Home
Posted By: stxhunter 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
any suggestions using the beartooth 350 gr piledriver.
Posted By: T LEE Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Fill the case with FFg to just compress when the bullet is seated! smile smile
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
FFg? this is a marlin guide gun i'll be loading for.
Posted By: hanco Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Big thumper
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
going to kill something with it this year.
Posted By: Deerwhacker444 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Don't have one of those...


[Linked Image]
Posted By: rost495 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Need me to load something let me know.

Not sure I have 350 grain data but I can snoop around too. LOL.

Jeff
Posted By: deerstalker Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by stxhunter
FFg? this is a marlin guide gun i'll be loading for.

1895 marlins shoot FFg just fine! you would be surprised at the accuracy using it. the load quoted will kill anything living. only draw back is clean up.

of the listed loads the starting Imr 4198 is my favorite. i have been shooting the 45-70 for 52 years come Christmas day in about every flavor of gun it is chambered in. my current arms are,1895 GBL, Siamese Mauser,
and the first long gun i ever had, my springfield Trapdoor.
the 45-70 doesn't need to be loaded to 458 speeds to kill or be accurate.
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by rost495
Need me to load something let me know.

Not sure I have 350 grain data but I can snoop around too. LOL.

Jeff
Docrocket lives here in corpus now, so i'll load them at his casa. he set up a out building as a dedicated loading room. Thanks for the offer though Jeff.
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by deerstalker
Originally Posted by stxhunter
FFg? this is a marlin guide gun i'll be loading for.

1895 marlins shoot FFg just fine! you would be surprised at the accuracy using it. the load quoted will kill anything living. only draw back is clean up.
cool just never have heard of it, who makes it?
Posted By: crossfireoops Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
*** shooting those Bearclaw 350 "Piledriver Lite" slugs with the blue lubricant they are delivered wearing ?

*** gas checking em ' ?

GTC

Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
they have gas checks Craig, they came with them. Blue lube yes.
Posted By: rost495 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by stxhunter
Originally Posted by deerstalker
Originally Posted by stxhunter
FFg? this is a marlin guide gun i'll be loading for.

1895 marlins shoot FFg just fine! you would be surprised at the accuracy using it. the load quoted will kill anything living. only draw back is clean up.
cool just never have heard of it, who makes it?


Cool about doc! I guess I just wasn't thinking.

FFg is black powder.... mess to clean up but its fun to shoot, but caustic to the gun if not cleaned with black powder solvent or hot soapy water....
Posted By: EdM Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Roger,

My load in that rifle was 52 gr H4198 pushing the 350 gr Hornady. Is that an LFN or WLN bullet? Have you checked how well it feeds? Rings are going in the mail tomorrow AM.
Posted By: deerstalker Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
go to an shop that sells Muzzle loading supplies.
also for a black powder sub try Jim Shockey's American Pioneer Gold.

just for S and G's i loaded up a case full of IMR 4350 under gummie tips and was amazed at the accuracy, no unburned powder and plenty of velocity.
Posted By: crossfireoops Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Roger, if you don't even know what FG means, I'd say that your safest bet, at this point is to load those gas checked bullets with just about ANY of the smokeless loads that DW put up.

SAVE delving into the mysteries of loading proper black powder ammunition for another time, and (if that Marlin Guide gun's ported) for a different rifle.

That blue lubricant has not performed WAS with BP, in my experience.

If the starting loads show great accuracy, ....just STAY there,....at the lowest Smokeless vels shown, that bullet will kill like the wrath of God.

GTC
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by EdM
Roger,

My load in that rifle was 52 gr H4198 pushing the 350 gr Hornady. Is that an LFN or WLN bullet? Have you checked how well it feeds? Rings are going in the mail tomorrow AM.
Ed its a hard cast bullet, LFN/WLN new terms to me. have only shot factory ammo out of it so far. Cool on the rings, got my scope Sunday.
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by crossfireoops
Roger, if you don't even know what FG means, I'd say that your safest bet, at this point is to load those gas checked bullets with just about ANY of the smokeless loads that DW put up.

SAVE delving into the mysteries of loading proper black powder ammunition for another time, and (if that Marlin Guide gun's ported) for a different rifle.

That blue lubricant has not performed WAS with BP, in my experience.

If the starting loads show great accuracy, ....just STAY there,....at the lowest Smokeless vels shown, that bullet will kill like the wrath of God.

GTC
Thanks, not going to mess with black powder.
Posted By: dale06 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
I shoot a Shiloh sharps 45-70.
My load is 405 grain lead GC over RL-7 powder.
Posted By: EdM Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by stxhunter
Originally Posted by EdM
Roger,

My load in that rifle was 52 gr H4198 pushing the 350 gr Hornady. Is that an LFN or WLN bullet? Have you checked how well it feeds? Rings are going in the mail tomorrow AM.
Ed its a hard cast bullet, LFN/WLN new terms to me. have only shot factory ammo out of it so far. Cool on the rings, got my scope Sunday.


I know them well as they are just a bit from my place in Idaho and I have used their bullets a bunch. WFN is Wide Flat Nose, WLN is Wide Long Nose, you can get into OAL issues with the latter. I suggest you load five without powder and see how they cycle.
Posted By: stxhunter Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
box says WLN.
Posted By: Steelhead Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Think 5744, about 28 grains.

No need to beat the sheit out of yourself with 50grains of powder, cuzz you ain't gonna accomplish anything.

Posted By: viking Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
http://home.earthlink.net/~sharpsshtr/CritterPhotos/SandyHook/SandyHook.html

Interesting article. It might have been discussed here before.
Posted By: 458 Lott Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
I'd start with Reloader 7 as its worked well for me with rounds that have a similar expansion ratio.
Posted By: Ranger_Green Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Thanks guys, as I also have a Guide Gun. If there is another Campfire Hog Hunt in the West, I \will bring it.
Posted By: plainsman456 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Pigs don't like a charge of H-322.
I have played with Trail Boss and it does a good job as well without hammering the shooter.
Posted By: tex_n_cal Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Agree with just about all of the above.

3031, H322, or 4198 are all good powders. Unless you need to kill an escaped rhino 1500-1700 fps should be a fine load and not abusive.

If loading for a tubular magazine, you need a tight bullet fit, and a firm crimp, to keep bullets from setting back in recoil, in the magazine.

What diameter are the Beartooths? they usually offer them in several different sizes.

I'll look to see if I have anything with a shorter nose, suitable for a Guide Gun. My Ruger typically gets pointy bullets smile
Posted By: EthanEdwards Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by tex_n_cal
Agree with just about all of the above.

3031, H322, or 4198 are all good powders. Unless you need to kill an escaped rhino 1500-1700 fps should be a fine load and not abusive.

If loading for a tubular magazine, you need a tight bullet fit, and a firm crimp, to keep bullets from setting back in recoil, in the magazine.

What diameter are the Beartooths? they usually offer them in several different sizes.

I'll look to see if I have anything with a shorter nose, suitable for a Guide Gun. My Ruger typically gets pointy bullets smile
I've used 4895, 3031 and 4198 and never had bad results. I've even used Unique and it was fine, if at lower velocities. I was going to go down to the basement and look at my records, but I've not shot that bullet before. I always loaded 405's that I cast myself. I know my old Lyman manual has three levels...Trapdoor, '86 and Ruger #1. I always used the mid-level loads.

I do use 350 grainers in my 45-75...but that's a different animal.
Posted By: DigitalDan Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
500 grains, paper patch it and a healthy dose of RX7.

Thump


Posted By: tikkanut Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16

http://www.reloadammo.com/4570load.htm
Posted By: tex_n_cal Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
I do have a box of the Hornady FTX 325gr, which have a soft pointed tip and are suitable for a Marlin. PM me if you want them. I have some Cast Performance 405gr but they are also WLNGC and may not work in your Marlin.

Posted By: Armednfree Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
On the powder, I've found H322 best all around in the 45 70. I use it for 325's and 400's, don't see any reason it wouldn't work as well with 350's. Now why I don't see it listed for 350's I don't know, it is listed for 325's and 400's.
Posted By: duck911 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
H322 and Trailboss are my two 45-70 powders.
Posted By: Vic_in_Va Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Quote
WFN is Wide Flat Nose, WLN is Wide Long Nose, you can get into OAL issues with the latter. I suggest you load five without powder and see how they cycle.


Good point.

The crimp groove on the Piledriver series of bullets is placed with the Marlin 95 in mind. I've used these bullets pretty extensively in my Guide gun. They are in (advertised as) 350, 425, and 525 grain weights, and firmly crimped, they feed well in my rifle, typically OAL being just under 2.55". My chamber can accommodate an OAL of 2.570", but that length won't feed well.

I've had the best luck with IMR4198 and H322 with the lighter bullets, H322 having very good accuracy and consistency.

I tried light loads with H4198, but it was very inconsistent, IMR4198 seemed to work better.

H322, IMR4198, IMR4895, AA2495, and IMR3031 work good with the heavier ones, and though the slower powders display some tendency to burn dirty, accuracy does not seem to be affected. Some of the loads I tried were real thumpers.

I used .460" diameter bullets.

The list of suitable powders is pretty extensive in that case, and loads can run from fairly fun to shoot to downright painful.

Posted By: deerstalker Re: 45-70 loads - 12/05/16
Originally Posted by DigitalDan
500 grains, paper patch it and a healthy dose of RX7.

Thump



Dan , can you get OAL short enough for the Marlin with those 500's?
i just now cast some Lyman 457125's and am going to use them in the Mauser. they are LONG.
Posted By: curdog4570 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/06/16
Originally Posted by tex_n_cal
I do have a box of the Hornady FTX 325gr, which have a soft pointed tip and are suitable for a Marlin. PM me if you want them. I have some Cast Performance 405gr but they are also WLNGC and may not work in your Marlin.



Those Flex Tip Hornadys don't load right except in a 450 Marlin case which is 1/10 inch shorter than 45 70 case.I bought some and had to send them back.

Look for a p m Roger.
Posted By: DigitalDan Re: 45-70 loads - 12/06/16
Originally Posted by deerstalker
Originally Posted by DigitalDan
500 grains, paper patch it and a healthy dose of RX7.

Thump



Dan , can you get OAL short enough for the Marlin with those 500's?
i just now cast some Lyman 457125's and am going to use them in the Mauser. they are LONG.


Indeed. The reference I made was used in a Marlin 1895 CB with MOA precision. The lever gun platform requires a short radius nose form to function properly.

[Linked Image]

With smokeless I've had better luck with a flat base rather than cup base....and a card wad helps. Don't twist the tail...cut the patch to allow for about 1/8" overlap on the base and fold it over. Smooth sided patch bullets provide a lot of wiggle room for seating depth...

Brooks Moulds is a good place to start looking.
Posted By: Armednfree Re: 45-70 loads - 12/06/16
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Originally Posted by tex_n_cal
I do have a box of the Hornady FTX 325gr, which have a soft pointed tip and are suitable for a Marlin. PM me if you want them. I have some Cast Performance 405gr but they are also WLNGC and may not work in your Marlin.



Those Flex Tip Hornadys don't load right except in a 450 Marlin case which is 1/10 inch shorter than 45 70 case.I bought some and had to send them back.

Look for a p m Roger.


You have to turn the case down to 2.040 and trim a bit off the bottom of the seating die. Not a problem, I did that on my belt sander.

I've personally killed or seen killed three deer with that bullet. Devastating internal damage, two bang flops and a 20 yard run.

First one was a doe at 45 yards, between the shoulder and the neck mushing the chest cavity and stopping in the off side hip. Bang Flop. Second one was a buck at 90 yards up hill quartering away. Entered just ahead of the last rib and came out ahead of the shoulder. That deer kicked about 20 yards and dropped dead. Third one was broadside 1/3rd the way up from the bottom, hit part of the heart, again a bang flop.
Posted By: cra1948 Re: 45-70 loads - 12/06/16
Wow! You guys get pretty complicated about the whole thing. Looks like fun and maybe someday I'll join in. But for now....I've used the same load in my Guide Gun (and those of 2 friends) for about 20 years now: 400 grain Speer flat nose over 54 or 55 grains of Varget in Starline cases with CCI 200 primers. It's not what I'd call a pleasant load to shoot, but I don't shoot it that much. It does shoot flat enough that, with a 100 yard zero, the POI is pretty close to the point of the bottom coarse section of my duplex reticle at 200 yards (1-4 Leupold Shotgun-Muzzle Loader scope with coarse duplex reticle) with the scope at 4X. It has killed a lot of deer very dead.
Posted By: tex_n_cal Re: 45-70 loads - 12/06/16
The .45-70 is seldom a mistake, in any case. smile
© 24hourcampfire