Home
Posted By: Uncle_Fester Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/15/14
Subject line says it all.....I'm interested in finding a light-weight Commander (true Commander length 4.25" slide). I believe Para makes ones, but others?
Posted By: iblong Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/15/14
Colt,Kimber,Springfield,Ria,Brown,Wilson ect.
Sig C3 is a lightweight Commander. I carry one everyday.
S&W PC Commander.....

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: UPhiker Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/15/14
Originally Posted by iblong
Colt,Kimber,Springfield,Ria,Brown,Wilson ect.
Kimbers and Springfields are 4in, not 4.25.

I'm loving this little pistol..

[Linked Image]
Originally Posted by UPhiker
Originally Posted by iblong
Colt,Kimber,Springfield,Ria,Brown,Wilson ect.
Kimbers and Springfields are 4in, not 4.25.


As are Wilson, & besides, they all have bull barrels without a bushing...........none of the bushing-less guns qualify, IMO.

On the high-end side, Guncrafters, Christensen Arms, & Nighthawk all make true 4.25", bushing-barrelled LWT guns.

MM
Posted By: bea175 Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by Uncle_Fester
Subject line says it all.....I'm interested in finding a light-weight Commander (true Commander length 4.25" slide). I believe Para makes ones, but others?


My Springfield Light Weight Champion 45 ACP

[Linked Image]
Here's my favorite LW Commander and every day carry gun for the last 5 years.
It's a Kimber Custom Shop Super Carry Pro with the round butt frame & Night Sights.
Uber Accurate & Super Reliable. I think they run about $1300 new nowadays.

[Linked Image]
Posted By: MIVHNTR Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Colt. If it's not a Colt, it's a copy.
My Colt XSE LWT Commander.

[Linked Image]
Posted By: HawkI Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by MIVHNTR
Colt. If it's not a Colt, it's a copy.
My Colt XSE LWT Commander.

[Linked Image]


Even if they have hobbles, its still THE Commander....
That's not a true Commander 4.25", is it?
Originally Posted by MontanaMan
As are Wilson, & besides, they all have bull barrels without a bushing...........none of the bushing-less guns qualify, IMO.

On the high-end side, Guncrafters, Christensen Arms, & Nighthawk all make true 4.25", bushing-barrelled LWT guns.

MM



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?
Posted By: dla Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by MIVHNTR
Colt. If it's not a Colt, it's a copy.


Or maybe its an improvement.
Posted By: dla Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by Reloder28



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?


Nothing. No difference. But to some there is some sort of mystic quality to the original Colt design.
Posted By: Savuti Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by dla
Originally Posted by Reloder28



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?


Nothing. No difference. But to some there is some sort of mystic quality to the original BROWNING design.


Fixed it for you.
Originally Posted by dla
Originally Posted by MIVHNTR
Colt. If it's not a Colt, it's a copy.


Or maybe its an improvement.


Couldn't have said it better myself.

Most people tend to disagree when I say I can't appreciate Colt anything.
Posted By: dla Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/16/14
Originally Posted by Savuti
Originally Posted by dla
Originally Posted by Reloder28



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?


Nothing. No difference. But to some there is some sort of mystic quality to the original BROWNING design.


Fixed it for you.
Hardly. You're trying to tell us that John Browning, who was long dead (died in 1926), designed a 4.25" barrel, aluminum-framed pistol for sale in the 1950's?

Lots of people make commander-sized 1911s. My current favorite is the Dan Wesson Guardian.

[Linked Image]
Originally Posted by Reloder28
Originally Posted by MontanaMan
As are Wilson, & besides, they all have bull barrels without a bushing...........none of the bushing-less guns qualify, IMO.

On the high-end side, Guncrafters, Christensen Arms, & Nighthawk all make true 4.25", bushing-barrelled LWT guns.

MM



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?


I don't think that there's anything "wrong" with it, but it's not a pure 1911 design, absent the barrel bushing & I do believe the OP was referring to a standard 1911 design with his question & comment re: a 4.25" barrel.

They will work just fine in most cases & about the only thing that could happen is that the slide & cone area is a little harder to fit up than a bushing & now you have a different wear part. If accuracy isn't what you want & you can attribute it to the barrel fit, it may not be an easy thing to correct.

The biggest issue for me personally, is that the bushing-less guns are a royal PIA to disassemble when compared to the standard gun with a barrel bushing.

MM
Les Baer Commanche Monolith:
[Linked Image]


S&W Scandium:

[Linked Image]
That Les Baer Commanche is the best Commander made, IMO.

You can spend a lot more money for a Wilson, a Nighthawk, or Ed Brown Custom, but I personally don't think you can get a better gun for the money !
Baer also makes the Stinger, which is their version of the CCO (Commander slide on an officer's frame).
Posted By: DMc Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/17/14
Caspian; carbon steel, stainless, aluminum or titanium:

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]


smile
DMc
Posted By: RJM Re: Who makes a LW Commander? - 09/18/14
Originally Posted by Reloder28
Originally Posted by MontanaMan
As are Wilson, & besides, they all have bull barrels without a bushing...........none of the bushing-less guns qualify, IMO.

On the high-end side, Guncrafters, Christensen Arms, & Nighthawk all make true 4.25", bushing-barrelled LWT guns.

MM



Going to show my ignorance here. What is sub-par about a bushing-less gun as long as it is accurate?



..simple word...balance. The bullbarrel makes a nice light in the hand Commander muzzle heavy...

Although all my Commanders are Colts, I have shot huntsman's S&W and a lot of others and can only say find the one that floats your boat and buy it...

Bob
© 24hourcampfire