Anybody use Lyman Orange Magic?
I have. Its garbage, as is the OP's Rooster Red. Saeco Green about the same. Lots of wax, mostly paraffin, which makes a good flux but a piss poor lubricant carrier. Paraffin is mostly decorative and works well for tinning, something we are trying not to accomplish.
Alox and SPG flat work for what 99.9% of us do with cast bullets and pressures under 40kpsi. Orange Magic kind of fits the bill in this regard, but it doesn't work like Alox or Texaco Taurac, both of which keep the steel "wet", even when hot.
SPG is allegedly Beeswax and petroleum jelly. Garbe made it specifically to keep fouling, especially black powder fouling soft. Mike Venturino swears by it, and few if any BP shooters swear at it. For most handgun pressures it should be right at home, but like alox it lubricates by volume of consumption, so generally more is more and is at home with large, square bottom grease grooves or multiple finned grease grooves like Louverin style bullets of old (or tumble lube bullets of today).
I've stocked up on LBT stuff and made my own and ran it side by side with LBT. LBT makes for a good substitute for Alox whether using as a groove hydraulic lube or surface lube with less smoke, less odor and higher load bearing and higher temp stability. LBT designed bullets pushed hard fare better with LBT lube as their groove size and depth are designed around it and less so volume lubes like Alox or SPG. Again, it depends on how hard you are trying to push them, how hot stuff is and what you want as an end result.
Beeswax with Lucas SYNTHETIC oil stabilizer, enough to soften to flow under pressure is what I have used as a sub for LBT. Its a few decades advanced from ordinary Alox and petro jelly and will run a couple feet of tube at max pressures without smoking or getting dry at the muzzle, still making a lube star upon exit.