I'm 5 days into our firearms season and I've seen 3 dinks and a few does and fawns. We've got 24" of snow on the ground making it a bitch to even get to any of my stands, and we've got neighbors drawing away deer with illegal bait piles, cutting deer travel to a fraction of what is normal here.
Fugg yes I'd shoot that thing. I'd probably even waste a finishing shot just because I sure as heck don't want to track (or drag) one in this mess, but straight answer - I'd probably shoot it even in good conditions and with normal deer movement. It has more potential, but it's a very respectable buck as it is.