I’d pay $30 more for the plain plex, all else being equal.
I have the E1 Plex on a CVA OptimaV2 .50 . My expertise is far more limited than many here but I find it to be a very good scope. If you throw in "for the money" I don't think you can beat it for a plain old hunting scope. I've had it side by side with a Leupold V3 3.5-10x40 checking in dim light and bright and prefer the Burris. Adjustments are firm and for me have held just fine. At $180 it's a deal. Still have a couple of USA scopes, 3.5-10x50 and 3-9x40 Fullfield II. They're over 15 years old and will be on the rifles mounted till Jesus comes.
As others have mentioned or insinuated I have no use for the E1 Ballistic Plex either. Of course for a 250 yard and under hunter why do I need what looks like a pile of dry spagetti dumped on a plate of glass.