Jerry - I'm with Kevin and Bob on this. After I got into the Super I sold all my 45acp stuff wen the 38 Super addiction set in. Then I missed the 45 so much that I needed another one. So I bought one, laid in a supply of ammunition and made a couple of range trips with the it. I sold it two weeks after the last range trip.
Wow... maybe I need to try a few diff. rounds, maybe even the 38 Super!
Jerry
My favorite shooting is long range; generally 100-150 yards. In this, few rounds excel greater than the old .38 super; it's just a flat shooting round that still hits pretty hard at distance.
I don't consider it the equal of the .45 ACP; it's just different. You don't give up much with the Super in terms of terminal performance, but you do gain a couple of pluses. Flatter shooting, less recoil, and another round or two in the magazine. For me, those things are very nice on the range, but not what I "need" for daily carry. On the down side, most .38 Supers are loaded a bit light; almost like a 9mm +P+ in many ways. But there are some rounds you can get that are just awesome. Buffalo Bore loads a 147 JHP that's just awesome and would be an ideal LE cartridge.
One thing I don't like about the .38 Super is the increased noise and muzzle flash over the .45 ACP.
Still, for defensive use the .45 ACP is just hard to beat. I still consider it THE benchmark defensive cartridge.
But even so, I just LOVE the Super, and I intend on switching my LW Commander over to Super for daily carry. Bob was nice enough to sell me a Series 80 9mm upper that will become my .38 Super upper once I decide how I'm going to do it (I tend to ponder these things for months on end).
There's no logic to the love of the Super...it's a sickness, a sin; and I'm unrepentent. If loving the Super is wrong, I don't wannabe right!