I hope they don't suck. Just got my wife and i each one for Christmas as I am tired of big Agnes pads going flat after only a few trips while our neo airs have lasted 5+ years. The big Agnes warranty isn't worth much when its going flat on day one of a fly out hunt.
I've had the down mats and syn mats , and I do think they are more comfy than the Neo. i have not had any problems with them so far, but I am real careful with air pads ...since I had some BA pads go flat on me in canyonlands a few years ago. Sleeping on slick rock , in the spring with a pad that wont hold air isn't a lot of fun. That trip alone, means most of the time I am taking a CCF back up on most trips.