Thank you Tanner. I started out shooting the 140 AB's in the Winchester Supreme ammo while I was stationed out at Camp Pendleton. Didn't have my reloading gear while I was there. Those factory loads are probably about as good as any handload I have ever built, and they chronoed a little over 3200 out of my rifle and were just accurate as heck. I took an elk and a few mulies with that load.
After I moved to NC, I tried my hand with some handloads and the 130 Interbonds. I used Magpro for those and had some excellent loads that ran just shy of 3400 out of my rifle and they were also accurate as any other. Shot some smallish NC deer and a couple of larger bodied deer in NY. Never recovered a bullet, and they were like a dynamite stick on deer.
Then, I started getting Nosler 2nds and ordered alot of the 150 BT's and 150 PT's and spend a little bit of time with them and RL22. I am pretty sure that is where I will stay. I haven't messed around with the 140 AB's in handloads, but that would probably be about the best of both worlds in the WSM, but I have so many 150's and they shoot well, I am not scratching to mess around much.
I did get about 150 of the 150 grain PT Golds, uncoated recently. I really like them as they shoot well, and they are some tough bullets! Their PT is moved forward just a hair and have the steel shank in the rear core. I think they would be an awesome elk bullet. They shoot the same as the regular PT's as well and run right at 3100 or so. I imagine I could bump them up a .5 or 1 grain get closer to 3150, but I am not sure it is worth the trouble.
I did some shooting out to 600 with the PT's and BT's, they shot excellent out there. Still grouping in the 4-5 inch range with the 3.5x10 VX3 on my rifle. I am not sure I could shoot much better. It does inspire alot of confidence.
Your right though, different rifles have so many different likes...