24hourcampfire.com
24hourcampfire.com
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Hop To
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,871
R
Campfire Tracker
OP Offline
Campfire Tracker
R
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,871
For those that have used both of these rimfire cartridges shot out of rifles on game/varmints, which do you think has the edge in killing power?

Thanks, RS

BP-B2

Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 129
A
Campfire Member
Offline
Campfire Member
A
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 129
I've had a few of both and prefer the hmr. Not sure I've noticed a big difference in killing power, but I definitely noticed a difference in accuracy. Seems every hmr I've had has been a tackdriver out to 125-150 yards. Every 22mag has been ok to about 50 yards then the groups open up tremendously after that. Only reason I'd go for a 22mag now would be if I needed a heavier bullet for close-in larger game.

Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 47,713
B
Campfire 'Bwana
Offline
Campfire 'Bwana
B
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 47,713
Oh no, not this chit again.... eek


Originally Posted by raybass
I try to stick with the basics, they do so well. Nothing fancy mind you, just plain jane will get it done with style.
Originally Posted by Pharmseller
You want to see an animal drop right now? Shoot him in the ear hole.

BSA MAGA
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 8,179
P
Campfire Outfitter
Offline
Campfire Outfitter
P
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 8,179
is it popcorn and soda pop time again ?


LIFE NRA , we vote Red up here, Norseman
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 492
M
Campfire Member
Offline
Campfire Member
M
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 492
Only experience are with crows and prairie dogs and my vote is the hmr. Night and day difference on them little critters.

IC B2

Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 74
O
Campfire Greenhorn
Offline
Campfire Greenhorn
O
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 74
If I were going to limit my shots to 50-75 yds the .22 Magnum is a pretty good bone cruncher,but the accuracy of the .17 HMR along with the added velocity makes it a better choice past that range, just plan on head shots past 100 yds.

My best with the .22 was 125yds, with the .17 it was 238yds according to the rangefinder, with an intentional head shot.


Youthful enthusiasm is replaced by old age and treachery!
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 26,280
Campfire Ranger
Online Content
Campfire Ranger
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 26,280
Next time you get a chance fill two 1 gallon milk jugs up with water. Shoot one with a 17 HMR at 100 yards and one with a 40 gr JSP 22 magnum at 100 yards. See if that influences your thoughts about penetration, disruption and power.

Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 36,822
D
Campfire 'Bwana
Offline
Campfire 'Bwana
D
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 36,822
Both kill hogs with FMJ slugs. I have both. The .17 HMR is an Annie 1717. The .22 WMR is a Browning T-Bolt synthetic. The T-Bolt is lighter and handier. The Annie more accurate. Knocking around, I’m more likely to be packing the Browning. I don’t shoot the Annie that much. Too many other projects. But it is a great rifle, fun to shoot. Not quite up to Annie accuracy, the Browning is no slouch.

DF

Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 21,125
J
Campfire Ranger
Offline
Campfire Ranger
J
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 21,125
22 mag hands down. Tweety birds or prairie dogs it’s a wash. Shot piles of coons, possum and skunks with both, along with some coyotes, 17 has never impressed me


Ping pong balls for the win.
Once you've wrestled everything else in life is easy. Dan Gable
I keep my circle small, I’d rather have 4 quarters than 100 pennies.

Ain’t easy havin pals.
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
Campfire Ranger
Offline
Campfire Ranger
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
22 mag for bigger, thick skulled varmints. For distance 17 hmr. Easy killing at 200 and some more yards with the hmr on small, furry, or feathered creatures. 😎


Curiosity Killed the Cat & The Prairie Dog
“Molon Labe”
IC B3

Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 1,513
D
Campfire Regular
Offline
Campfire Regular
D
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 1,513
17 WSM might be worth tryin if you want the most powerful commonly available rimfire.

I got a Marlin 783 22 mag with a little 1-4x20 on it for fast action and short range thump. Wouldn't mind a lever, pump or auto in 22 mag though.
I'm sure the 17HMR trumps it for small critters at extended range, and is probably a bit quieter to shoot.
But I made my choice and lucked into a bunch of 22 mag ammo on sale.
17 HMR ammo seems to always be available though, even when the 22LR and 22mag was in short supply. So that might be something to consider.

Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
Campfire Ranger
Offline
Campfire Ranger
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
If you want to step up the fun meter. Look at a Ruger 77/17 in 17 WSM. Ammo is the same price as 17 hmr. The Ruger feels like an full size rifle in your paws, and you’re now lazering shots out to 250 plus in low-no wind.

Pat has one and the groups we have compared are ridiculous. Savage makes a 17 WSM but it appears to be almost junk like with its unusual bolt system.

I only looked at the Savage, never shot one. A lot of owners have given the Savage mixed reviews with too many being negative. YMMV

😎


Curiosity Killed the Cat & The Prairie Dog
“Molon Labe”
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
Campfire Ranger
Offline
Campfire Ranger
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 23,506
Good job....I was typing, didn’t see your post. 😎


Curiosity Killed the Cat & The Prairie Dog
“Molon Labe”
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 1,513
D
Campfire Regular
Offline
Campfire Regular
D
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 1,513
Originally Posted by Beaver10
Good job....I was typing, didn’t see your post. 😎

Yours is a better description of what you get with the WSM. Definitely would be the way I'd go if I wanted to try another rimfire. Probably would've already went there if it was a 20WSM slingin 30-ish grain pills.

Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 12,491
R
Campfire Outfitter
Offline
Campfire Outfitter
R
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 12,491
On prairie dogs and crows, I'd prefer the .17HMR, it's just easier to hit with. On coons, groundhogs and such things, I'd rather have the .22WMR. I've killed coons and groundhogs with the HMR, but they don't kill as cleanly as I'd like them to kill things that size.


You can roll a turd in peanuts, dip it in chocolate, and it still ain't no damn Baby Ruth.
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 74
O
Campfire Greenhorn
Offline
Campfire Greenhorn
O
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 74
Originally Posted by PaulBarnard
Next time you get a chance fill two 1 gallon milk jugs up with water. Shoot one with a 17 HMR at 100 yards and one with a 40 gr JSP 22 magnum at 100 yards. See if that influences your thoughts about penetration, disruption and power.



Groundhogs ain't milk jugs, and I perfer to judge it by the groundhogs reaction to it, A 30.06 and a 22/250 have similar milkjug explosions at 200 yds,(yes Sir I have tried it before), but at that range the deer knows the difference, too. I'll stay with my previous observation.


Youthful enthusiasm is replaced by old age and treachery!
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 32,029
Campfire 'Bwana
Offline
Campfire 'Bwana
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 32,029
[quote=RipSnort]For those that have used both of these rimfire cartridges shot out of rifles on game/varmints, which do you think has the edge in killing power?


Under 5 lbs., I prefer the .17 HMR.

Over 5 lbs., I prefer the .22 Mag.

I shoot called 'cats at close range, sometimes as little as 10', with a Remington 597 in .22 Mag. I don't know if I'd do the same with the .17 HMR.

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 24,338
7
Campfire Ranger
Offline
Campfire Ranger
7
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 24,338
Side by side on Whistle pigs (small ground squirrels) the 22 Mag had more instant kills and fewer flip flops.

Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 8,410
T
Campfire Outfitter
Offline
Campfire Outfitter
T
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 8,410
Originally Posted by RipSnort
For those that have used both of these rimfire cartridges shot out of rifles on game/varmints, which do you think has the edge in killing power?


I don't know exactly what you intend to mean by killing power. I can tell you that .22 magnum hits harder if it hits at all. The flatter trajectory gives the HMR more reach. The .22 mag hits harder within its reach. There is no argument with 50% to 100% .. or more .. greater bullet weight ... as long as you hit what you're aiming at. Second factor .. I have not owned any .22 mags as accurate as my HMR.

I've owned 3 relatively decent .22 mags. The first would hold about 1.25 to 1.5 inches at 100 yards. That was a Win 61 magnum back when the only ammo I could find was WW or CCI, both 40 grain JHP loads. The other two, a Ruger 77/22 boat paddle and a Win 9422 mag, both would stay between 1 and 1.25 inches at 100 yards with CCI Maxi Mag +V ammo.

I'll take the HMR for smaller rodents .. up to ground squirrels, maybe a bit bigger. For jackrabbits or even coyotes, .22 mag all the way. Stay with 40s, or the 50 grain Federal load, and though it may not be legal, used carefully, it's pretty effective even on deer. Don't ask how I know, I'll leave it to your imagination.

Tom


Anyone who thinks there's two sides to everything hasn't met a M�bius strip.

Here be dragons ...
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,391
Campfire Regular
Offline
Campfire Regular
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,391
I like 22Mag, one friend shoots the HMR. We've clobbered groundsquirrels and the splat factor is about identical. But the mag does have more power, it just does. My gun likes Win. 40JHP and chews ragged hole after ragged hole at 50yds. I'll mostly use the 17AH now, even on squirrels, and it just flat blows the crap out of them.

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Moderated by  RickBin 

Link Copied to Clipboard
YB23

Who's Online Now
510 members (007FJ, 10gaugeman, 17CalFan, 160user, 10ring1, 1lesfox, 49 invisible), 2,246 guests, and 1,023 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums81
Topics1,187,596
Posts18,398,171
Members73,815
Most Online11,491
Jul 7th, 2023


 







Fish & Game Departments | Solunar Tables | Mission Statement | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | DMCA
Hunting | Fishing | Camping | Backpacking | Reloading | Campfire Forums | Gear Shop
Copyright © 2000-2024 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5
(Release build 20201027)
Responsive Width:

PHP: 7.3.33 Page Time: 0.116s Queries: 15 (0.003s) Memory: 0.8959 MB (Peak: 1.0458 MB) Data Comp: Zlib Server Time: 2024-03-28 12:23:41 UTC
Valid HTML 5 and Valid CSS