If your going to scope it, I'd say the Super Redhawk. For open sights carry and hunting, I prefer just the plain old Redhawk.
This is your answer.
It's not a real problem to scope a Redhawk. Weigand Rail and it now has the 3-Ring Weigand rings, no gunsmithing. Very accurate with Alliant MP-300 and Beartooth 300 grain LCMN DCG bullets at 1.725". I could probably get better accuracy at 1.775", but I have two SuperBlackhawks I'm feeding the same load to.
The SRH has a much improved trigger system and is by far the better platform for scope mounting. The RH has more eye appeal IMHO.
I agree wholeheartedly. My particular SRH also seemed to be slightly more accurate, possibly the trigger?