We don't run in the same circles, but I've hunted a couple of times with Joe Coogan. My take on him is that he is a very knowledgeable, nice guy. He's the calm kind of fella; the type that you'd want to have with you when you have a bad elk (on the side or in the bottom <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/help.gif" alt="" /> of a steep canyon). I feel, instinctively, that he would hold up his end and would do a Hell of a lot more than just wring his hands and hold legs. In case anyone is wondering, this is very high praise from an old elk hunter who has chased the damned things for almost 50 years (that would be me) <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif" alt="" />.
On one hunt, Jim Carmichel and I were cleaning our rifle barrels after a particularly great morning of hunting prairie dogs in Colorado. Our .223 rifle barrels had 400 or rounds through them and we were cleaning them, whether they needed it or not. Joe wandered up to us and freely admitted that he had a lot to learn about cleaning barrels and wanted us to teach him how to do it properly. I was impressed that a noted hunting writer was so open to learning. That says volumes about the man.
I highly suspect that when Joe writes about something, he knows the subject very well. By "knows the subject," I mean that he has learned from his vast experience in the bush......not by simply reading the words of dead men.
From what little I've seen of Joe, I can honestly say that I very much like the man.
Having said that, and having killed fifty-plus Afrikan critters, I'd have to say that I would not take a .243 Winchester on safari. Yeah, the .243 is probably just fine for game up to, say, impala. But what if a really great kudu or eland shows up? You're screwed.
All of my Afrikan hunting has been on eland and smaller animals and I've never found the .30-'06 lacking. The eland I shot on my last safari was hauled out....guts, feathers and all. The eland weighed 1069 Kg (2,352 pounds) at the butchery. A single 180-grain Hornady SPBT flipped him on his back and killed him with nary a wiggle. For Seyfriend fans; the expanded boat-tail bullet crushed three vertabrae and came to rest after penetrating well over three-feet of eland.....bullet core in the jacket.
I've attached a photo of the eland. I am six-feet tall and notice that the eland is taller than I am, while his rear quarters are still on the ground. His heart was delicious and I ate part of his liver raw.
In the future, I plan to hunt for cape buffalo and, probably elephant. At that time, I will carefully look at getting a .375 H&H.....and no bigger. I've shot .416s and, truth be known, I'm simply not man enough.
Steve