Home
Posted By: goalie Crossbow - 09/09/23
So, after finally getting a crossbow permit approved by the DNR in March, the law was changed and now they're legal during archery season without the disability permit.

I'm loving mine, but my son likes it as well. I didn't realize they were so accurate with a probably adjusted speed dial scope.

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: jackmountain Re: Crossbow - 09/09/23
What did you buy? Couple of my guys bought Ravin and Ten Points. I had no idea how expensive they could get. Accuracy at 60yds is unreal.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/09/23
I went with an Excalibur Bulldog 330 that I got used. I wasn't a fan of the scope that was on it, and am glad I got a Vortex for it.

With the Excalibur crossbow you can change strings and adjust brace height at home easily.
Posted By: jackmountain Re: Crossbow - 09/09/23
I’m actually considering one, rotator cuff is trashed.
Hate missing the opportunities that our 4 weeks if early season in Oct presents.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
I'm liking the simplicity of the Excalibur. It'll be a hunting machine.
Posted By: johna1 Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Just wait until your first deer with one.

They are more efficient than a rifle.
Posted By: 44mc Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
i have bohunted since i was 10 legal or not at that age and it was with a recurve ,then in the early 70`s i used a compound from the start of those years to now at 70 years of age with poor physical strength and a bad shoulder that the surgeon wanted to replace 4 years ago that i don`t want to , i already have had surgery in both shoulders so my body is a mess . > here is what i see is a negative thing that might happen to us handi cap and old bowhunters = Minnesota the state i live in the DNR is following who kills a deer with a x- bow during the archery season this year and probably even more in the future so myself and other handi cap old bowhunters will end up with the same law/rules for all x-bow archery hunters if it gets changed . i think x-bows are fine in the archery for all but there are plenty archery hunter selfish whiners out there that will try and change this law about x-bows in Minnesota, i hope it don`t happen but if it does i sure hope they leave the handi-cap old bowhunters alone in the archery season. Montana is one state that has a lot of whining selfish bowhunters with plenty butt hurt against handi-cap x-bow hunters during the archery season even on Federal land in Montana x-bows are not legal . so i hope Minnesota does not do this bowhunter butt hurt chit to x-bow archery hunters, at least not for the handi cap and old.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Um, they already changed the law in Minnesota to allow crossbow use in archery season by anyone.

Are you concerned that they'll stop letting you use a crossbow?
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

Lots of crossbow scopes do that. I zero'd my Vortex at 40 yards, then shot at 80, and adjusted the power ring/speed dial until POA=POI there, and verified at 20, 30, and 50. The reticle isn't too busy, and I like the illumination.

It was nuts on. I want too check it at 100 next time I'm out.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

this is B. S. ever shoot a x-bow free hand at 50 yds. ? myself i was always much more accurate with my compound bow when i was healthy than with a x-bow free hand. so if you feel you can shoot that x-bow so accurate at 50 yds. free hand come to my place and if you can out shoot my son and his compound bow at 50 yards 5 shots each i will hand you a $100.00 bill. you loose you hand my son the $100.00 bill , i will post the results on 24 hr. Campfire. so some weekend let me know if want to do this , Pete53
Posted By: mibowhunter Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Where did anyone mention shooting free hand with an x-bow ? Did I over look it ?
Posted By: Blackheart Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

Lots of crossbow scopes do that. I zero'd my Vortex at 40 yards, then shot at 80, and adjusted the power ring/speed dial until POA=POI there, and verified at 20, 30, and 50. The reticle isn't too busy, and I like the illumination.

It was nuts on. I want too check it at 100 next time I'm out.
I love my Vortex Crossfire crossbow scope. Like I said in the optics forum, it works as advertised. Been using it for the last two seasons and have filled all of my archery tags.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by mibowhunter
Where did anyone mention shooting free hand with an x-bow ? Did I over look it ?

No.

It's apparently an "old man yells at clouds" moment.
Posted By: WStrayer Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Get yourself some heavy shafts and broadhead. You don't lose much speed but the extra momentum is really noticeable. Helps with noise and vibration as well. Vibration is hard on the bows and eventually takes it's toll on their lifespan. I have a Matrix 380 for late season and shoot a 500 grain bolt.
Posted By: bbassi Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

Lots of crossbow scopes do that. I zero'd my Vortex at 40 yards, then shot at 80, and adjusted the power ring/speed dial until POA=POI there, and verified at 20, 30, and 50. The reticle isn't too busy, and I like the illumination.

It was nuts on. I want too check it at 100 next time I'm out.

Shoot what makes you happy, but this statement is why many bowhunters resist including crossbows in "primative" or "restrictive" seasons. It's not bowhunting. it's rifle hunting without powder.
Posted By: Blackheart Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by bbassi
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

Lots of crossbow scopes do that. I zero'd my Vortex at 40 yards, then shot at 80, and adjusted the power ring/speed dial until POA=POI there, and verified at 20, 30, and 50. The reticle isn't too busy, and I like the illumination.

It was nuts on. I want too check it at 100 next time I'm out.

Shoot what makes you happy, but this statement is why many bowhunters resist including crossbows in "primative" or "restrictive" seasons. It's not bowhunting. it's rifle hunting without powder.
Like so many of those who hunt the muzzleloader seasons are still using iron sighted side locks ? Those compound shooters should STFU. If you're smart you'll restrict your shots with a crossbow to 40 yards. They're loud and still not fast enough so deer can't jump string.
Posted By: 44mc Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
shooting your xbow for fun has nothing to do with hunting get off your high horse. I did not say any thing about free hand or hunting . pete I have nocked bolts together at 50yards free hand before
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
Originally Posted by bbassi
Shoot what makes you happy, but this statement is why many bowhunters resist including crossbows in "primative" or "restrictive" seasons. It's not bowhunting. it's rifle hunting without powder.

I can't shoot a bow enough to be confident hunting with one due to shoulder issues. If I do, I'll need another surgery rather quickly.

So, due to crossbow being legal, during archery season I'll finally be back hunting. I self limit distances due to deer jumping the string, and don't really GAF what others do or don't do. I don't look down on guys that shoot deer at 300+ yards with a rifle just because I've almost put powder burns on one with my 44mag.....
Posted By: Bwana_1 Re: Crossbow - 09/10/23
And if you're shooting expandable broadheads, they will have penetration issues at longer distances. You won't get pass throughs, so get a moderately fast xbow or keep the shots shorter.

I'd never shoot at 80 or 100 yds myself at an animal, but I do at target for fun and tuning. Arrows and broadheads are a big part of the accuracy, so tune and check spine/nock tune if needed.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by 44mc
shooting your xbow for fun has nothing to do with hunting get off your high horse. I did not say any thing about free hand or hunting . pete I have nocked bolts together at 50yards free hand before[/quote

>> bring your money i thing your full of it, making statements like that on how far you can shoot a x-bow accurate rather its free hand or off the bench what do other bowhunters think you are meaning ? they are thinking hunting conditions !

[quote=goalie]Um, they already changed the law in Minnesota to allow crossbow use in archery season by anyone >>which is fine but that might not be what will be the end results ?


Are you concerned that they'll stop letting you use a crossbow?

yes i am as are many other handi cap and older x-bow archery hunters ,its like the Liberal DNR is putting us the handi cap and old archery hunters under the bus so in the future the DNR may change the season for all of us in a x-bow archery season . don`t thing that has not crossed the DNR`s mind i hope your smarter than that this chit could happen ?
Posted By: Boarmaster123 Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Seems to be a lot of high horses in the archery world. A few years back overheard a compound bow hunter criticizing x bow hunters. A old guy who shot a recurve commented they he was cheating with the compound bow. I guess they were all fortunate their wasn't a long bow hunter that whittled his own wooden arrows there to look down his nose at the both of them. Archery equipment has come a long way.

I took up bow hunting back in the late 80’s with a cheap Fred Bear compound bow. I got good enough after practicing for a summer to kill a few hogs then lost interest. I’m thinking on taking it back up next year. It gets me in the woods a month early at my lease in Alabama.
I will probably go with an Excalibur maybe 380 matrix crossbow. I’m 61 these days. I’m sure a few of younger compound bow hunters a camp might look down there nose at me but I don't really care.
Posted By: 9point3 Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by johna1
Just wait until your first deer with one.

They are more efficient than a rifle.


In what way are crossbows more efficient? Please explain so I can understand what you are getting at.
Posted By: johna1 Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
I've shot multiple deer with rifles.

And multiple deer with crossbows.

At the distances that I have killed deer with the crossbow, they have only ran a few feet before tumbling over.

I did kill a little 6 point with a 6.8 one year that dropped in its' tracks. But, that's the only one I've ever seen that done personally. Most of the time, they go a lot further before piling up and resulting in needing to track them.

I think 30 feet is the farthest I've seen a deer go before going down with a crossbow.

Least those are my experiences.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by 9point3
Originally Posted by johna1
Just wait until your first deer with one.

They are more efficient than a rifle.


In what way are crossbows more efficient? Please explain so I can understand what you are getting at.

ya me too ?
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by pete53
yes i am as are many other handi cap and older x-bow archery hunters ,its like the Liberal DNR is putting us the handi cap and old archery hunters under the bus so in the future the DNR may change the season for all of us in a x-bow archery season . don`t thing that has not crossed the DNR`s mind i hope your smarter than that this chit could happen ?

What, exactly, are you afraid of?
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by 44mc
with an xcal if you turn the scope that came with the bow down to the FPS it will shoot to the marks in the scope, turn down the fps nob down 1 time then shot the 50yard mark at 60 yard. if you play with it you can shoot to 70 80 plus yards

this is B. S. ever shoot a x-bow free hand at 50 yds. ? myself i was always much more accurate with my compound bow when i was healthy than with a x-bow free hand. so if you feel you can shoot that x-bow so accurate at 50 yds. free hand come to my place and if you can out shoot my son and his compound bow at 50 yards 5 shots each i will hand you a $100.00 bill. you loose you hand my son the $100.00 bill , i will post the results on 24 hr. Campfire. so some weekend let me know if want to do this , Pete53


This reminds me of the Seinfeld episode when Jerry was in the hospital and the old guy kep changeling him to various weight lifting activities against his son.

The more Jerry win, the lord the old man upped tha anti.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/11/23
Originally Posted by 9point3
Originally Posted by johna1
Just wait until your first deer with one.

They are more efficient than a rifle.


In what way are crossbows more efficient? Please explain so I can understand what you are getting at.

Do you really not understand how x-bows are more efficient? If you can’t see that I’m not sure explains that to you will help.
Posted By: 44mc Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k
Posted By: 9point3 Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by 9point3
Originally Posted by johna1
Just wait until your first deer with one.

They are more efficient than a rifle.


In what way are crossbows more efficient? Please explain so I can understand what you are getting at.

Do you really not understand how x-bows are more efficient? If you can’t see that I’m not sure explains that to you will help.



Just give the parameters of input vs results and I will hopefully understand what you are defining as efficient
Posted By: johna1 Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
I stopped feeding trolls years ago.

But if you insist:


30-06/165 gr bullet @3000 fps = 2997 ft lb energy at the muzzle.

20", 535 gr arrow and broadhead weight @ 310 fps = 114 ft lb energy at the riser

Last deer I shot with a 30-06 was not recovered because it ran into a neighboring property. Which was a state animal preserve.

Last deer I shot with a crossbow, launched up on it's back legs, moved forward 6 steps, stiffened up, fell over.

Good shot placement for both.

Crossbow is more efficient.

Thanks for playing. Please come again.
Posted By: Angus1895 Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
Congratulations!

I have a Kodak bow with an Excalibur micro limbs.

The trigger on the Kodak bow makes it for me 60 yard bow for elk, 50 for deer.

I need to try heavier bolts/ broadheads but I hate how the string deteriorates after shooting so I don’t shoot it much.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
Originally Posted by 44mc
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k

let`s try to be a little more positive and don`t feel so butthurt . maybe learn to spell the easy words better 1st >>legal not leagle << makes you look even more foolish idiot
Posted By: 9point3 Re: Crossbow - 09/12/23
Originally Posted by johna1
I stopped feeding trolls years ago.

But if you insist:


30-06/165 gr bullet @3000 fps = 2997 ft lb energy at the muzzle.

20", 535 gr arrow and broadhead weight @ 310 fps = 114 ft lb energy at the riser

Last deer I shot with a 30-06 was not recovered because it ran into a neighboring property. Which was a state animal preserve.

Last deer I shot with a crossbow, launched up on it's back legs, moved forward 6 steps, stiffened up, fell over.

Good shot placement for both.

Crossbow is more efficient.

Thanks for playing. Please come again.

Try that at 250 yards and tell me about efficiency! Try shooting 2 deer seconds apart and tell.me.about efficiency. If crossbows are the best thing since sliced bread, why haven't the bear guides hung up their big guns for cross bows ??
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by 44mc
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k

let`s try to be a little more positive and don`t feel so butthurt . maybe learn to spell the easy words better 1st >>legal not leagle << makes you look even more foolish idiot

More foolish than your stupid bet? Lmao
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by 44mc
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k

let`s try to be a little more positive and don`t feel so butthurt . maybe learn to spell the easy words better 1st >>legal not leagle << makes you look even more foolish idiot

More foolish than your stupid bet? Lmao

TRY AND BE A LITTLE MORE POSITIVE ,DOING THE TROLL THING ON YOUR KEYBOARD LOOKS FOOLISH.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by 44mc
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k

let`s try to be a little more positive and don`t feel so butthurt . maybe learn to spell the easy words better 1st >>legal not leagle << makes you look even more foolish idiot

More foolish than your stupid bet? Lmao

TRY AND BE A LITTLE MORE POSITIVE ,DOING THE TROLL THING ON YOUR KEYBOARD LOOKS FOOLISH.

Ok boomer
Posted By: 44mc Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
dam I though the only idiot on here was in AK not north USA
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by Angus1895
Congratulations!

I have a Kodak bow with an Excalibur micro limbs.

The trigger on the Kodak bow makes it for me 60 yard bow for elk, 50 for deer.

I need to try heavier bolts/ broadheads but I hate how the string deteriorates after shooting so I don’t shoot it much.

You can polish the latches, or send the trigger group in for warranty polishing.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by pete53
Originally Posted by 44mc
pete get the fu$k off your high horse I shot recurves all my life . my shoulders gave out 25 years ago I waited 11/12 years tell FLA made xbows leagle for every body . then I got one and I shoot it 2500/3000 times a year . so go pound sand you dumb fu$k

let`s try to be a little more positive and don`t feel so butthurt . maybe learn to spell the easy words better 1st >>legal not leagle << makes you look even more foolish idiot

You still haven't answered: what, exactly, are you afraid of with crossbow becoming legal for everyone in MN?
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
i will spell it out again = MN. DNR are watching and taking notes this year and next year on how many deer are shot with a x-bow in Mn. during the archery season and if its too high DNR plans on changing how long x- bow season might be like a shorter separate season during the regular archery season and when that happens the old and handi-cap x-bow archery hunters will be included in with the x-bow season. i would hate to see that to happen but it might , i will turn 70 years old this year soon. i have bowhunted since i was 10 years old i feel as many others do we have a right even with poor health to still hunt the entire archery season even with x-bow . our old friends , family , and us all archers helped get and support to get a Minnesota Archery Season . so now do you understand ?
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by pete53
i will spell it out again = MN. DNR are watching and taking notes this year and next year on how many deer are shot with a x-bow in Mn. during the archery season and if its too high DNR plans on changing how long x- bow season might be like a shorter separate season during the regular archery season and when that happens the old and handi-cap x-bow archery hunters will be included in with the x-bow season. i would hate to see that to happen but it might , i will turn 70 years old this year soon. i have bowhunted since i was 10 years old i feel as many others do we have a right even with poor health to still hunt the entire archery season even with x-bow . our old friends , family , and us all archers helped get and support to get a Minnesota Archery Season . so now do you understand ?

Oh, yeah, you're selfish and are afraid everyone getting to do what you're doing might ruin it.

Won't happen, the DNR wants more deer killed.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
Originally Posted by Bwana_1
And if you're shooting expandable broadheads, they will have penetration issues at longer distances. You won't get pass throughs, so get a moderately fast xbow or keep the shots shorter.

I'd never shoot at 80 or 100 yds myself at an animal, but I do at target for fun and tuning. Arrows and broadheads are a big part of the accuracy, so tune and check spine/nock tune if needed.

I’ll refrain from the who-struck-john about whether or not xbows should be allowed, but I can agree with what you said about expandables. I have one I dug out of a buck I killed with a ML. It had hit high on the scapula and was actually poking through the hide on the opposite side. The buck was fat and healthy, but that thing must’ve hurt like blazes every time he moved. It never opened.

My Excalibur is for sale in hopes I’ll abstain this year and chase more small game and birds, but if seems like the same dreary economy that’s futzing up gun sales is affecting other stuff too. If it doesn’t sell, I guess I’ll give it a whack on cooler days.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 09/13/23
I figgered out what you were saying Pete, and I doubt that they will cut back on the ♿️ opportunities. Wouldn’t make sense.

I’m older than you, and got my xbow because I simply couldn’t practice enough with a hunting weight bow to be ethical.
Posted By: hillestadj Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by pete53
i will spell it out again = MN. DNR are watching and taking notes this year and next year on how many deer are shot with a x-bow in Mn. during the archery season and if its too high DNR plans on changing how long x- bow season might be like a shorter separate season during the regular archery season and when that happens the old and handi-cap x-bow archery hunters will be included in with the x-bow season. i would hate to see that to happen but it might , i will turn 70 years old this year soon. i have bowhunted since i was 10 years old i feel as many others do we have a right even with poor health to still hunt the entire archery season even with x-bow . our old friends , family , and us all archers helped get and support to get a Minnesota Archery Season . so now do you understand ?


Oh, my!!


You MN X-Bow boys tone it down so Pete isn't inconvenienced.


lol
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by hillestadj
Originally Posted by pete53
i will spell it out again = MN. DNR are watching and taking notes this year and next year on how many deer are shot with a x-bow in Mn. during the archery season and if its too high DNR plans on changing how long x- bow season might be like a shorter separate season during the regular archery season and when that happens the old and handi-cap x-bow archery hunters will be included in with the x-bow season. i would hate to see that to happen but it might , i will turn 70 years old this year soon. i have bowhunted since i was 10 years old i feel as many others do we have a right even with poor health to still hunt the entire archery season even with x-bow . our old friends , family , and us all archers helped get and support to get a Minnesota Archery Season . so now do you understand ?


Oh, my!!


You MN X-Bow boys tone it down so Pete isn't inconvenienced.


lol

Screw that. The DNR approved my permit a few months before the law changed. I'm still happy the law changed.

I don't have time for the ME ME ME crowd. It's like the people with machine guns that would be mad if the NFA act was repealed
Posted By: Magnum_Bob Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb


That's how it used to be in MN and WI...you needed a permit. Not now and apparently Pete wants the law changed back for him!
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.
Posted By: AH64guy Re: Crossbow - 09/14/23
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by hillestadj
Originally Posted by pete53
i will spell it out again = MN. DNR are watching and taking notes this year and next year on how many deer are shot with a x-bow in Mn. during the archery season and if its too high DNR plans on changing how long x- bow season might be like a shorter separate season during the regular archery season and when that happens the old and handi-cap x-bow archery hunters will be included in with the x-bow season. i would hate to see that to happen but it might , i will turn 70 years old this year soon. i have bowhunted since i was 10 years old i feel as many others do we have a right even with poor health to still hunt the entire archery season even with x-bow . our old friends , family , and us all archers helped get and support to get a Minnesota Archery Season . so now do you understand ?


Oh, my!!


You MN X-Bow boys tone it down so Pete isn't inconvenienced.


lol

Screw that. The DNR approved my permit a few months before the law changed. I'm still happy the law changed.

I don't have time for the ME ME ME crowd. It's like the people with machine guns that would be mad if the NFA act was repealed

A few months ago Petey Pup was bashing Montana for NOT having any xbow season - I'm being "more than positive" that he'll be back again...

We grumbled about it Virginia when they went all archery tackle for the entire season, but the truth is for our state - it's putting more hunters in the woods each year, and the aged hunters are staying in the field more years than they would have pulling vertical bow.
Posted By: Joel/AK Re: Crossbow - 09/30/23
We use a cross bow. Don't care what anyone else thinks.

Daughter loves it, although she doesn't want to hunt.

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 10/01/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.

no the new x-bow law is fine but the DNR is going to try and keep an eye on the numbers of deer shot with a x-bow and there are plenty compound bowhunters that feel butthurt now in Minnesota . i see this might be a problem but we will have to wait and see ? x-bows for handi-cap hunter law was in court again this year in Montana and was out voted again because of those compound bowhunters feeling they might be butthurt.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/01/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.

Based on my own experience, 7 shots resulting in 6 hits, plus countless videos I’ve watched, I think that an unalarmed deer will often not jump the string. One that’s looking your way wondering what you are at the shot probably will. The last one I shot at with my xbow stood there while it zipped over his back, then trotted off, as much I think in response to the sound of the bolt hitting the ground as the whang of the bow. He was 50 lasered yards away. I just whiffed it. The other deer were taken at between 20 and 35 yards. Only one was looking at me, and she had zero time to duck. The rest only moved when the bolt hit.

Nothing is written in stone of course. I’ve seen more than one stay put after being missed by a rifle, as long as there was no other sound or movement to alert them to my presence.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 10/02/23
Originally Posted by Joel/AK
We use a cross bow. Don't care what anyone else thinks.

Daughter loves it, although she doesn't want to hunt.

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

Whatever gets them outside!
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 10/02/23
Originally Posted by Pappy348
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.

Based on my own experience, 7 shots resulting in 6 hits, plus countless videos I’ve watched, I think that an unalarmed deer will often not jump the string. One that’s looking your way wondering what you are at the shot probably will. The last one I shot at with my xbow stood there while it zipped over his back, then trotted off, as much I think in response to the sound of the bolt hitting the ground as the whang of the bow. He was 50 lasered yards away. I just whiffed it. The other deer were taken at between 20 and 35 yards. Only one was looking at me, and she had zero time to duck. The rest only moved when the bolt hit.

Nothing is written in stone of course. I’ve seen more than one stay put after being missed by a rifle, as long as there was no other sound or movement to alert them to my presence.

Have you noticed any difference in how far they run with a crossbow compared to a compound?
Posted By: Bwana_1 Re: Crossbow - 10/02/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by Pappy348
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.

Based on my own experience, 7 shots resulting in 6 hits, plus countless videos I’ve watched, I think that an unalarmed deer will often not jump the string. One that’s looking your way wondering what you are at the shot probably will. The last one I shot at with my xbow stood there while it zipped over his back, then trotted off, as much I think in response to the sound of the bolt hitting the ground as the whang of the bow. He was 50 lasered yards away. I just whiffed it. The other deer were taken at between 20 and 35 yards. Only one was looking at me, and she had zero time to duck. The rest only moved when the bolt hit.

Nothing is written in stone of course. I’ve seen more than one stay put after being missed by a rifle, as long as there was no other sound or movement to alert them to my presence.

Have you noticed any difference in how far they run with a crossbow compared to a compound?

A lot depends on shot location of course, and whether you are using a fixed or expandable broadhead....I find my Vert bows penetrate better with better blood trails, still trying to figure out why tbh....ymmv
Posted By: Blackheart Re: Crossbow - 10/02/23
I've had zero problems with mechanical broadheads. Haven't kept one in a deer yet with compound or crossbow. Three of the four deer I've killed with my crossbow and NAP shockwaves have gone down within sight in less than 30 yards. The fourth made it 75 bleeding like a stuck pig the whole way. Last years buck fell on the third bound. All of the mechanicals I've used in both my compound and my crossbow were old tech {NAP shockwaves and Rocket Steelheads}, 3 blade swing opens held closed with rubber O rings and 1 1/4" cutting diameter. Some guys just gotta spend for the supposedly latest and greatest and use heads that open wide and rely on gadgetry to stay closed and/or deploy and I think that's where they run into problems with mechanicals. My hunting partner insists on using some kind of Rage broadheads that open like 3" wide. Sure they chop a wide swath but he gets much less penetration than I do and missed an easy 25 yard shot at a buck last season because the blades opened on launch and hit his foot stirrup on the way out of the bow. No thanks, I'm stickin with what I've been using until they give me some reason to look elsewhere. You ain't gotta chop holes through deer you can stick your foot in to kill them.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/03/23
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by Pappy348
Originally Posted by tzone
Originally Posted by goalie
Originally Posted by Magnum_Bob
In SD you have to get a release from a Dr saying your physically unable to use a traditional or compound bow to get to you a crossbow use permit. I passed on a sweet deal on a slightly used Ravin R-10 a month a go because I don't have that release yet. That ravin made a muzzleloader look like a joke to 100yds. It's as high tech as anyone's 3-5000 dollar rifle. Mb

I don't know about the new super fast ones, but my experience with a dozen or so deer with a regular bow is that you get past a certain distance and jumping the string becomes a thing. It doesn't matter how accurate the arrow flies if you're literally guessing at where the deer will be when it gets there.

That said, 40 yards is a "long" shot where I hunt no matter whether I've got rifle, pistol, muzzle loader or bow.

There is no way a deer won't jump the string, even with X-bow at ranges past 50 yards. They make too much noise and the arrow has to fly too far. Even at 450fps it has like 3/4 of a second to move out of the "strike zone" of the bolt from 100 yds.

Based on my own experience, 7 shots resulting in 6 hits, plus countless videos I’ve watched, I think that an unalarmed deer will often not jump the string. One that’s looking your way wondering what you are at the shot probably will. The last one I shot at with my xbow stood there while it zipped over his back, then trotted off, as much I think in response to the sound of the bolt hitting the ground as the whang of the bow. He was 50 lasered yards away. I just whiffed it. The other deer were taken at between 20 and 35 yards. Only one was looking at me, and she had zero time to duck. The rest only moved when the bolt hit.

Nothing is written in stone of course. I’ve seen more than one stay put after being missed by a rifle, as long as there was no other sound or movement to alert them to my presence.

Have you noticed any difference in how far they run with a crossbow compared to a compound?

Never shot one with any sort of bow except the xbow. Can’t imagine there’d be much difference. Through and through is want it is, and entrance and exit holes are pretty nasty. I know the first time I shot one I was really surprised at the loud pop of the impact. Those Muzzys are inexpensive, but cut on contact, and I doubt any deer bone will bend that point. The last one I shot ran a good ways, but that’s on me for hitting him too high. None of the others went over 50 yards or so.
Posted By: Northern_Jim Re: Crossbow - 10/05/23
I've shot a lot more deer with a compound & fixed blade heads than I have with a crossbow but they don't seem to go any farther one way or the other as long as you can put it in the right spot. I did hit one through both shoulders (scapula) with a Xbow I doubt my compound would have penetrated that far but I was shooting a heavy broadhead.
I agree that most of the time a deer will be able to duck an arrow out past 40 yards or so, I won't take a shot past 40 yards but that's just me.
Posted By: TolnaND Re: Crossbow - 10/06/23
Goalie, sent you a PM.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 10/06/23
Originally Posted by Northern_Jim
I've shot a lot more deer with a compound & fixed blade heads than I have with a crossbow but they don't seem to go any farther one way or the other as long as you can put it in the right spot. I did hit one through both shoulders (scapula) with a Xbow I doubt my compound would have penetrated that far but I was shooting a heavy broadhead.
I agree that most of the time a deer will be able to duck an arrow out past 40 yards or so, I won't take a shot past 40 yards but that's just me.

I agree Jim. They maybe can't duck a bolt from a xbow, but they'll be able to move far enough to make it a bad shot.
Posted By: 44mc Re: Crossbow - 10/06/23
the first deer I killed with my excal I shot the 20 yard mark in the scope at 40 yards hit the dirt way short deer did't spook much 10 min. later I set the scope fps down and killed him at 70 yards
Posted By: Bay1975 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by pete53
i have bohunted since i was 10 legal or not at that age and it was with a recurve ,then in the early 70`s i used a compound from the start of those years to now at 70 years of age with poor physical strength and a bad shoulder that the surgeon wanted to replace 4 years ago that i don`t want to , i already have had surgery in both shoulders so my body is a mess . > here is what i see is a negative thing that might happen to us handi cap and old bowhunters = Minnesota the state i live in the DNR is following who kills a deer with a x- bow during the archery season this year and probably even more in the future so myself and other handi cap old bowhunters will end up with the same law/rules for all x-bow archery hunters if it gets changed . i think x-bows are fine in the archery for all but there are plenty archery hunter selfish whiners out there that will try and change this law about x-bows in Minnesota, i hope it don`t happen but if it does i sure hope they leave the handi-cap old bowhunters alone in the archery season. Montana is one state that has a lot of whining selfish bowhunters with plenty butt hurt against handi-cap x-bow hunters during the archery season even on Federal land in Montana x-bows are not legal . so i hope Minnesota does not do this bowhunter butt hurt chit to x-bow archery hunters, at least not for the handi cap and old.

Handicapped hunters are the only ones that should be allowed to use crossbows during archery season. A crossbow has a trigger, a stock, a scope, and a saftey. Does that sound like a bow lol. If your too lazy to learn to shoot a compound or a real bow stay home till gun season. Older handicapped hunters that would shoot a real bow if not for their infirmities, should be allowed to use the crossbows. That’s how it always was. In my home state during bow season it was uncommon to see other hunters on weekends let alone week days. Now the woods are full of these lazy fat mouth breathers staggering around with a crossbow, their only handicap being obesity and lack of hunting ability lol.

I knew an old man that helped get bowseasons started in Louisiana in the beginning. He killed more deer than anyone I’ve ever known. He had kidney problems bad, aswell as belong near 80yo, he had used nothing but recurves until he could no longer shoot the weight he wanted, he then went to a compound. If anyone deserved to hunt with a crossbow it was this man. He told me he would quit before he used a crossbow. Compare that to these 30 yo flat brimmed hatted morons lol
Posted By: hookeye Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
If I want to hunt deer I'll take a vertical bow.
Within that, if I REALLY want to hunt deer, a recurve.

But if I want meat in the freezer, during archery season.............best bet would be an X bow.
Unfortunately my kid, somewhat disabled, doesn't want to use one.

Was looking at a Mission Sub 1.

My arthritis was bad yesterday, better today. Still didn't go hunting.
I'm good for 6-12 shots w my recurve in practice, but my hands will ache for a day or two.
New med maybe help, dunno yet.

Yup a lot of lazy folks like X bows.

Newsflash, shot 3D for a long while, have seen plenty of shiddy arrow flingers toting recurves and compounds.
Purists my azz.

At least with an X bow they might hit better.

IMHO using a crossbow makes one an "Xbow hunter" or "Ex bowhunter".
Which is fine.

Some folks do try to spin it as bowhunting though.
Posted By: hookeye Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Northern_Jim
I've shot a lot more deer with a compound & fixed blade heads than I have with a crossbow but they don't seem to go any farther one way or the other as long as you can put it in the right spot. I did hit one through both shoulders (scapula) with a Xbow I doubt my compound would have penetrated that far but I was shooting a heavy broadhead.
I agree that most of the time a deer will be able to duck an arrow out past 40 yards or so, I won't take a shot past 40 yards but that's just me.


Agreed.
Posted By: hookeye Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Being honest............


the older I get the more I like cooking venison.

The less I like busting my azz, freezing, hurting............to supply it.

If I had no love of archery, I'd buy an X bow and be grilling straps today.

They work.

But I find them heavy and awkward. Hell I found my Hoyt compound last yr to be a bit of a PITA.
Toting my recurve is a joy.

Don't have to worry about hurting my back dragging a deer out very much LOL

FWIW my old BW had 5 kills in a row, right off the bat.
This new recurve is 0 for 1.

Burns my azz. Maybe redeem myself tomorrow.

if another ducks it I'll be getting a custom cam lever compound as my handicap recurve LOL
Posted By: hookeye Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
My dad's old friend, was a pretty hardcore bowhunter.
Pops didn't bowhunt, but shot in the factory league (recurve days).
Both got me into archery.

Pop's bud had a stroke and had to go X bow, hated it.
But it got him afield, which added fun.

Handicapped or not, have fun.

Life is short.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Originally Posted by pete53
i have bohunted since i was 10 legal or not at that age and it was with a recurve ,then in the early 70`s i used a compound from the start of those years to now at 70 years of age with poor physical strength and a bad shoulder that the surgeon wanted to replace 4 years ago that i don`t want to , i already have had surgery in both shoulders so my body is a mess . > here is what i see is a negative thing that might happen to us handi cap and old bowhunters = Minnesota the state i live in the DNR is following who kills a deer with a x- bow during the archery season this year and probably even more in the future so myself and other handi cap old bowhunters will end up with the same law/rules for all x-bow archery hunters if it gets changed . i think x-bows are fine in the archery for all but there are plenty archery hunter selfish whiners out there that will try and change this law about x-bows in Minnesota, i hope it don`t happen but if it does i sure hope they leave the handi-cap old bowhunters alone in the archery season. Montana is one state that has a lot of whining selfish bowhunters with plenty butt hurt against handi-cap x-bow hunters during the archery season even on Federal land in Montana x-bows are not legal . so i hope Minnesota does not do this bowhunter butt hurt chit to x-bow archery hunters, at least not for the handi cap and old.

Handicapped hunters are the only ones that should be allowed to use crossbows during archery season. A crossbow has a trigger, a stock, a scope, and a saftey. Does that sound like a bow lol. If your too lazy to learn to shoot a compound or a real bow stay home till gun season. Older handicapped hunters that would shoot a real bow if not for their infirmities, should be allowed to use the crossbows. That’s how it always was. In my home state during bow season it was uncommon to see other hunters on weekends let alone week days. Now the woods are full of these lazy fat mouth breathers staggering around with a crossbow, their only handicap being obesity and lack of hunting ability lol.

I knew an old man that helped get bowseasons started in Louisiana in the beginning. He killed more deer than anyone I’ve ever known. He had kidney problems bad, aswell as belong near 80yo, he had used nothing but recurves until he could no longer shoot the weight he wanted, he then went to a compound. If anyone deserved to hunt with a crossbow it was this man. He told me he would quit before he used a crossbow. Compare that to these 30 yo flat brimmed hatted morons lol


Bullschitt. Who elected you Ethics Monitor? Game has to be managed, and in this area whitetails are like rats, even with constant pressure Sept-Jan from hunters toting guns, all sorts of bows, airguns, and MLs new and old. If rifles are ethical, so is anything less effective.
Posted By: WTM45 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
For me, the feeling I get when it all comes together with a bow is not matched by the crossbow.

I'd not deny that feeling to anyone, even if they get there with a crossbow.
Posted By: johna1 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Bay1975
A crossbow has a trigger, a stock, a scope, and a saftey. Does that sound like a bow lol. If your too lazy to learn to shoot a compound or a real bow stay home till gun season. Older handicapped hunters that would shoot a real bow if not for their infirmities, should be allowed to use the crossbows. That’s how it always was. In my home state during bow season it was uncommon to see other hunters on weekends let alone week days.

While I generally support anyone to believe whatever they want, I also believe a lot of people posting online are not of the very smart variety.

I don't think anyone that uses the username Bay1975 should be allowed to hunt with any bow he didn't make himself from a poplar branch and including gut string and flint arrows that he dug up and knapped himself and bird feather fletching and sinew wrap to hold them in place.

Otherwise, it would be just unethical to hunt with any commercially built and bought bow or arrow. The woods would be full of those inferior people come archery season. May God have mercy on us all and protect us from those evils. We would run out of deer in only a few years if that were to occur.


[Linked Image from i2.wp.com]
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
I’ll cheerfully knock them down with any legal device I can get them in front of. There are methods I don’t care to try, but it’s not my place to deny others their opportunity to use them. The DNR is in charge of that. Most who decry this and that way of hunting are actually trying to preserve the experience they desire, not the game, who are pretty good at doing that themselves if you examine the evidence of the numbers.

The IWLA chapter I belong to stocks its lake with hatchery rainbows twice a year. They get hammered with Power Bait, worms, lures, and flies. I prefer using a spinning rod with jigs and spinners, while my wife likes to watch a bobber. It’s all good, and the only restrictions are a limit to one rod and the daily limit of four per angler. Everybody has their fun, and the fish don’t care how they end up in the pan.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
For the anti crossbow losers, GFY


[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Hey, no fair. That guy in the foreground is using one of those unethical new-fangled cranks to cock his crossbow….

Cheater.
Posted By: StoneCutter Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
To each his own. If you want to use a compound, recurve, or long bow, more power to ya. I'll use anything they let me use. I started bow hunting with a compound in 1990. Bought my first crossbow in 2015 and killed more deer with that than all of the guns combined. There have been a lot of deer that probably would have walked if I didn't have the crossbow. Our bow season goes from Sept. through Jan. Call me a cheater, but it's legal.

I upgraded to this 10 Point Titan Decock last year.

[Linked Image from i.imgur.com]
Posted By: Bay1975 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by johna1
Originally Posted by Bay1975
A crossbow has a trigger, a stock, a scope, and a saftey. Does that sound like a bow lol. If your too lazy to learn to shoot a compound or a real bow stay home till gun season. Older handicapped hunters that would shoot a real bow if not for their infirmities, should be allowed to use the crossbows. That’s how it always was. In my home state during bow season it was uncommon to see other hunters on weekends let alone week days.

While I generally support anyone to believe whatever they want, I also believe a lot of people posting online are not of the very smart variety.

I don't think anyone that uses the username Bay1975 should be allowed to hunt with any bow he didn't make himself from a poplar branch and including gut string and flint arrows that he dug up and knapped himself and bird feather fletching and sinew wrap to hold them in place.

Otherwise, it would be just unethical to hunt with any commercially built and bought bow or arrow. The woods would be full of those inferior people come archery season. May God have mercy on us all and protect us from those evils. We would run out of deer in only a few years if that were to occur.


[Linked Image from i2.wp.com]
Originally Posted by johna1
Originally Posted by Bay1975
A crossbow has a trigger, a stock, a scope, and a saftey. Does that sound like a bow lol. If your too lazy to learn to shoot a compound or a real bow stay home till gun season. Older handicapped hunters that would shoot a real bow if not for their infirmities, should be allowed to use the crossbows. That’s how it always was. In my home state during bow season it was uncommon to see other hunters on weekends let alone week days.

While I generally support anyone to believe whatever they want, I also believe a lot of people posting online are not of the very smart variety.

I don't think anyone that uses the username Bay1975 should be allowed to hunt with any bow he didn't make himself from a poplar branch and including gut string and flint arrows that he dug up and knapped himself and bird feather fletching and sinew wrap to hold them in place.

Otherwise, it would be just unethical to hunt with any commercially built and bought bow or arrow. The woods would be full of those inferior people come archery season. May God have mercy on us all and protect us from those evils. We would run out of deer in only a few years if that were to occur.


[Linked Image from i2.wp.com]

Lol. I bet your one of them man boob having cross dresser/crossbow shooters lol. You never hear any comeback for how a crossbow with a freakin scope and trigger is a bow, just some dumbass remark that barley makes sense.

Anywhere in the country the rifle/shotgun seasons have the largest number of deer kills, it ain’t even close. So anyone with much brain knows the deer population control is done mostly by the gun hunters. So saying we need more bowhunters with crossbows is beyond stupid. Most of the cross dressers don’t have any better kill statistics than real bowhunters, it’s not how many deer they kill it’s them stinking up the woods stumbling around with their Xbows when 10 years ago they’d have been on the couch steadily increasing their cholesterol levels and leaving the woods to bowhunters until rifle season the way God intended.
Posted By: 10gaugemag Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Not like crossbows haven't been used for centuries.
Posted By: Blackheart Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
[align:center][/align]
Originally Posted by 10gaugemag
Not like crossbows haven't been used for centuries.
Way longer than compound bows. These archery puritan whiners best be sticking to old school recurves and longbows like we did when I sarted bow hunting or STFU. I for one am tired of listening to the whiny sunsabitches.
Posted By: Bay1975 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Well I’ve never owned nor hunted with a compound. I started with a recurve and now hunt only with a longbow and wood arrows so GFY lol
Posted By: Blackheart Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Well I’ve never owned nor hunted with a compound. I started with a recurve and now hunt only with a longbow and wood arrows so GFY lol
Yeah well I hunt with a sidelock, patched balls and black powder during MZ season. My choice. I don't begrudge the guys using scoped inlines and say they shouldn't be allowed to use them unless they're old and disabled.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Blackheart
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Well I’ve never owned nor hunted with a compound. I started with a recurve and now hunt only with a longbow and wood arrows so GFY lol
Yeah well I hunt with a sidelock, patched balls and black powder during MZ season. My choice. I don't begrudge the guys using scoped inlines and say they shouldn't be allowed to use them unless they're old and disabled.

Blackheart posted i very good statement ! i say the same thing who cares what you use to fill your tag . as a lineman who has work all over Minnesota the worst thing i ever seen was a pile of dead deer hidden somewhat by some city hunters " ST. Cloud ,Mn." gutted , tags removed and the buck horns removed , there was 9 rifle shot dead deer in this pile wasted. >if you eat your deer meat then kill the deer how ever you want and enjoy the meat ,if you waste the deer meat you have no business hunting shame on you. Pete53
Posted By: johna1 Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Lol. I bet your one of them man boob having cross dresser/crossbow shooters lol. You never hear any comeback for how a crossbow with a freakin scope and trigger is a bow, just some dumbass remark that barley makes sense.

Anywhere in the country the rifle/shotgun seasons have the largest number of deer kills, it ain’t even close. So anyone with much brain knows the deer population control is done mostly by the gun hunters. So saying we need more bowhunters with crossbows is beyond stupid. Most of the cross dressers don’t have any better kill statistics than real bowhunters, it’s not how many deer they kill it’s them stinking up the woods stumbling around with their Xbows when 10 years ago they’d have been on the couch steadily increasing their cholesterol levels and leaving the woods to bowhunters until rifle season the way God intended.

Posted By: 10gaugemag Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Well I’ve never owned nor hunted with a compound. I started with a recurve and now hunt only with a longbow and wood arrows so GFY lol
Stone points??

Fletching attached with sinew??
Posted By: 10gaugemag Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
I bet harvest numbers have increased less than 5% in states that have legalized the crossbow.
Posted By: 10gaugemag Re: Crossbow - 10/20/23
Originally Posted by Blackheart
Originally Posted by Bay1975
Well I’ve never owned nor hunted with a compound. I started with a recurve and now hunt only with a longbow and wood arrows so GFY lol
Yeah well I hunt with a sidelock, patched balls and black powder during MZ season. My choice. I don't begrudge the guys using scoped inlines and say they shouldn't be allowed to use them unless they're old and disabled.
Better get a matchlock or your not a true muzzleloader hunter.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 10/21/23
Originally Posted by 10gaugemag
I bet harvest numbers have increased less than 5% in states that have legalized the crossbow.


^^ TRUE ^^
Posted By: willycc Re: Crossbow - 10/21/23
Pa archery buck kill numbers have almost doubled since the crossbow was legalized
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Crossbow - 10/21/23
Originally Posted by 10gaugemag
I bet harvest numbers have increased less than 5% in states that have legalized the crossbow.

Whatever it is, it ain’t enough in many places. Next door in Clarke County, VA, they’ve opened the antlerless season on private land on the first of September for a couple or three years now. choose your weapon. The standard deer license allows six deer, and for a few dollars, you get tags for another six. You have to kill two does before you can take a second buck.

VA is a patchwork of regs due to the wide variety of conditions. Gotta be a Philadelphia lawyer to understand them all. Access to the private land is hard to come by, just as in my WV county, so the hunters are concentrated on the public, or often join clubs, but the clubs are usually located on timber land, not ag.
Posted By: WStrayer Re: Crossbow - 10/22/23
Willycc,
Didn't run the numbers of buck only but in 2008-2009 archery kills were 120,260. Last year that was 130,650. The ratio of buck/doe varies by WMU. I would suspect that buck numbers are down due to the antler restrictions.
Posted By: tzone Re: Crossbow - 10/24/23
Originally Posted by hookeye
Newsflash, shot 3D for a long while, have seen plenty of shiddy arrow flingers toting recurves and compounds.
Purists my azz.

At least with an X bow they might hit better.

IMHO using a crossbow makes one an "Xbow hunter" or "Ex bowhunter".
Which is fine.

Some folks do try to spin it as bowhunting though.

I donno...I was shooting both yesterday. Unless I have a real steady rest, I'm better with my compound out to 40. Seriously.

I'll be bowhunting for the next few weeks before gun season. I'm not sure the x-bow will make the trip. I've only had it for a month or so and not had much time on it. There certainly is no comparison between the two for speed.
Posted By: mckbcat2000 Re: Crossbow - 12/04/23
Best of luck
Posted By: 1eyedmule Re: Crossbow - 12/04/23
This print hangs on the wall in my office. Thought you guys might enjoy it. Looks like the crossbow was Willie's and is being presented as evidence by the sheriff. Hard to argue with The Bard laugh

[Linked Image]
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 12/31/23
>> recurve type x-bows have been use for 100`s maybe 1,000 years and that`s is what i use yet ,i also sharpen my broadheads Zwickey Eskimos manufactured in Minnesota many years before compound bows were invented ,build my own arrows with real bird feathers . ^^ i like the picture of above my post ^^
Posted By: 30338 Re: Crossbow - 01/04/24
Priced up a new Hoyt lefthanded long draw bow today minus the sight. It came in at $2,060. Got a couple crossbow deals emailed to me for complete setups at $499 and $600. Still shooting my old Z9 Mathews but someday I'll need to upgrade. I don't really worry about killing stuff just figuring out what I may enjoy using the most. Could be a Toelke longbow, a rebuilt old Mathews or a crossbow. I dunno. In no hurry to decide but my guess is 20% are still going to kill 80%.

And yes at my age my shoulders hurt etc. Looked at a 55 pound Hoyt with 32" draw. Probably where it ends up at. But won't rule out a crossbow yet either.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 01/05/24
Originally Posted by 30338
Priced up a new Hoyt lefthanded long draw bow today minus the sight. It came in at $2,060. Got a couple crossbow deals emailed to me for complete setups at $499 and $600. Still shooting my old Z9 Mathews but someday I'll need to upgrade. I don't really worry about killing stuff just figuring out what I may enjoy using the most. Could be a Toelke longbow, a rebuilt old Mathews or a crossbow. I dunno. In no hurry to decide but my guess is 20% are still going to kill 80%.

And yes at my age my shoulders hurt etc. Looked at a 55 pound Hoyt with 32" draw. Probably where it ends up at. But won't rule out a crossbow yet either.


well take good care of those shoulders ,today i seen the Minnesota Twins shoulder surgeon for the 1st time ,after looking at the x-rays of my shoulder he told me i need shoulder replacement soon, i am trying to hold out tell after summer fishing,trap shooting and next fall hunting since it is my left shoulder and i am right handed .surgeon said i need to do MRI`S very soon they are making my appointment for the MRI`S and then he will make the decision when,he does know i have a African hunt in May and said it might have to happen when you get back early June.
Posted By: goalie Re: Crossbow - 01/05/24
Good luck. Shoulder surgery recovery sucked. It takes a legit three months to be back to doing real stuff. Of the flip side, I played another 15 years of hockey as a goalie without issues after having mine done (by the Wild's ortho guy at the time) almost 20 years ago.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 01/05/24
Originally Posted by goalie
Good luck. Shoulder surgery recovery sucked. It takes a legit three months to be back to doing real stuff. Of the flip side, I played another 15 years of hockey as a goalie without issues after having mine done (by the Wild's ortho guy at the time) almost 20 years ago.


thanks for the support in the past i have had surgery on both shoulders and your right it does suck . now getting new man made parts installed in the shoulder will probably give me new different meaning to pain again . as the surgeon said to me the 1st 10-12 weeks nothing but very light therapy , yes go on the hunt in May but we might need to do surgery in early June so i will have to be careful this summer and my 11yr.old grandson will be learning some young man working skills .
Posted By: Joel/AK Re: Crossbow - 01/28/24
Went to my sis in laws place today to see how she's doing. Brother died on the 2nd. She was frustrated cuz she couldn't get into the safe.

I got it open for her and she said said I could take whatever gun I wanted....not today.

I did take his crossbow. In MI you can use them whenever you want, no disability license needed. It's a new 10 point turbo s1.

Been using an older 10point for about 11 years now. Left shoulder is shot. Tried using my brother in laws older compound but my shoulder feels like it's gonna dislocated before let off.

I'll take the upgrade
Posted By: KillerBee Re: Crossbow - 01/28/24
Sorry for your loss Joel/AK.
Posted By: Joel/AK Re: Crossbow - 01/28/24
Thanks but as we all know...shidt happens
Posted By: KillerBee Re: Crossbow - 01/28/24
Yup
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 01/30/24
yup chit happens rather it is a illness ,health problem or even death it sucks . the shoulder surgeon warned me some after that shoulder is replaced and in a sling for around 12 weeks ,then therapy for a few months , then surgeon said best you never ever pull a bow back again i agreed with him . take care of yourself,Pete53
Posted By: Joel/AK Re: Crossbow - 01/31/24
My wife loved deer hunting. Unfortunately, her back said otherwise. After 6 surgeries was when we got our first crossbow. She did OK but slow.

After her 7th surgery, this time on her thoracic, that was it. She can't sit, let alone recover a deer on her own. She misses it but it's life. She's 50 years old.

I use a cross bow cuz of my shoulder but I can still get out.

Enjoy every day you can get out and hunt. Use whatever tool is legal that you can. Sometimes the door slams shut on you
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 01/31/24
Originally Posted by Joel/AK
My wife loved deer hunting. Unfortunately, her back said otherwise. After 6 surgeries was when we got our first crossbow. She did OK but slow.

After her 7th surgery, this time on her thoracic, that was it. She can't sit, let alone recover a deer on her own. She misses it but it's life. She's 50 years old.

I use a cross bow cuz of my shoulder but I can still get out.

Enjoy every day you can get out and hunt. Use whatever tool is legal that you can. Sometimes the door slams shut on you

most healthy young hunters don`t understand when some of us have health problems but still want to hunt sad but true , but some day they may have health problems too . Pete53
Posted By: davesonic444 Re: Crossbow - 02/25/24
I live in Ohio and the crossbow is a hate love thing to me. There was a time you could go hunting on public land and not see another soul. Today it is over crowded and sad.
Posted By: pete53 Re: Crossbow - 02/28/24
Originally Posted by davesonic444
I live in Ohio and the crossbow is a hate love thing to me. There was a time you could go hunting on public land and not see another soul. Today it is over crowded and sad.

find a different area to hunt or lease ,buy land , i purchased some land made payments and work extra hours to make the payments for my hunting land.
© 24hourcampfire