That buck will go closer to 60ish than 50 any day. He would be close to P&Y, but not make it, could if his mass and length are misleading in that pic.
Depending on the area he may well be very mature and conditions dictated his horn growth for this year.
A better angle of pic would also be helpful with getting a better look at his curl. If the curl goes in as well as back he may be a little longer than first look. Horns that curl back need to be seen from the side as well as front to judge them . The bases can be seen and compared to the eye in that pic though.
My main consideration is if a buck is mature or not, he looks mature but no pot belly or long nose. I would let him walk based on that and opt for a nice mature doe instead, one with neat little horns.
Whatever you decide it's your decision and he would be a fine harvest.
Some folks actually get their animals scored as a homage to it , not themselves. Your paint brush is way too large szihn. Funny how you got God and boobs into your reply.
