After a few years at a previous employer, I am entitled to a small monthly pension when I turn 65, which is about 9 years away. The company is offering to cash out employees with lump sum payments, along with other options that aren't interesting. I'll probably work until I am 67...and maybe 70. I have a variety of other investments, all of which are worth more than this one.

I'll use fictitious numbers, that are more or less in the ballpark. If I do nothing, the pension will start paying me $100 a month, forever. If I take a cash settlement right now, it would pay me $9710.00. I can roll it into an IRA, otherwise it's taxable right now.

So I take the $9710, invest it in an IRA (I'd probably do mutual funds or ETF), and earn 8% compound interest. I have $20,963 after 10 years. Assuming I used the right formula and continue making 8% compounded interest, I could withdraw $184.50/month for 20 years.

The pros of cashing in (as I see it) are:

-if the company goes broke before I die, the pension is at risk.
- after 59½, I could cash the IRA with no tax penalty, if I really needed it.
- After retirement I'll probably be buying a home to retire to, and cash reserves will be handy.
- I control my money

cons:

- I take the money and buy a Rigby (or something equally irresponsible)

********

So I am inclined to take the cash out option. Opinions?

I have a situation similar to yours, the Rigby sounds like a good fall back position...grin

For $10,000 I would cash it in and re-invest.

Roll it over to an IRA. But 8% compound is extremely optimistic.

I was thinking the same 8% is probably the upper end of what you could expect. You might make that much, but you might not.