Actually, what really gives me a thrill is the thought of Cape Buffalo. I don't think I'd get a thrill over killing Dumbo, but the thought of shooting the mighty Buff does click my clock. But if I do I want nothing smaller than a .458 Win. if not something larger.
I have shot 3 of each. There is no comparison. A buff is simply a big cow unless you screw up and hit him badly. Then it’s your own fault if the follow up gets dicey. An elephant, generally shot inside 25-30 yards and often much closer is a whole different kettle of fish. Wounded buff generally run off, then charge on the follow up. A wounded elephant(you missed the brain) may run but is just as likely to charge from VERY close range. There is simply nothing as exciting as working in close on a group of elephants and braining him. It gets really tense if his companions decide to take offense......As an aside, I have used .375 H&H on all 6 with no problems. It’s not the bore size or ft.lbs. of energy that matters, it’s bullet placement.