Patrick, in the late 'nineties I was sitting under an old post oak tree that had limbs drooping all the way to the ground, making a natural blind. I was watching one of my box hog traps with corn scattered out in front of it and soured corn inside.
One by one, young bucks came and fed on the corn a good while. I believed all of them to be 1 1/2 Y O with small 8 point racks.... except one.
He appeared to be the same age as the others, but he behaved differently. He never came fully out of the brush but I could see he had a ten point frame and appeared to have some trash points.
I figured I'd see him again next year, but I didn't. Nor the next year or the next.
I forgot about him, figuring one of my neighbors killed him. But I saw signs of a good buck each year.
Then, in 1999, about 150 yards from where I had sat watching the young bucks that day, and after finding signs of a big deer, I threw up an elevated box blind.
And killed this deer:
174 gross, 163 6/8 net NT, with 18 score-able points.
At the base of his right antler, on the rear, there is an "L" point with each leg of the "L" being about an inch. For several years, someone would kill a young buck with that "L" point in the same place, but often only an 8 point.
In spite of all my "schooling", my young lease partners just couldn't pass up young 10 points, and the last one killed in that pasture that had the "L" point was only 1 1/2 YO. He had an inside spread of about 15 inches and 15 points. That was 3 years ago.
I hope you are rewarded for doing the right thing.