Home
Posted By: renegade50 Blue or cerracoat - 01/19/18
Got the metal on my marlin 36g down to 320 level
The stock and forearm are well on their way with tru oil being done.
I have used various blueing products over the years, most seem to wear away. Did use blue wonder several yrs ago on a Lyman bp pistol in the white which came out fairly well.
I can get a cerracoat job done for $100 on all the metal and the 7 visible screws
Gonna leave the hammer and loading gate original blue if I go this route.
Kinda leaning towards gloss black on the cerracoat if I go that route or one of the " new " cerracoat gun blue colors

Ain't got a cerracoated gun and this 36g is kinda my foul weather rifle and that is what I'm kinda leaning to getting done.

Basically right now I can give this a acetone bath, a heat cycle and another acetone bath.
Go up town and they blast it and paint it and cook it . And it will be done and probably alot more weather proof the a home blue.


Going the hot blue route is expensive as heck. 250 bucks....
I paid 165 otd for the rifle at a pawn shop back in Sept, got 50 in a receiver sight and 20 in a new front site
So basically I got around 250 into the rifle itself . Be right under 400 with a cerracoating and the materials i have used so far, even less with a home cold blue.


Any of ya all got pics or comments of cerracoated rifles or a durable home blue product experience/ pic.

Thanks....



Posted By: Fireball2 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/20/18
The most durable coating I've ever seen is powder coat. There is zero chance of scratching it and it's warm to carry in cold weather. I have been way less than happy with 3 or 4 I've had ceracoated.
The lighting makes this looks mustard color, but it is not. I went with the heavy texture because this rifle was rusted and pitted. You can also get smooth, and any color you want. I've since shortened the barrel to 20". Two years ago elk hunting we had 21 inches of rain in three days and I had no issues with it.


[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/20/18
Was it bad cerracoating jobs that were done? Prep work , dirty or round glass ball media for blasting or bad paint spraying and cooking?
The place I'm thinking of getting mine done has a good rep . They do alot of business outside of fort campbell. I have seen their work . I'm gonna go with this place. Have asked about their media, they said they use clean oxide stuff 160 grit and they don't use any round media cause it dimples metal and causes bad adhesion. Ain't got a cerracoated gun so I'm gonna throw the dice. That is a pretty cool looking finish on that 99.
Posted By: gunswizard Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/20/18
If you like cerracoat and have found a reputable firm and have seen their work the I'd say go for it. While it's fine to ask for advice and opinions, in the end you should go with what makes you happy.
Posted By: Jerseyboy Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/20/18
Fireball, tell us more about your Savage 99. It looks to be a 99 F with lever safety. What caliber is it? What kind of finish is on the wood? Who did your powdercoat job?
Posted By: Fireball2 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/21/18
Originally Posted by Jerseyboy
Fireball, tell us more about your Savage 99. It looks to be a 99 F with lever safety. What caliber is it? What kind of finish is on the wood? Who did your powdercoat job?


It is a 99F featherweight in .358 Winchester. I disassembled it, a local shop prepped it, taped it off, and coated it. The wood is just painted. I literally had water running thru the rifle elk hunting and the outside just sheds water. The inside need to be dried and oiled.
Posted By: 79S Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/22/18
I have a rifle in a model 70 that was cerakoted in midnight blue. I bought it that way, if you want to stick to a more traditional blue I would go that route. I been pretty happy with it, went on a winter caribou hunt last weekend temps ranged from -21 to 14 and held up very well.
Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/22/18
Ceracoat bas been mighty unimpressive to me. I would never waste the money on it again.
Posted By: 79S Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
Originally Posted by Sitka deer
Ceracoat bas been mighty unimpressive to me. I would never waste the money on it again.


Why were you not impressed?
Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by Sitka deer
Ceracoat bas been mighty unimpressive to me. I would never waste the money on it again.


Why were you not impressed?


Less than two weeks of riding in a raft had rubbed the ceracoat off in large areas... job was done by someone with a great deal of experience.

Several rifles that had significant failures in minor dings...

I had a job done by a name Smith and it looked very bad... obviously an application issue...

To my way of thinking it is not worth doing for free, let alone being so pricey.
Posted By: HiredGun Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
If it is going to be in the weather much bluing starts rusting right away and can be rubbed through in very short order. Check out the durability tests. For the real skeptics there are a bunch of tests published on youtube by private individuals that show the same as results as long as it's properly installed.



Cerakote done properly should be at least as tough as what ever is under it. Over tool steel they are almost impossible to scratch. I have put it on vise grips and you can destroy a piece of pipe with them and not wear it off the tips on the jaws. On a Stanley hammer head you can pound in a bunch of 16 penny nails and it doesn't touch the face of that hammer. I live on the Oregon coast and have a test barrel I let people beat on and scratch and you have to put a very sharp edge into it to get it to scratch. A hammer simply dents the steel even glancing blows won't expose the metal under it. This barrel lives in a ditch or buried in the wife's flower bed and has lived out there 24/7 since about 200 when we were certified in it's application. Where ever it is through the finish is rusted but as long as the base metal doesn't show it still looks new.

Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
How does one explain failures by a highly regarded applicator with a lot of experience?
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
Maybe changed to glass based media to blast and left tiny dimpled surface?
Or used dirty media? Ratio,s of materials incorrect? Bad cook?
Another employee did it.
Who knows?

Ain't all the up and up cerracoating outfits supposed to go to seminar classroom and hands on training and be approved by cerracoat also?






"Rough" oxide media blasting is supposed to have better adhesion

I got my metal down to 220 grit right now.
Degrease, heat , degrease again is all I got left to do.
Then I'm gonna run it uptown to em.
I have seen alot of their work on people's guns around town
They wouldn't be able to do business around Clarksville/ fort campbell if they did stuff half assed
Word would get spread around fast among the active duty, retirees and everyone in this community.
My biggest question was type of media and making sure they use clean media
160 grit oxide stuff and clean. Spoke with them about me turning in metal in the white and degreased by myself just for my own peice of mind
They said that is Good , but you don't have too.
The work is guaranteed and If it fails they will redo it no charge I then asked them if they would blast it back to in the white if I didn't want it redone
They said ya and give me half of cost back.
I am gonna get it done.
Only 100 bucks.
If it turns to s h i t down the line then I will just home blue it.

See how it turns out.
Posted By: HiredGun Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/23/18
Originally Posted by Sitka deer
How does one explain failures by a highly regarded applicator with a lot of experience?


It depends. In almost 10 years now I have seen a lot of the popular forum applicators Cerakote and gunsmithing work and these are the problems I have observed. There are dozens of ways to do it wrong and only one right way. If they are certified, you are assured at least they knew the right way at one time but still is no guarantee that over time that applicator might have started taking shortcuts to cut costs or has modified the process in an effort to get better results that in the long run has negative repercussions. If a certified applicator gets enough complaints for poor work or bad business practices he can lose his certified status and listing on the applicator locater. It's not much but it's the only protection you have that the applicator is doing it right. Uncertified applicators can do whatever they want and there is no consumer protection of any kind. Trained or not it boils down to the integrity of the applicator to follow the directions to the letter and not deviate in any way.

The test of time is the one that counts because they all look good right when they are first done. Some skip critical areas leaving metal exposed to rusting or wear. Be wary of applicators who are not charging enough. To do Cerakote right takes a lot time, expensive equipment that wears out over time and consumables including a fair amount of electricity. It calls specifically for 100-120 grit. This is a huge one so ask to actually see the media and compare it with what is really in the cabinet. If it is dusty it needs changed out. It the media is used or too fine Cerakote will not be near as durable as it's rated for. That mesh grit can be hard to get. I have to drive 4 hours each way and it's $2 a pound if I buy at least 200 pounds. Each gun wrecks about 5 pounds of media. 5 gallons of acetone is $75. It will only do at most 10 rifles. There are other approved degreasers but none as good.

Another occasional problem is a shop may do so many guns people assume they are doing it right when in fact they are doing it wrong. They may unknowingly intimidate the consumers from pointing out problems because the applicator is so highly regarded that they become unapproachable. If a job just goes bad he should be offering to fix it before you have to ask. Unfortunately, that almost never happens and Cerakote takes the blame for a poor performance.
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
Hiredgun. Good info!!!100 - 120 grit , im gonna ask again about their blasting media. so I'm kinda doing a good thing at least with my acetone baths before I bring it up. Im not gonna mention it .They have their certificate on display at least. The price I got is for a lever barelled action , 1/2 mag tube, forearm end cap, bottom receiver plate, and 9 receiver screws. All in the white. They have a price list for all different categories. Mine fell into lever hunting rifle price 1 color for 100, some of their prices went up to 300 for alot more stuff being done to more complex firearms.
Should I plug my barrel muzzle and breach end with wooden dowel prior to bring it up or check to make sure they do something like that?
Posted By: Fireball2 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
I've had a few rifles with ceracoat and they scratched easier than if I had Krylon'd them. Ridiculous. To me it's a scam run by scammers. Never had any experience to show me otherwise. Maybe it can be done right, but I've never seen it.
Posted By: HiredGun Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
Originally Posted by Fireball2
I've had a few rifles with ceracoat and they scratched easier than if I had Krylon'd them. Ridiculous. To me it's a scam run by scammers. Never had any experience to show me otherwise. Maybe it can be done right, but I've never seen it.


Please explain what you mean by scam run by scammers. What is the scam and who is the scammer?
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
Sounds like alot shady outfits all across the country are doing some messed up stuff.
Posted By: liliysdad Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
No kidding...I have several Cerakoted rifles....and they are all very scratch and ding resistant. Duracoat, on the other hand, no as much.
Posted By: JoeMartin Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/24/18
Originally Posted by Fireball2
I've had a few rifles with ceracoat and they scratched easier than if I had Krylon'd them. Ridiculous. To me it's a scam run by scammers. Never had any experience to show me otherwise. Maybe it can be done right, but I've never seen it.

Dang Roy, you must have gone to school with my Dad, actually he may have been your teacher. He used black Krylon on his old shotguns, Joe.
Posted By: mike7mm08 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/26/18
Thinking a lot of "cerakote" is duracoat. So many outfits are doing it now a days are out to make a quick buck. They know even if they do a good job the average customer is going to be a one time deal. I would never send out a gun to be coated. I want to be able to deal with someone personally. Less likely to screw you if you can go pound on their door. Also complaints carry more weight among the local shooting community when coming from another local.
Posted By: Fireball2 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/27/18
Originally Posted by JoeMartin
Originally Posted by Fireball2
I've had a few rifles with ceracoat and they scratched easier than if I had Krylon'd them. Ridiculous. To me it's a scam run by scammers. Never had any experience to show me otherwise. Maybe it can be done right, but I've never seen it.

Dang Roy, you must have gone to school with my Dad, actually he may have been your teacher. He used black Krylon on his old shotguns, Joe.


$4 vs. $100 and the same results.
Posted By: RiverRider Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/27/18
I've been using Norrell Moly Resin for a few things and it seems to be a pretty good product. It is sprayed on using an airbrush and baked. I have refinished a couple of handguns that came out nicely, and most recently refinished a 77V barreled action that I received back from Pac-Nor in December. The Norrell website has (or at least HAD, at one time) some testing data on the product.

I like the appearance of the stuff. I'll be finding out more about its durability over the coming years.

I have an econo-custom 98 in .280 (a great shooter, even with its cheap A&B barrel) which I bought finished with Duracoat (allegedly). I don't have reason to doubt that this is what the finish is, but I honestly don't know it for a fact. It seems to be okay for the most part, but it is chipping off at the edge of the muzzle. I think I'm going to blast that finish off and Moly Resin it also.

I took photos of the 77 with my phone , but it's hard to get that camera to do what I want to show detail. Here's one anyway:

[Linked Image]



Attached picture xxx20180127_104957.jpg
Posted By: Horseman Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/29/18
I’ve also not been overly impressed with ceracoat. It shows superficial marks more than any other finish I own. I’ve got 3 guns coated and one duracoated flat turkey 870. The duracoated 870 holds up just as well as the ceracoated rifles and it gets carried a lot more.
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/30/18
Turned it in today
Gloss black way to reflective
Picked an "elite" series color midnight e-110
Told em to make a semi gloss
Showed a bunch of projects one color versus the other


Late next week
125 bucks.
See how it looks
Posted By: Sitka deer Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/31/18
Originally Posted by HiredGun
If it is going to be in the weather much bluing starts rusting right away and can be rubbed through in very short order. Check out the durability tests. For the real skeptics there are a bunch of tests published on youtube by private individuals that show the same as results as long as it's properly installed.



Cerakote done properly should be at least as tough as what ever is under it. Over tool steel they are almost impossible to scratch. I have put it on vise grips and you can destroy a piece of pipe with them and not wear it off the tips on the jaws. On a Stanley hammer head you can pound in a bunch of 16 penny nails and it doesn't touch the face of that hammer. I live on the Oregon coast and have a test barrel I let people beat on and scratch and you have to put a very sharp edge into it to get it to scratch. A hammer simply dents the steel even glancing blows won't expose the metal under it. This barrel lives in a ditch or buried in the wife's flower bed and has lived out there 24/7 since about 200 when we were certified in it's application. Where ever it is through the finish is rusted but as long as the base metal doesn't show it still looks new.









I have taken to bringing a bit of OxphoBlue with me on extended hunts and find it can be applied in a tent in the serious Boonies easily... and it does a great job of fixing any issues I have bumped into...
Posted By: leftycarbon Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/31/18
Renegade,

If your rifle is di assembled and polished we will HOT blue it $100. We use Brownells products You pay shipping and insurance both ways.

Can send you a copy of our FFL.


Lefty C
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/31/18
Thanks for the offer man.
I turned it in yesterday
Got it down to 220 level
Getting oxide blasted to 120 evenly, then painted and cooked.

I'm gonna roll with the cerracoat job, ain't got a gun done in it, so this will be it.
Call It good , only a 165 dollar pawn shop find
Foul weather gun, use the mod70ot6 safe queen in good weather.
Posted By: HiredGun Re: Blue or cerracoat - 01/31/18
Sitka, I use Oxpho Blue for touchup in the shop. One thing for sure if it isn't neutralized real good before left for any length of time you will wake up to a serious rusted mess.

Sunday was the last day of duck season here on the coast. My son spent the day sea duck hunting in a kayak around the mouth of the Coos Bay bar and just inside the bay. His Remington 1100 was rained on, submerged in salt water and every paddle stroke poured sea water all over that shotgun inside and out. Thank goodness he had a tether on it. He didn't take any oil of any sort. He was wiped when he got home so the shotgun was left unloved on a stool in the garage. He finally got to tear it down last night and after over 48 hours since it's last exposure to the ocean it is still flawless. The kayak was one of those hard plastic jobs so it was under constant sand and plastic abrasion the whole time. There is no bluing in the world that wouldn't have been destroyed from one trip like this but this shotgun thrives in it year after year thanks to Cerakote.
Posted By: renegade50 Re: Blue or cerracoat - 02/08/18
Since I started the great cerracoat debate


Outta the shop and done
Put back together about 3 hr ago at the house
Nice blue black hue in daylight
Ain't looked at assembled rifle in daylight yet
Bout 20ish coats of 50- 50 mix mineral spirits and tru oil
Im happy with it.
Midnight e-110 with a little bit of gloss black h-109

Click enlarge rotate can't figure out posting pics again

https://www.24hourcampfire.com/ubbthreads/ubbthreads.php/galleries/12620333/36g
© 24hourcampfire