short answer is find an older marlin. the rossi's i have handled look like they were made in china. they may shoot ok, but the looks and workmanship turn me off. the newer marlins are a bit better but have been plagued with problems such that i would not buy one. there are plenty of JM 1895G's on gunbroker. they cost a bit more these days but are worth it. i have had one since 2000 and it is an awesome gun. the 18" barrel is plenty for the 45-70 round.
