Home
Posted By: Teal Cigars - 04/22/09
Wondering where you all order cigars, on-line. I haven't smoked in some years but have a hankering to give some a try. A Camacho specifically. There isn't anywhere local that sells them - closest being 105 miles away. Ain't driving that far for 1 stick.

Anyone have some place they use, reputable?
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
I get mine from Thompson's, but YMMV
Posted By: isaac Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
Teal...consider checking out the link below for ideas, reviews and, in general, some good cigar 411. You might be able to find the cigars you'd like for a cheaper price someplace else but this is not a bad site to begin with.

http://www.cigaraficionado.com/
Posted By: Lawdwaz Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
I never bought any through the mail, I would assume that NY state would put a tax on them also?

Over the counter cigars have gone up with new taxes recently. Only place to buy is on the Indian reservation.

I see a single pack of cigarettes is $7.00 in gas/convenience stores.
Posted By: Teal Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
I've gone thru their magazine, low on cigar content, high on Franklin Mint watches, Viagra, and Vegas. I want CIGAR content. If I may suggest - Cigar Magazine.

I've found it much more on task with cigars and the like - not so much "lifestyle of the pseudo-affluent".

We do have a good tobacconist here in town, they don't carry the Camacho brand and at the price a Camacho commands, I don't want to risk ordering one without some referrals from the campfire brethren.
Posted By: GoDucks1 Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
I usually go through cigarsintl.com. Check tampahumidor.com . If they sell camachos, they ship singles for free.
Posted By: San Antonio Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
http://www.cigarsinternational.com/
http://www.jrcigars.com/
http://www.famous-smoke.com/
My preferred internet suppliers. Hurry, as of May 1 new higher taxes are coming.
Posted By: The_Real_Hawkeye Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
Originally Posted by teal
Wondering where you all order cigars, on-line. I haven't smoked in some years but have a hankering to give some a try. A Camacho specifically. There isn't anywhere local that sells them - closest being 105 miles away. Ain't driving that far for 1 stick.

Anyone have some place they use, reputable?
Soon you'll be able to get the good stuff, i.e., Cubans.
Posted By: shootem Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
Check out JR's. And their store brands are pretty doggone good particularly the La Gloria takeoffs. Several stores here in NC and I'll probably run by one tomorrow on my way home.

http://www.jrcigars.com/
Posted By: Teal Re: Cigars - 04/22/09
I've had Cubans. To be honest, I feel to my very non-expert cigar palate, that a good Dominican or Honduran is every bit as good, if not better than the Cubans I had in Jamaica. YMMV...
Posted By: GoDucks1 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
There is absolutely no reason to say that a Cuban is better than a cigar produced in the DR, Hond., or Nicarauga, without smoking it. Obviously, there are some quality control issues associated with cubans, and there are some fantastic blends being developed outside the ISOM.
Posted By: 17ACKLEYBEE Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Originally Posted by teal
Wondering where you all order cigars, on-line. I haven't smoked in some years but have a hankering to give some a try. A Camacho specifically. There isn't anywhere local that sells them - closest being 105 miles away. Ain't driving that far for 1 stick.

Anyone have some place they use, reputable?


Maybe Bill Klintone will come on line here a share what his source for good cigars is. wink
Posted By: NathanL Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
The Cubans day has come and gone. They got left behind...funny with no money how that happens.

I've never ordered them I buy them at a local shop but I really don't do much quantity.
Posted By: RickBin Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
The best smokes in the world still come from the Vueltabajo.

A few things I've noted:

1] A WHOLE lot more inferior-grade smokes seem to be coming off the island. The QC is still generally there for factory stuff, it's just that low-end stuff that would have never seen the light of day is now banded and boxed and sold by "entrepeneurs". A cash-poor country/populace will monetize it's premium crop.

But the premium stuff is still being produced in the legit factories, and it's still as good as it's ever been ... when you can get it (the real stuff, I mean)!

In a similar vein:

2] A WHOLE lotta sticks that are legitimately "Cuban" are NOT bought from factory stores, and have not gone through the still-rigourous factory QC process. Which is to say, just because somebody's uncle went to Cuba and paid a taxi driver $50 for a box of Lanceros doesn't mean he's got the goods. Yeah, I know, the guy works at the factory, and steals the raw materials and packaging, and makes it at home during his spare time, yada, yada.

It ain't the same! If a traveler to Cuba did not source the box at a factory store and pay retail there (like $300 a box for some of the better vitolas), he's got moonshine. That's not to say there's not good 'shine, but it's still 'shine, and Macallan 18 it will never be.

In Cuba, factory or bust! FAKE HABANOS IN HAVANA

3] A WHOLE lotta guys who think they've smoked Habanos have smoked nothing but counterfeits, often made in Central America. I've seen wildly divergent claims as to the ratio of legit/counterfeit sticks on the US black market, and even the most conservative estimates usually consider the lion's share of "inventory" to be bogus. If I see one more box of "Esplendidos" with a glass top, or "Habanos" in cellophane sleeves, or Cuban maduros ...

Some counterfeits are damned hard to distinguish (until you light one, usually), but an awful lot are obvious fakes to anyone with half a clue.

Here's one clue, if they smell like ammonia, welp, there's your sign. Sometimes, you don't even need to look at foot cuts, or labels, or color-sort, or stamps, or boxes. Just check the waft and a young box (most counterfeits are young/still sick) will readily give itself away.

4] Here's where I think the comments about QC are well placed: Even legit, factory Habanos, same brand/vitola, you can often note a distinct difference in quality depending on what country/establishment outside of Cuba you buy them (and that NEVER used to happen). Which is to say, a box of Lusitanias sourced from Harrods in London, or Switzerland, is often noticeably better than a box sourced from Canada or Mexico. I'm not the first to notice that countries with strong currencies seem to have better "luck" scoring the Class A chit from Fidel.

HABANOS SWITZERLAND

There are a lot of good non-ISOM cigars. I'm a fan of Honduran stuff, especially Villazon. And I've tried a lot of the top-tier non-ISOM stuff, some of which cost more than a genuine trophy Habano.

None can hold a candle to the true, genuine, premium stuff that still comes from the Vueltabajo. OK, not the garbage hurricane leftovers that would have never made it of the island prior to, oh, say the Soviet collapse. I'm talking the genuine article.

Find me a better Churchill than a R&J.
A better double corona than a HdeM or a Lucy.
A better robusto than a Epicure #2 (not such a big fan of the Cohiba).
A better petite corona or torpedo than a Monte.

And the best corona gorda in the world continues to be a Punch Punch.

Not that I'd ever indulge in contraband or anything. I'm just speculating here. wink

rb
Posted By: RickBin Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
BTW: Gotta agree with shootem on jrcigars, AND on the LGC seconds (El Credito, right?). Be warned, Carrillo's stuff will knock you on your a$$ if you're not careful. wink

Even with the price increase, for bang-for-your-buck, it's hard to beat Connies (Consuegra -- Villazon seconds) too.
Posted By: NathanL Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Travel to countries where they are legal and they are good cigars...but even the people who have a choice will tell you it's not clear cut that just because they come from Cuba they are the top dog like they once were just for "being" from Cuba.
Posted By: RickBin Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Gotcha, Nathan.

I can accept that we disagree. wink

Posted By: NathanL Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
I don't know if we disagree. Used to be a "cuban" was the best no questions asked. Now just because it's "cuban" I don't think it means that anymore. A lor of other areas now produce great cigars. Doesn't mean certain cubans can't be the best.
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
That's some pretty good info, thanks Rick!

I've just started to look into better sticks than the cheap ass Muriels and Swishers that are so abundant and over priced here in Wis, so this content is quite limited in contrast to the above.

Teal, I am in Miami alot and have been buying from http://www.cubancrafters.com/index.php I've never bought via mail order, as I just purchase in store, but I know they do mail orders. I'm not sure what flavored stick you desire, but a good valued sampler pack of 12 sticks can be had for about $25 (plus shipping) http://www.cubancrafters.com/products.php/item_id/289

I bought this sampler pack and am about half way through it. Personaly I like the Cuban crafters cabinet cigar the best. It has a creamy buttery taste. Stout but good and smooth. Outta those 12, a guy should be able to find a cigar to his liking. I am gonna try the CUPIDO TUXEDO stick (which is not included in the sampler pack). They run about $175 per 25 sticks (dependanding on the size).

I'm hoping Barak will weigh in on this thread. I saw him post some good info about 4 years ago, but have forgoten most everything he wrote.

Cuban crafters cigar shop Miami Fla
[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: shootem Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Code
 Maybe Bill Klintone will come on line here a share what his source for good cigars is.  


Seems I remember the El Camino Kid depended more on the marinade than on the tobacco.
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
www.tampahumidor.com is a darn good place to order from.

As far as a "best cigar" goes, I would try the R&J Churchill Reserve 7.0 x 54. My favorite, and I've tried and go thru a lot of cigars.
The Habano's that I buy in some oveseas AP's are excellent choices, but in my opinion don't compare to the ones from the D.R. I don't think that I've gotten any fakes other than whats available at Baghdad IAP.

Acid Kuba Kubas are decent if your looking for something different.

CAO Gold Maduro are a good choice for medium smoke.

Rocky Patel V 1992 are another great choice.
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Can you describe in words what those taste like? I'm looking for something that has 'creamy buttery' taste myself, in medium or stronger.
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Which one in particular are you asking about?

If you want a smooth cigar with the flavors that your asking about, I would suggest a CAO Gold Torpedo 6.0 x 52 with a good cup of coffee and a dollop of Bailey's irish creme. Best cigar and drink combo there is in my opinion.
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
I was thinking with a beer, but I bet you're right about a stick with some Bailey's irish creme
Posted By: Steve Re: Cigars - 04/23/09

Here's a extensive list of vendor off a another site that I frequent http://www.cigarasylum.com . I haven't tried them all, but if their listed they're probably reliable. YMMV

Cigar Vendors

Arnolds Tobacco Shop
Atlantic Cigar Company +
BestCigarPrices.com +
Black Cat Cigar Company
Bonita Smoke Shop +
BuyMoreCigars
cheapercigars.com
Cigar.com +
Cigarbid.com
Cigar Hut
Cigars Direct
cigarobsession
Cigar-ette City
Cigar Express
Cigars Around the World
Cigars International +
Cigar King
Cigar Place
Cigars Etc.com
Cigars Etc.com
Corona Cigar +
Duke City Cigars
duquecigars
El Fumador
Famous Smoke Shop +
Fuller's Pullers
Fumee World
Holts Cigars +
islandsmokeshop
Jays Cigars
jrcigars +
Lil' Brown Smoke Shack +
L.J.Peretti
Mike's Cigars +
Mr. Bundles
Neptune Cigars
New Havana Cigars
niceashcigars
Old Virginia Tobacco Company
Paradise Cigar Company
Phatash.com
phoenixcigar
Premium Cigars
Rocky's Cigars
Rigoscigars
Serious Cigars
Silo Cigars.com
Slipperyrockcigars
SmokeAll.com
Southside Cigars
Tampa Humidor
Tampa Sweethearts
The Cigar Humidor
thepartysource
Thompson Cigar
Tinderbox
TNT Cigars
Taboo Cigars +
Show Me Your Ash
Tobacco World Cigars


Accessories:

Cigarmony +
Cigar Solutions
Cubancrafters
Heartfelt Industries +


Cutters

Cigar Cutters
Xikar

Lighters

elighters
Lava Premium Butane
Vector


Humidors:

Aristocrat Humidors
Avallo Humidors
Bargain Humidors
Cheap Humidors +
Cigar Humidors
Cigar Humidor Store
Cigar Solutions � Avallo dealer
Cuban Crafters
Humidor Vault
Humidors Wholesaler
Tampa Humidor

Humidor How-to

Cigarnexus
Humidor-guide

Price Listings

Cigarcyclopedia
Cigar Spider
Price Grabber
Pronto


Daily Specials

Cigar Monster +
Joe Cigar +
Today's Cigar
cigar.com/DailyDeal

Bidding Sites

Cigar Auctioneer
Cigarbid
JR Cigars


Manufacturers:

Ashton
Avo
Bucanero
Cao
cigarfamily.com
Cigars of Brazil Dona Flor
Davidoff
Drew Estate
Espanosa-Ortega Brands (601)
El Rey de los Habanos (Pepin)
Felipe Gregorio
Gran Habano
Gurkha
Illusione Cigars
La Flor Dominicana
NUB Cigar
Oliva
Padilla
Padron
rockypatel
Santa Clara Puros
Torano


Magazine, Information, and Review Sites:

Cigar Advisor
Cigar Aficionado
Cigar Blog 101
Cigars.com
cigarchoice
Cigarcyclopedia
Cigar Diary
Cigar Envy
Cigar Fan
Cigar Inspector
Cigar Jack
Cigar Magazine
cigarplaces
cigarsearch
Cigars-Review
Cigar Weekly
fujipub.com
Holy Smoke
Internet Cigar Group
Select Cigars
Smoke Magazine
Stogie Fresh
Stogie Guys
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
I've ordered from several on your list. I still like www.tampahumidor.com for the service and price.
If you need a single, no problem, cutters, lighters, humidors ect, they have them.
Posted By: Barak's Womn Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Originally Posted by 379 Peterbilt
I'm hoping Barak will weigh in on this thread. I saw him post some good info about 4 years ago, but have forgoten most everything he wrote.

I'll alert him to it the next time I talk to him. He's currently off in another state working on a pretty time-intensive project for his employer. I'm not sure how much he's reading the Campfire right now.

Penny
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Me, I like a cigar that starts out mellow, and get spicy toward the middle thru the end. Plus, I dig the taste of a good Maduro wrapper. Any recommendations, I'm a member of Thompson's zCigar club, they send me all kinds of deals and offer's. Personally my daily Cigar is a rather cheap one, Paso Dobles with the maduro wrapper. Les
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Thank you Penny. I'm sure he can add to this.
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Some of my favorites,

Partegas black label 6.0 x 60 Piramide
Rocky Patel "V" 1992 6.0 x 60 60's"
CAO VR 6.0 x 52 Cathedral
Olivia "O" Maduro 7.0 x 50 Churchill
CAO LX 2 6.5 x 52 Belicoso
Acid Kuba Kuba 5 x 54
CAO Italia 6.25 x 54 Edge Battalion
Rocky Patel Conn. 6.0 x 60
CAO Brazilia 6.25 x 54 Samba
CAO Gold 6.0 x 52 Torpedo
La Gloria Cubana 6.5 x 52 Torpedo
Rocky Patel 2X Maduro 6.5 x 52
Montechristo #2 6.0 x 50 Torpedo
Romeo Y Julieta 7.0 x 54 Churchill
Olivia "G" 6.5 X 52 Torpedo

Posted By: mathman Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Quote
Find me a better ... robusto than a Epicure #2


Partagas Serie D No.4, not that I've ever indulged in such a thing. grin
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Originally Posted by rgrx1276
Some of my favorites,

Partegas black label 6.0 x 60 Piramide
Rocky Patel "V" 1992 6.0 x 60 60's"
CAO VR 6.0 x 52 Cathedral
Olivia "O" Maduro 7.0 x 50 Churchill
CAO LX 2 6.5 x 52 Belicoso
Acid Kuba Kuba 5 x 54
CAO Italia 6.25 x 54 Edge Battalion
Rocky Patel Conn. 6.0 x 60
CAO Brazilia 6.25 x 54 Samba
CAO Gold 6.0 x 52 Torpedo
La Gloria Cubana 6.5 x 52 Torpedo
Rocky Patel 2X Maduro 6.5 x 52
Montechristo #2 6.0 x 50 Torpedo
Romeo Y Julieta 7.0 x 54 Churchill
Olivia "G" 6.5 X 52 Torpedo



the ones I bolded I have had, and yep, I do enjoy them. Les
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Wife calls me a cheap azz when it comes to Cigars though, I only buy small bundles of the one I like,but have a 100 cigar humidor. Which is usually full of the Paso Bobles. grin Now if ya add Scotch to the Mix, I gotta have good stuff, Glenfidditch 18 year. grin
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Les,
While I smoke all of the cigars on my list, Both of my humidors always contain these.

Montechristo #2 Torpedo (Habanos)
CAO Gold Torpedo
Acid Kuba Kuba
La Gloria Cubana Torpedo
Romeo Y Julieta Churchill (Habanos)

Can't go wrong with any of them. I buy the Habanos to give to associates back home, so they can impress their friends, not because I think they are the best smoke.
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
MIL has a line on some good cuban's they are actually damn good cigar's. She gets them form a buddy that travels to Canada all the time. I think the Acid Kuba Kuba is one of my favorites though.
Posted By: ChasR Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Wow !! Great list - thanks! Been using JRCigars for a number of years and have had great service. Generally smoke Don Tomas and La Gloria but have dabbled in various others.

Since I'm 'Semi-Retired' (which means I don't have a full time job but I'm too young to get SS!), I just wandered in from the hot tub where I had a cup of coffee with a cigar while soaking my 'troubles' away.
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Had a bud try to get a box of habanos thru from canada last year, and had them confiscated by customs.
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Wow, My wife was told by customs when she came back from Argentina a few years ago, a box was ok, as it is for Personal use.
Posted By: mathman Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
That's not the case. In fact it's even against the rules for a US citizen to sample the goods in other countries where they are legally sold.
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Really, so why would the custom's inspector have told my wife that? crazy
Posted By: rgrx1276 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
Some people have shiite luck when it comes to customs, some don't. I've been fortunate.
Posted By: mathman Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
They know their regs about as well as some postal or UPS counter employees know the regs about shipping firearms.
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 04/23/09
That figures, this was back in 2001 when my wife brought me the box full, tis when I got my humidor., grin It is well seasoned now. Les
Posted By: shootem Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Ran by JR's in Burlington,NC late yesterday afternoon on my way back to Mooresville after slaving over a hot customer base all day. Picked up some La Gloria Wavell's and had a nice relaxed smoke on the way home, tempered with a bubbly Diet Dr Pepper. Sun roof open, listening to the wind, watching the sunset. It was a good day made better.
Posted By: Barak Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Quote
I'm hoping Barak will weigh in on this thread.

My favorite Internet source is cigarsinternational.com; but I have also had good experiences with jrcigars.com and cigar.com. I like Thompson's International for non-cigar cigar stuff, like humidors and lighters and humidifiers and cutters and so on, because they generally have good prices; but I haven't had a lot of luck with their actual tobacco--especially their house brands.

I'm a very light smoker, so I don't have extensive experience with hundreds of brands; but when I think "smooth and buttery," two come to mind. The first would be a Padron Maduro: I'm not sure a smoother cigar exists. The second would be CAO's new mx2 model (mx2 means "Maduro times two"--it has two maduro wrappers, one layered over the other). It has a very dark, sweet, thick flavor that might be described as "buttery."
Posted By: Steve_NO Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Originally Posted by NathanL
The Cubans day has come and gone. They got left behind...funny with no money how that happens.

I've never ordered them I buy them at a local shop but I really don't do much quantity.



I do the same thing....it would be cheaper to buy from Thompson's or JR....but I want to make sure my handy downtown cigar shop stays in business despite recessions, layoffs, hurricanes and tobacco taxes, so I buy mine there. Plus, I like to squeeze and sniff.
Posted By: shootem Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Padon Maduro is duly noted. I'm a light cigar smoker as well and that sounds like my preference. Have a JR's local and will check out the brand.
Posted By: Red44spl Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
I usually buy mine in Tucson, but have had good luck with JR's
Posted By: Savage_99 Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Tobacco Valley was the land along the Connecticut river from Hartford all the way to S. Vermont. Its a rich flat river bottom land. The farming is just about all gone now for tobacco. I remember when it was busy. Tobacco Valley

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Barak Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Originally Posted by shootem
Padon Maduro is duly noted. I'm a light cigar smoker as well and that sounds like my preference. Have a JR's local and will check out the brand.

Oh yeah. If you're a light smoker and you haven't yet tried one of those, you owe it to yourself. Not a cheap stogie--about $7.00/stick around here or so--but not a premium ($15-20) or super premium (>$50) either.

One of the best things about the Padron is its characteristic easy draw. It means you get scads and scads of flavorful, creamy, off-white smoke with no effort.

Even if I could afford to smoke one or two every day--and enjoyed smoking that often--I wouldn't, because I want to continue to be surprised by the quality and the flavor, not to become accustomed to it.
Posted By: jackfish Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
http://phoenixcigar.com/shop/

I stick with short, fat cigars as I don't have two hours to smoke one. I also like the flavor of Central American cigars over that of Dominican Republic cigars, except perhaps the Bauza Robusto.

Astral Besos
Baccarat Rothschild
Don Tomas Clasico Rothchild (my main smoke)
Helix X550 Robusto
Hoyo de Monterrey Rothchild
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend Robusto Grande
Joya De Nicaragua Antano Consul
Punch Rothchild Natural
Puros Indios Rothchild
Te Amo Robusto

If I have more time, for me there is nothing like a Padron 6000 or Te Amo Toro.
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 04/24/09
Thanks Barak, 'preciate it. I'll try that Padron out.
Posted By: isaac Re: Cigars - 04/25/09
Yesterday, after a couple of hours work and hearing that we were going to be in the high 70-80's for a few days, I left for my place in Rehobeth. As I usually do, I stopped in at my favorite cigar joint to gather up the latest 411 (his opinion, of course) and the man gifted me a Perdomo (lot 23) saying he felt Nicaragua was the leader in cigar making these days. Anyways, went to the boardwalk,staring at the ocean and lit her up. Not a bad cigar, at all. Mild to slightly moderate to my untrained palate.

Today, after a stop at the Levi, Brook's Brothers and Gourmet Kitchen outlet stores, I think I'll buy Barak's Patron recommendation.

Beautiful day at the beach. Watched the surf fisherman try their luck but saw no one enjoying success. I'm thinking we're still 3 weeks early with all the rain and cool temps we've been having.

Anyways, have a good weekend gang!
Posted By: GoDucks1 Re: Cigars - 04/28/09
I'd recommend anything Padilla (minus the Obsidian) and anything Oliva (especially the Serie V).
Posted By: rifle Re: Cigars - 04/28/09
Montecristo,Opus x and R&J's here.....at least two a day!
Posted By: elkfitter Re: Cigars - 04/28/09
[email:http://uptowncigar.com/]http://uptowncigar.com/[/email]

Great service , great prices and selection.
Posted By: 3sixbits Re: Cigars - 04/28/09
When you get some, do like Billy Bob Clinton does and soak them insiderher. Gives them a pork flavor.
Posted By: 379 Peterbilt Re: Cigars - 05/29/09
I smoked up some sticks from Cuban Crafters in Miami. Readers digest type review;

Cuban crafters cabinet (I smoked various sizes) I thought these were damned good tasting. They tend to canoe, but they're powerfull and very tastey.

Cuban crafters cupido criollo. This is hands down my favoite from CC. Much like the cabinet, just a little better in taste. awesome, and reasonably priced

Don Kiki white and brown labels - both very good tasting. Kiki red and green labels - yawn.

Medina 1959. I've only smoke one of these, so it might not be fair here, but I thought this one was bad. It is supposed to be the flagship stoggie of CC. I let this stick sit in the humi for 3 weeks before I smoked it. I'm not sure how to describe it, plywood or sawdust. Hopefully others had/have better luck, as I know CC prides thenselves in this one.

Cuban crafter contraband. These sticks are stupid spendy. Not my type of go to everyday smoke, but definatley a good tasting cigar. decent burn, draw as well as taste. But they're $300 something per 25.

Arte Cubano (Honduras) 7x48 - These are dogshit. A friend and myself smoked a couple of these, and we both agree it was a total waste of $40. I have about 21 of these left if anyone wants them or actually likes them, if so PM me. Otherwise they're going in the garbage. Unless my dog wants to chew on 'em.

CC cupido tuxedo. These are spendy, like $7 ea. I've only smoke one, so again take this with a grain of salt, but for the flavor they offer, they should be sold in cheap bundles at about $2 per. This one tasted "okay", but not $180 per 25 okay.

Barak, per your recomendation I smoked up a 5 pack sampler of rocky patels, ordered from Thompson, and I thought they were pretty good. Thanks.
Posted By: Kimber7man Re: Cigars - 05/29/09
I recently have been going through a stash of Rocky Patel Fusions - nice smooth smoke for me...

However, sis and her fiance got back from Cuba last week and for my birthday I got two Cohibas...
Posted By: Steve_NO Re: Cigars - 05/29/09
I smoked a ton of Cubans in Hong Kong and China, and didn't think they were by and large any better than a number of other Dominican or Hondurans. I'll still put an Avo No.2 up against about anything.....except an absolute top of the line and perfectly fresh Davidoff or R&J. And they cost eleven bucks instead of twenty.


Many Cubans have quality control, package sealing and storage issues. I try to only buy the ones in tubes which give you some guarantee they won't be dried out.
Posted By: Violator22 Re: Cigars - 05/29/09
I like my Rocky's and Acid over any of the Cuban cigar's the MIL has given me. Les
Posted By: shootem Re: Cigars - 08/11/09
Hey Barak...couldn't get those Padron Maduros at either of the JRs I go by now & then but still keeping my eyes open for them. HOWEVER, I did try some Punch Pita Maduros on a whim. Very nice for a $16/5-pack cigar. Smooth, easy drawing, even burning with a nice aftertaste. Very little flavor change till I tossed it at the last couple of inches. Think they're a 6.2 x 50.
Posted By: gwindrider1 Re: Cigars - 08/11/09
The problem I experienced when first trying to find the "right" cigar for myself is that everyone's palate for cigars is different. All the recommendations from seasoned cigar smokers left me unimpressed. I see no way around spending the time and money to try various brands, sizes, and wrappers.

If you subscribe to Cigar Afficianado, or similar publications, you will get the reviews and comments on various sticks, which can help you decide which to try.

After dealing with all the major internet and mail order suppliers, I have settled on dealing with Famous Smoke Shop.

My personal search ended when I found Padron Maduros. It has become my go to smoke, although I still enjoy some variety from time to time. It just takes time and money to find what is right for you. Enjoy the journey!
© 24hourcampfire