The 375 Ruger will do nothing a 375 H&H cannot except fit in a shorter action. There is some argument as to duplicating 375 H&H performance with Ruger reloads.
Will it be around in 90+ years? Do I care? (as I won't).
H&H has been designing cartridges and building rifles a lot longer than Ruger for use in really nasty places. Does that matter?
Finally H&Hs are "cool", you're handling history.
(but I just bought a Benelli R 1 in 270 WSM, so I'm no purist)
244, 300, 375 & 400.... H&Hs all
.............Neither the 375 H&H or the 375 Ruger will out do the other when it comes to killing power. So that is not an issue. Ruger and Hornady did not develop the 375 Ruger as a better killing cartridge than the 375 H&H.
The 375 Ruger was developed to offer a shorter 30-06 length action, in a shorter OAL rifle package, that does in fact (with reloads) duplicate 24" and 25" barreled 375 H&H ballistics. No gimmicks, no hype, just a plain cold hard fact. The 375 Ruger casing holds more powder. And if given the "same" barrel lengths for both, there is no way any 375 H&H rifle could equal the 375 Ruger in the velocity dept given the same bullet weights. It`s not just the Ruger cartridge which is so appealing. It is the rifles even more so. A 40.75" OAL rifle which offers the same performance as a rifle 5" or 6" longer, has great appeal. So in lieu of handling history and the emotional nostalgia, I`ll simply take a more modern, a better and faster handling 21st century rifle with the same ballistic performance.
Yep! The 375 H&H has been around for nearly 100 years!....Yep! The 375 H&H has killed more game than any 375 in history. I hope so, as it had a 92 year head start! However, the 375 Ruger doesn`t need to be proven any further and if so, in what way? It already has been proven via all the testing and R&D by Hornady and Ruger prior to its intro, via modern design technology and used extensively in the field on game. It shoots the same bullets as the H&H and is just as accurate if not more so. So what`s left to prove?
I once owned a 375 H&H, but I didn`t consider myself handling history or from some other historical perspective. Its only a rifle cartridge, not the original Mona Lisa, a Rembrandt painting, or original papers written by Lincoln, Washington or Jefferson, a rare collectors coin, an antique piece of furniture or vase, etc, which do have true historical value.
Here are some #s from my particular 20" Alaskan barrel which were taken from other refereneces, duplicated and worked up to, which "should" eliminate any arguments or debates, as to whether or not, the 375 Ruger is capable of duplicating longer barreled 375 H&H performance from the shorter barrels.
225 gr Horn SP,,79.8 gr RL-15,,@ 3016 fps. 20" load data e/mailed from Hornady showed 79.5 gr @ 3000 fps.
270 gr Horn SP,,87.0 gr H-4350,@.2808 fps. see "gunblast.com".."archives"..2/6/07.
2875 fps from a 23" African test rifle by
Jeff Quinn.
The above loads grouped 1.15" OD and less. (3 shot). I have other reloads which are moa and less.
Yes! The 375 H&H will do anything on game that the 375 Ruger can do. That is not the issue! What the 375 Ruger offers, which the 375 H&H cannot offer, is a faster, better handling and shorter OAL rifle package, that does equal or slightly better the ballistics of the longer H&H rifle.
The 375 Ruger`s popularity is on-going and is continuing to grow rapidly. No other round in history has come so far in such a short period of time. (A Boddington paraphrase, not mine).
So to you classic, nostalgic and historical 375 H&H owners (incl Oldman1942). Keep on using your fingers to plug the holes of the dam walls which are holding back the waters of 375 Ruger popularity. Little by little, the leaks will keep gettin bigger every day.