Home
The favorite rock band thread got me thinking... What’s your favorite three member band? Which three member band do you think was the best/most talented?

Personally, I’m amazed at some of the sounds Rush could make with only three dudes. Who are some others?
Cream.
Posted By: efw Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
The Jimi Hendrix Experience
Rush
ZZ Top
Jimi Hendrix Experience
James Gang
Rush, Triumph
The Winery Dogs
Nirvana.
Posted By: papat Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
James Gang for sure
Rush
Motorhead

RUSH

The ARISTOCRATS https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6tvASVy5pk








Nirvana...you serious, dude??? That sht is woot doot.
ZZ Top. Everyone knows that.
Other than the ones mentioned....

Motorhead
Green Day
Posted By: 79S Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Originally Posted by Ducksanddogs
The favorite rock band thread got me thinking... What’s your favorite three member band? Which three member band do you think was the best/most talented?

Personally, I’m amazed at some of the sounds Rush could make with only three dudes. Who are some others?


Oh the Lumineers for the win... there last album was pretty dark
Cream
ZZ Top
Rush
Rush
The Police
Stray Cats
Grand Funk Railroad
Crosby, Stills and Nash
Genesis
Posted By: 79S Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Prince and the Revolution
Posted By: 79S Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Dirty Dancing OST

Bubbles: “Julian owns 55 copies of that movie.”
Julian: “[bleep] you, I don’t own a single copy of that.”
Ricky: “He also owns karaoke versions he likes to sing along to.”
Julian: “Bullshit – that’s what I bang to!”
Ricky: “He really likes that song – the one Patrick Swayze used to sing.” (She’s Like The Wind)
Julian: “When that song used to come on you’d be in the bars, you’d be dancing, waltzing to that tune, then the fingers start going down and [bleep] – that’s some good memories, but that’s about it.”
Bubbles: “Julian, what are you talking about? Finger banging?”
Julian: “Basically, yeah.”
Posted By: ribka Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Cream
RUSH
POLICE
ZZTOP
Definitely RUSH.
Originally Posted by viking
ZZ Top. Everyone knows that.



they would be the best liberal 3 piece rock group
Posted By: MAC Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
ZZ Top
Rush.
[quote=12344mag]Cream

I fixed that for you Toby!!
As far as three member bands go I'd have to say Rush and ZZTop have to be at the top of the list.
Originally Posted by cooper57m
Cream.

As usual on the fire, the first answer is correct.
ZZ Top
Rush
Jimi Hendrix Experience
Emerson, Lake, and Palmer
Jeff blando
Honky
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!
Originally Posted by viking
ZZ Top. Everyone knows that.


ditto, +1
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!

I only listen to Rush for as long as it takes to twist the knob. Can't stand that voice.
Posted By: WAM Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
ZZ Top
I can’t believe nobody’s mentioned Bananarama! Sheesh!
Originally Posted by papat
James Gang for sure


^^^THIS^^^

and ZZ Top.
Best is subjective, but my vote goes to King'sX.

ZZ Top is my pick.

I'll throw Hot Tuna into the fray . . .
Posted By: T_O_M Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Originally Posted by Skankhunt42
As far as three member bands go I'd have to say Rush and ZZTop have to be at the top of the list.


Yep, that's as good as it gets.

Tom
1. Motörhead
2. Rush
2. The Police
4. Nirvana (and I’m a gen-x’er too).
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!



Drinking beer and booze and firing up a fatty. Try it.

2112 rules!!
Posted By: Steve Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/07/20
Originally Posted by cooper57m
Cream.


Yep
R U S H.......accept no substitutes.

Peart was a lyrical genius
Originally Posted by cooper57m
Cream.



Yup.
Triumph
The Crickets
Genesis
Grand Funk Railroad
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!



Yer just jealous because he can sing.
The ones that started it all for Rock&Roll
1954
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

Bill Halley and the Comets
Beastie boys
I have always been astonished at the success of Rush. They surely sound like sh*t to me. To each, his own, I guess.

My answer is Cream. They only existed for about a year and a half, I am one of the few who saw them in concert. Chastain Park, Atlanta, October 1968. Great show.

I had a date with a "hippie chick" named "Easter."
Cream.No one else in this category, IMO, produced such full and rich sound.
Damn straight!



Come on now; Clapton, Bruce, Baker. That's all that needs to be said.
Best I ever heard in person was West(Leslie of Mountain) Bruce(Jack of Cream) and Laing(Corky of Mountain); they blew the roof of the place.
The American Cream
Rush
Posted By: Ken_L Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
Rush by far the most talented musicians of any mentioned.
Posted By: ribka Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
Originally Posted by Morewood
The Crickets
Genesis
Grand Funk Railroad


forgot about the crickets. incredible group
Add Rory Gallagher
Originally Posted by Ken_L
Rush by far the most talented musicians of any mentioned.



I agree. Cream was good and set the pace for a while, but in my opinion none of the members of Cream---Clapton included, could match the the members of Rush one for one. I don't dislike Clapton by any stretch, I just think he is way, waaaay overrated.

Genesis was a very talented 3-man group also, but I never was a fan of their style.

When Peter Banks left Yes, he formed a group called Flash. Their first album, In the Can, was outstanding. They had a bass player named Ray Bennett who played a mean bass, more melodic than what was usually heard in those days.

Jimi Hendrix's bands were no slouches either. All those guys were top drawer.
Grand Funk
All are great. Hendrix Experience, ZZ Top, and James Gang are up
There for me. But because no one mentioned it, and you kinda can’t NOT mention it (especially when you’re talking blues rock)

Steve Ray and Double Trouble.

They were a trio for a bit. Keys came later and then they were four. But the Trio was original. Stevie in front of Double Trouble.

When I saw him live, the key player only even came out for certain songs.
Pay very close attention to the lyrics, Rush had many messages in their songs.



SRV & Double Trouble tied with ZZ Top
Originally Posted by Hogwild7
Grand Funk



Solid contender, Grand Funk was a fantastic group.
Originally Posted by 12344mag
Pay very close attention to the lyrics, Rush had many messages in their songs.






So the Maples formed a Union
And demanded equal rights
‘The Oaks are just too greedy
We will make them give us light’
Now there’s no more Oak oppression
For they passed a noble law
And the trees are all kept equal
By hatchet,
Axe,
And saw…

That's the part a lot of these present day idiots known as Biden voters don't understand.
Cream
Grand Funk RAILROAD
ZZ Top
SRV

Depends on my mood.
Rush
ZZ Top
Originally Posted by bruinruin
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!

I only listen to Rush for as long as it takes to twist the knob. Can't stand that voice.


Agreed, Rush is for homosexuals.
Originally Posted by Swifty52
The ones that started it all for Rock&Roll
1954
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

Bill Halley and the Comets


I live right down the street from Bill Haley’s childhood home and first music studio, “Melody Manor”. The owner of the home keeps it as a guest house and has dedicated themself to cherishing the memory of the place.
Posted By: IZH27 Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
Originally Posted by mathman
Originally Posted by 12344mag
Pay very close attention to the lyrics, Rush had many messages in their songs.






So the Maples formed a Union
And demanded equal rights
‘The Oaks are just too greedy
We will make them give us light’
Now there’s no more Oak oppression
For they passed a noble law
And the trees are all kept equal
By hatchet,
Axe,
And saw…

That's the part a lot of these present day idiots known as Biden voters don't understand.


Witch Hunt

"Those who know what's best for us must rise and save us from ourselves"
Emerson, Lake & Palmer are by far the most talented trio of musicians mentioned.
Originally Posted by mathman


That's the part a lot of these present day idiots known as Biden voters don't understand.

Originally Posted by MarkFed

Agreed, Rush is for homosexuals.
Does every thread have to devolve to politics and homophobia?
A fellow can pinpoint pretty closely when folks went to high school by their choices here.
Originally Posted by Steve
Originally Posted by cooper57m
Cream.


Yep



This thread could have very well ended with the first mention of Cream.
Originally Posted by 3dtestify
Emerson, Lake & Palmer are by far the most talented trio of musicians mentioned.


They are damn good.
Originally Posted by Springcove
Rush, Triumph


This!!
Originally Posted by Jim in Idaho
A fellow can pinpoint pretty closely when folks went to high school by their choices here.

Yeah. I remember watching Keith Emerson spinning around on a piano at an Emerson Lake and Palmer concert in the later 70's. Dated.

Originally Posted by bruinruin
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!

I only listen to Rush for as long as it takes to twist the knob. Can't stand that voice.


Me either.
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by bruinruin
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!

I only listen to Rush for as long as it takes to twist the knob. Can't stand that voice.


Me either.

Not a 3 man band, but the voice I can't stand is Steve Perry of Journey.
Posted By: hanco Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
Cream
Originally Posted by cooper57m
Cream.

Yep.
Emerson, Lake, and Palmer.

Genesis was a three man band for a very short period of time. I really liked it when Phil Collins was the drummer And backup singer, Peter Gabriel was the man.
Posted By: gunzo Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
I never quite got used to Getty's voice, but after watching Rush some, listening more closely to their lyrics, the individual players, etc. puts them way close to the top.

ELP, CSN, super talented. I listened to a lot of ZZ at one time, but after a while most of their material sorta runs together for me. Cream was great no doubt.

SRV & Hendrix, were there other musicians on stage with those two? Sorry Double Trouble & the Experience, but the stars of he show overshadowed all you did.

Triumph, love 'em.

I can't say best, but I still like them as much or more after 50 years. Maybe rough around the edges, but hard working, get after it musicians. First 3 albums are must haves. Each member played like it was to keep them alive.

https://youtu.be/ZezWRc0VsPY



Not sure about the best but the Police get a special mention. Saw them live in 82 or 83. Great concert.
Originally Posted by 12344mag
Originally Posted by Whelenman
How can anybody listen to Rush???? The lead singer ( is you can call him that) sounds like a cat that got his tail caught in a screen door!!!!!!



Yer just jealous because he can’t sing.



I fixed this for you too Toby
Originally Posted by UPhiker
Originally Posted by mathman


That's the part a lot of these present day idiots known as Biden voters don't understand.

Originally Posted by MarkFed

Agreed, Rush is for homosexuals.
Does every thread have to devolve to politics and homophobia?


I had heard the all three of them have 270’s
Posted By: gunzo Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/08/20
Stupid post, stupid vid. Irrelevant.
Originally Posted by Whelenman
Originally Posted by UPhiker
Originally Posted by mathman


That's the part a lot of these present day idiots known as Biden voters don't understand.

Originally Posted by MarkFed

Agreed, Rush is for homosexuals.
Does every thread have to devolve to politics and homophobia?


I had heard the all three of them have 270’s
That's just low...
ZZ Top.
Posted By: gunzo Re: Best Three Member Rock Group - 10/09/20
Three members........

Srv and double trouble
© 24hourcampfire