Home
http://www.shootingillustrated.com/mobile/article.php?id=463

Based on the Info below... Same bullet with different impact speed changes size of wound channel and penetration.


"The most important bullet characteristics with regard to terminal performance are expansion, weight retention, penetration and wounding qualities. Without knowing these, you are pretty much shooting in the dark as to bullet suitability for a particular game species and downrange performance. To test these traits across a spectrum of muzzle and impact velocities, I shot sample 130-grain TTSX bullets through a .300 Whisper, a .308 Winchester and a .300 Weatherby Magnum into Bullet Test Tubes with Extenders at 25 yards.

With a muzzle velocity of 2,013 fps, through the .300 Whisper the TTSX expanded to .541 inch, retained 129.2 grains of its weight, penetrated 14 3/4 inches and produced a .667-inch-wide wound channel. At a similar velocity, the TSX expanded to .439 inch, weighed 130 grains, penetrated 13 1/2 inches but veered severely off course at the 6-inch mark while creating a .638-inch-wide wound channel.

Propelled through the .308 Winchester at 2,878 fps, the new bullet enlarged to .614 inch, kept 129.3 grains of its weight, pierced 15 inches into the media and formed a 2-inch-wide wound channel. The most punishing evaluation came when I launched the TTSX from the .300 Weatherby Magnum at 3,562 fps. It penetrated all 20 inches of Test Tube and Extender and exited, but not before leaving a 2.371-inch-wide wound channel and shedding a single, 11.8-grain petal at the 11 1/2-inch mark. It�s possible to argue the recovered bullet weight would be between 117.3 and 117.6 grains. "


so here is the results
130 TTSX
speed---- expansion --- penetration-- would channel
2013 --- .541" --- 14.75" -- .667"
2878 --- .614" --- 15" -- 2.00"
3562 --- n/a --- 20"+ -- 2.371"
The highest velocity had the deepest penetration....interesting. smile
But the different in wound channel between 300 whisper and 308 was 3x the size!!!
velocity.... wink

Who says "it doesn't matter"?....of course it does. cool
Originally Posted by BobinNH
The highest velocity had the deepest penetration....interesting. smile


Yup. Pretty typical of mono bullets. The faster they hit, the harder and deeper they smack.
Jordan the faster you drive some bullets,the expanded petals fold back flatter against the shank,creating a somewhat smaller frontal area....this allows a bit more penetration I think.
Yes Bob, even with the TSX/TTSX's, I've driven them so fast into test media when they are retrieved they look like a 'brad' or "bradded rivet", petals completely gone with a bit of nose slump left.

Gunner
Originally Posted by BobinNH
Jordan the faster you drive some bullets,the expanded petals fold back flatter against the shank,creating a somewhat smaller frontal area....this allows a bit more penetration I think.


Bob, you're absolutely right. Although, even the bullets that impact at high velocity and expand to a fairly wide diameter tend to penetrate better than those that impact at a slower speed. I believe to some degree it's because higher impact velocities don't cause partial disintegration, as with many lead-cored bullets, so the increase in momentum due to the increased impact velocity is not offset by a loss in bullet mass. Essentially, because monos retain their weight so well, added velocity aids the bullet in penetrating deeper, which is the opposite of what we are used to with traditional bullet designs.
I believe this thread is touching on the "knock" of the TTSX/TSX bullet. I'm a firm believer they need to be driven fast to reach maximum potential.

I feel as though some of the failures -- for lack of a better term -- are from guys trying run traditional weight bullets instead of stepping down (180 in 30-06, 130 in 270, 140 in 7mm etc.).

Drop a few grains from your traditional bullet weight, push the lighter bullets hard and watch the results.
Originally Posted by shortactionsmoker
I believe this thread is touching on the "knock" of the TTSX/TSX bullet. I'm a firm believer they need to be driven fast to reach maximum potential.

I feel as though some of the failures -- for lack of a better term -- are from guys trying run traditional weight bullets instead of stepping down (180 in 30-06, 130 in 270, 140 in 7mm etc.).

Drop a few grains from your traditional bullet weight, push the lighter bullets hard and watch the results.
bingo!!!

I wouldn't dare hunt deer with a 168ttsx out of my 308 ..... Would it work? Probably but it wouldn't expand as fast as my 130's launched at 3050....

I swear I'm toying with the idea of ordering the 110ttsx in 30 cal and seeing if I can get 3300-3400 out of them. Think that would penetrate?
Yep -- especially on deer size game. It doesn't take a 50BMG to kill a deer. The light for weight TTSX/TSX's work. I also like the bone busting ability.

I like TTSX's north of 3200fps. Faster works even better. Just another dimension to the game.

A TSX of any flavor at 2800 doesn't excite me much.
FOr the 110's Think TAC would be a good powder to start with?
Originally Posted by SAKO75
Originally Posted by shortactionsmoker
I believe this thread is touching on the "knock" of the TTSX/TSX bullet. I'm a firm believer they need to be driven fast to reach maximum potential.

I feel as though some of the failures -- for lack of a better term -- are from guys trying run traditional weight bullets instead of stepping down (180 in 30-06, 130 in 270, 140 in 7mm etc.).

Drop a few grains from your traditional bullet weight, push the lighter bullets hard and watch the results.
bingo!!!

I wouldn't dare hunt deer with a 168ttsx out of my 308 ..... Would it work? Probably but it wouldn't expand as fast as my 130's launched at 3050....

I swear I'm toying with the idea of ordering the 110ttsx in 30 cal and seeing if I can get 3300-3400 out of them. Think that would penetrate?


Yes it will penetrate, and Barnes says ya can get 3500+ fps with a 24" barrel and TAC, nearly 3600 FPS with AA-2230. shocked LOL

Gunner
Kinda makes the 308 a different cartridge
Painfully different. wink

Gunner
Originally Posted by Jordan Smith
Originally Posted by BobinNH
Jordan the faster you drive some bullets,the expanded petals fold back flatter against the shank,creating a somewhat smaller frontal area....this allows a bit more penetration I think.


Bob, you're absolutely right. Although, even the bullets that impact at high velocity and expand to a fairly wide diameter tend to penetrate better than those that impact at a slower speed. I believe to some degree it's because higher impact velocities don't cause partial disintegration, as with many lead-cored bullets, so the increase in momentum due to the increased impact velocity is not offset by a loss in bullet mass. Essentially, because monos retain their weight so well, added velocity aids the bullet in penetrating deeper, which is the opposite of what we are used to with traditional bullet designs.


Jordan/Gunner: That is precisely the theory behind the construction of the old Bitterroot.It ran contra to our conventional thoughts on how standard bullets behave,and how velocity affects them.

I spent a small fortune on phone calls to Idaho,and tested Bill Steigers patience explaining it to me 25+ years ago...until I finally got it,and saw it action a few times. smile
Geez,

There you guys go getting all practical and stuff...
3550fps from a 257wby+100ttsx= rapid death out to 500+
[Linked Image]

1st recovered X type in many years of using them.
.308 130 TTSX
MV 3050 with CFE 223
Front quartering shot on a whitetail at 70 yds. DRT.
Recovered on opposite flank in the hide.
94.6 grains retained

Center punched another through the lungs (same distance) a few seconds later. DRT

YRMV


thanks for the pic and the story...

how many have you killed with that combo?

where in GA do you hunt?
I might try Barnes again. I'm one of the apparent few that has experienced poor expansion with the TSX. I've killed deer with 25 cal 100 gr TSX and 7mm 140. These failed to produce the internal damage some claim. I was really underwhelmed by the internal damage. All 3 deer looked like they were shot with an arrow with a field point.

I like the concept of a monometal bullet and associated penetration characteristics but can't go with the minimal damage TSX's caused. It's too bad because they have always been very accurate in almost every rifle I tried them.
I've always said you just can't push a Barnes too fast.
I've had way better performance with the tipped versions over the standard. And no risk of tip deformation or the hollow tip getting loaded up with crud from a pocket or whatever (had that happen, but doubt it affects bullet performance at rifle velocity.
About the worst that happens when drive them at warp speed is some or all of the petals could shear off
Originally Posted by SAKO75
thanks for the pic and the story...

how many have you killed with that combo?

where in GA do you hunt?


I load for the guys I hunt with. We've killed 30 some with 130s in 30 caliber. None went over 50 yards all one shot kills but for one that took the first one in the knee.

A couple of .308s like them at ~2950 and the rest at ~3050. Mostly the 30-06s lke them at 3150 with 53.5 grains Varget.
Originally Posted by SAKO75
thanks for the pic and the story...

how many have you killed with that combo?

where in GA do you hunt?


75,
Just the two this year with this load so far. Still have a month to go and hunting for 3-4 more to fill the freezer.

Shot 168 TSX's over Varget in my .308 up until last year. They worked from 40 yards on out. Very, very accurate. Blood trails were easy to follow. Pic shows a broadside, double lung exit with a 168 and she stumbled for around 30 yds if I remember correctly. Impact velocity est. @ 2600 fps.

[Linked Image]

I've come to the conclusion (along with many others) that the faster they impact, the better they work. 80gr TTSX's @ 3475 out of my 25-06 have been very impressive on whitetails and yotes.

110's in the .308 would be fun to work with someday.

FYI, I hunt in Screven County.

Good original writeup. Thanks for posting your results.



I have shot some 80 gr ttsx outta of my 257wby at 4160 at the muzzle. Deer from 10 yds to 300 have got an exit only recovered two outta about twenty
Only two bullets have been recovered.
© 24hourcampfire