A couple years ago my wife shot this one. He has the bases of a big old buck but everything up above his brows is stunted. He was big bodied, had the most worn teeth I’ve ever seen on a deer, and stunk like an old Billy goat.
And we have a place about 15 miles from where that one came from that about 25 percent of the bucks grow one normal antler and the other will just be a nub. Neighbor killed one years ago that had 9 points on one huge side and a knob about like the last 3” of a shovel handle on the other. Been that way for years out there. I shot this one last fall with my bow. The short side isn’t broken, just grew that way.