I like the Springfield XD, but my 45 XD doesn't like to feed right with all ammo after I put more than 9 rounds in it.

What 40 cal. pistol (aside from a Glock) should I be checking out?

Spot

SIG P226, XD, the new pistol from FN, S&W MP 40
Those would be my short list for the .40S&W, in descending order

How many differnt models of P226 are there 16 ? !!!

Which one would you say is best if any.

Taurus 24/7 short slide

Why no Glocks? Does the boring monotony of a bang every time you squeeze the trigger just leave you cold?

Before I leave the house every day there is a Glock .40, 9mm or 10mm and spare BBs on my side.

SIG 229s are also quite dependable and accurate though they need more maintenance and must be kept very wet to run well.

Hear M&Ps are running well, but no personal experience.

Of the modern type, I think the all around best is the Smith & Wesson M&P series. If you want the best all around, you need to look at an older design, i.e., the Browning High Power. That was designed in the days before lawyers were part of the design teams behind handgun development.

BHP or CZ75B or 1911

Sig, Sig, or Sig.........take your pick. Try a P220 and you might not even think about a .40 S&W....

XD-M

I only have a lowly Sigma 40VE-but it is my favorite .40 s&w.
Serves it's purpose well.

I am leaning toward the Beretta PX4 Storm. Had an XD-40 and sold it -- liked it a lot. Had a Browning Hi-Power in 40 and did not care for it -- sold it too. Might consider the FNP-40 if I do not get the Beretta. Had a Sig 2022 in 357 Sig, liked it but too much muzzle flip. Don't care for a buddy's Sig P229 in 40. Handguns are very personal things. About the only handgun I am truly satisfied with is a Colt Peacemaker or a Colt 1911. I am willing to give the PX4 Storm a try. Best advice I can give you is get what you like, and don't worry about what everyone else likes. Handgun has to work for you.

I have all of these, and my order of preference is
S&W M&P
XD-M
XD
Sig 229 (probably #1 if I wasn't left handed)
H&K P2000
Sig 2022

Again, just my preferences, I really think you need to go handle all of them, and maybe shoot them to make your own opinion.

If you want to conceal it, look at the Kahr MK40. I have one and it is tiny but heavy enough to shoot well -accurate for category - dependable and built like a tank. Smooth trigger. I love mine.

Wow! How did I forget about the Kahr. I have the P-9, and I'm sure the P-40 would be a dandy too.

My XD works fine in 45acp and it would probably be my choice in a 40.

A couple quick comments about the tiny Kahr guns. Most of the complaints I have seen have to do with the polymer models. I would want to shoot the polymer model S&W .40 (PM40) to see if the recoil is tolerable as it is quite a bit lighter. The steel gun (MK40) is very tolerable to shoot, IMO.

What are the major difference between the Sigma and the M&P?

G23

The M&P is an updated sigma. but the changes are many, different frame, with removable/changeable backstraps, a mag release that lets you change from left to right hand,stainless steel slide with black melonite coating, rail for mounting lights or lazers. You can get it in more calibers, and even with or without manual thumb safety, magazine disconnect, night sights, full size or compact.

The sigma comes in 9 or 40cal, a couple of different color frames, blued or stainless slide and that's about it. Feels very cheap in my hand.

get a xd40 subcompact, i really like mine. i put the laser/flashlight on mine

The 40 caliber XD has worked well for me for several years. It is my favorite polymer framed pistol.

these are all fair and good points noted above, but I must add that the ergonomics for the Sigma are actually excellent even when compared to a couple of Sig-Sauers, Beretta 92 Brig & 3rd series S&Ws that I also own and like. Most feed back from owners is positive on the Sigma VE series. It is a less costly option with a very heavy double action trigger that takes some getting used to, but it also helps you to become a better shooter, and with use the trigger gets very smooth-not really lighter but certainly nice and smooth. Trigger is not good as a Glock's for sure, but even so it is certainly worth a look and if the sights are lined it will shoot point of aim for me always. Mine has fired lots of practice ammo without any trouble and it favors the 180 hollow points by Rem. I Think I will get a olive drab 9mm (9GVE) in the future.
Best-MC

A Browning Hi-Power in .40 cal. is a GEM. Others may be smaller for carry ... but this slim-profile pistol DOES carry well.

That aside, it is such a great pistol, for what it IS ... I would forever keep mine over most all of my other 24 or so handguns.

New to the forum.

Love my Sigs (have a 229 in .40) but I have to say that my XD Tactical .40 is a little more accurate. I seems that I like the Sig better in dry fire practice but the XD outshoots it on paper. I seem to find myself gravitating more to 9mm and .45 Auto, and see more of both in my future before anymore 40s

I can't believe all the people mentioning all the DAO pistols, I know they are the rage, from now on my pistols will have an exposed hammer, so they can be fired SA, which means in most cases the guns will have a very nice trigger. a 6# trigger in a hand gun is not condusive to accuracy. CZ 75, browning HP

PLUS 1:

I like "hammers" on my pistols also ...

Glock. Then the XD 40. I have a XD 45 tactical and an XD 40 subcompact. No problem with either. Both have been flawless.

Browning does make a nice pistol though.

My full size S&W M&P is nice, but my G23 is my favorite. Also I have a G22 that I just bought, but the jury is still out on it.

Ron

BTW speaking of DAO pistols I had an XD 40 that I could not hit the broadside of a barn with, strangely one of the more accurate pistols I have ever shot is my little LCP.

Which model in specific?

For the hammer guys... Any thoughts on the CZ P07?

That works!

While I very much appreciate the single action autos, there is much to be said for a good double action only auto pistol too, such as the Kahr. If you cut your teeth on double action revolvers, you will have no problem quickly mastering this trigger, and getting combat accuracy from it.

I've been real happy with my CZ-75B in 40 S&W. For a concealable package the old, discontinued Firestar is hard to beat. Pity they quit making them.

sig 239

Years ago I shot a Beretta Cougar (Eye-talian version, not the current Stoeger Turkish gun) in 40 and thought it was about the sweetest-shooting semi I had ever fired. I don't have .40s so I never bought one but have considered getting a 9mm at some point.