that needs to be discussed.


No kidding. And, pray tell, what do you call it when I make venison "chili" but it has beans?????



That's the way I make it. But then I like an ice cube in my Old Weller Antique too. whistle


Yes!!! There's someone that can hang out with me on the porch at deer camp.

cheers!
Posted By: byc Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
"Old Weller Antique"

I'm fortunate enough to have several jugs of OWA but danged if it doesn't taste like cough medicine!
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Originally Posted by goalie
While I obviously think he's as big of a dumbass as anyone, I doubt if his conduct on here is for his financial gain, and thus rises to the threshold of the 2013 law.


If I recall correctly,there was money involved.
Also...This isn't directed toward you goalie because I believe you get it.
I don't care where this things lead. Yuck it up all you want but to anyone that haven't been involved in something as important as Stolen Valor,maybe it's serious and means more than some insults.
So put beans in your chili and Coke and ice in your bourbon,I don't care. But act like a fool and lie about being in the Military or what you did while you were there,watch out because there are folks around that take that kind of thing very seriously.
Posted By: byc Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
there are folks around that take that kind of thing very seriously.
=================================================
As they should!!

I got pissed when I saw some guys selling their Eagle Scout badges and certificates on e-bay! And of course the fakers who buy them. I realize it's not near the same BUT it's not at all right. Just WRONG!
Posted By: calikooknic Re: Stolen Valor - 12/20/14
Agreed Bart. Take A Schit, Countbacula, or whatever that dumbfucq calls himself this week, needs a good old fashioned azzwhompin if his lies are indeed just that.

Beans, ice, cola, fat chicks, tat tramps, all that is whatever someone prefers. No skin off my nose.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
Originally Posted by BrotherBart
Originally Posted by goalie
While I obviously think he's as big of a dumbass as anyone, I doubt if his conduct on here is for his financial gain, and thus rises to the threshold of the 2013 law.


If I recall correctly,there was money involved.
Also...This isn't directed toward you goalie because I believe you get it.
I don't care where this things lead. Yuck it up all you want but to anyone that haven't been involved in something as important as Stolen Valor,maybe it's serious and means more than some insults.
So put beans in your chili and Coke and ice in your bourbon,I don't care. But act like a fool and lie about being in the Military or what you did while you were there,watch out because there are folks around that take that kind of thing very seriously.


He didn't bet me. I put up the 2k that he was not an active duty SF and he backed off his offered bet real quick.

I thought he was probably guard, but, his sudden disappearance and lack of promised disclosure has me thinking I gave him more credit than he was due......
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
I think you handled yourself like a gentleman and you were more patient with him than I ever could be.
I always wonder what drives someone to act like an ass on an internet site like this. There must be something basically wrong with him. Probably still wets the bed or still sucks his thumb.
Anyway,you called him and he backed off. Win-win.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
The real "win" is tomorrow when real people from the fire have a beer at the VFW in Blaine and don't treat each other like complete jerks.

I might try to start a 9mm vs .45 discussion though....

smile
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
[Linked Image]
Posted By: BrotherBart Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
I talked to 338Rem(Steve)and he said that he's going to try and make the get-together. I talk to him on the phone pretty regular and he's a very funny guy.
Y'all are going to have a good time.
Posted By: 280shooter Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
[Linked Image]
Posted By: Barkoff Re: Stolen Valor - 12/21/14
You know, it boggles my mind that there are really dudes out there who can do this. No self respect at all, I can't fathom that, I can't even begin to.
Posted By: efw Re: Stolen Valor - 12/22/14
Some peoples' integrity is worth nothing to them and it shows.

Unrelated but had to say... BB your old avatar was way better.
Posted By: goalie Re: Stolen Valor - 12/26/14
So did TAK ever send that e-mail? I thought it was gonna take a "nanosecond" to verify his claims?!?!?!?!
Posted By: 12344mag Re: Stolen Valor - 12/26/14
It is very obvious that a "nanosecond" shares no relationship with the "second".
© 24hourcampfire