I shot the Shield Plus, Hellcat, and P365XL side by side yesterday. The Hellcat feels better in my hand than the Shield Plus, but the S+ is more comfortable to shoot. The Hellcat is pretty snappy!

This was my first time firing the Sig, but it seems to be the best of both worlds...feels great in the hand, like the Hellcat, and shoots soft like the Shield Plus.

I don't see how a person could go wrong with any of them, to be honest. They are all really nice for their intended purpose.


Thoroughly enjoying Alaska since 2001.