Home
Posted By: bobinpa 35 cal barrel options - 10/26/19
So I was just about to order a couple of barrels from PacNor when I heard the news that they had a devastating fire. Which is truly a shame! I need 2 sporter weight barrels in .35 caliber. 1 for a 358 WSM and 1 for a 358 Norma Mag. Both will be stainless. Who do you guys suggest I go with now? Not many.35 cal options out there....
Thanks in advance
Posted By: 5shot Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/26/19
Lothar-Walther

My last one came from Pac-Nor, but if I had to do it again I would go with L-W.
Posted By: 700xcr Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/27/19
Have you tried Benchmark Barrels?
http://benchmark-barrels.com/Benchmark_Barrels/Benchmark_Barrels_Home.html
Posted By: howard1 Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/27/19
Douglas one of the oldest around.
Posted By: Shadow Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/27/19
All below will make 35 caliber barrels, in addition to LW and Benchmark:

https://kriegerbarrels.com/

https://riflebarrels.com/

https://www.hartbarrels.com/

http://www.shilen.com/index.html
Posted By: hangunnr Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/28/19
Add Lilja to your list of options.

I put a #5 12 twist Lilja on my 358WSSM and couldn’t be any happier with it.
Posted By: gunswizard Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/28/19
E.R. Shaw makes quality barrels at a reasonable price.
Posted By: jackmountain Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/29/19
I have a Shilen on a Remington 700 in .35 Whelen AI. It was a #4 or #5? Can't remember. Had Dave at IT&D turn it down to a Remington mag sporter contour. Shoots like this with the first loads I tried with 250gr hornady's.
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: z1r Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/29/19
Originally Posted by gunswizard
E.R. Shaw makes quality barrels at a reasonable price.


No they don't.
Posted By: 358Norma_fan Re: 35 cal barrel options - 10/30/19
I've had 2 35 cal barrels from Douglas. I certainly wouldn't go looking too hard to find another maker.
It is easier to make a good barrel with the larger, 30cal+, bore sizes. Any of the major barrel companies make great hunting barrels.
Posted By: rickt300 Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/07/19
Originally Posted by z1r
Originally Posted by gunswizard
E.R. Shaw makes quality barrels at a reasonable price.


No they don't.


I have gad several ER Shaw barrels that shot great, did you get a bad one?
Posted By: gunswizard Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/08/19
Same here, E.R. Shaw barrels are amoung some of the best shooting that I have.
Posted By: z1r Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/08/19
Originally Posted by rickt300
Originally Posted by z1r
Originally Posted by gunswizard
E.R. Shaw makes quality barrels at a reasonable price.


No they don't.


I have gad several ER Shaw barrels that shot great, did you get a bad one?


Worse than bad. Very long story but the short version is, it was the only barrel I ever had to pretzel on me when contouring it. As supplied they are too heavy so a "little" thinning was required. Do this with most brands. Theirs started flopping around on the lathe like a fish out of water at the first light cut. They may have improved the stress relieving of their barrels since, but I never tried another. Too many good barrels to waste my time on another Shaw.
Posted By: Craigster Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/08/19
I've have one in 222 on a 700 action. It shoots very well.
Posted By: STA Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/11/19
Originally Posted by jackmountain
I have a Shilen on a Remington 700 in .35 Whelen AI. It was a #4 or #5? Can't remember. Had Dave at IT&D turn it down to a Remington mag sporter contour. Shoots like this with the first loads I tried with 250gr hornady's.
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]




My 358STA shoots the same with its #4 Shilen.....
Posted By: Judman Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/18/19
My whelen has a 12 twist hart. Love it
Posted By: texken Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/19/19
Originally Posted by howard1
Douglas one of the oldest around.

this, I have had tremendous luck with Douglass
Posted By: Bugger Re: 35 cal barrel options - 11/23/19
I've had good luck and bad luck with ER Shaw. The bad luck was a long time ago.

I have Shilen and Douglas barrels also. If I were wanting 1/2 MOA I'd probably go with either and get their "premium". If I were building a hunting rifle I'd probably go with ER Shaw especially with the calibers you're talking about.. The last rifle I built was with ER Shaw - a 375 Whelen AI. I only have Iron sights on it, but it's plenty accurate for what I wanted it for. The bore looks excellent. It doesn't foul with copper or lead.
Posted By: TX35W Re: 35 cal barrel options - 12/10/19
Most barrel makers do them. The rub is is you want one cut rifled in a lighter stainless contour. In button rifled you've got Benchmark, Lilja, Hart, etc.
Originally Posted by Bugger
I've had good luck and bad luck with ER Shaw. The bad luck was a long time ago.

I have Shilen and Douglas barrels also. If I were wanting 1/2 MOA I'd probably go with either and get their "premium". If I were building a hunting rifle I'd probably go with ER Shaw especially with the calibers you're talking about.. The last rifle I built was with ER Shaw - a 375 Whelen AI. I only have Iron sights on it, but it's plenty accurate for what I wanted it for. The bore looks excellent. It doesn't foul with copper or lead.



I use a lot of Shilens and will tell you that it is a waste of money using a select match barrel over the match barrel for a hunting rifle. The only advantage is between your ears.
Posted By: Greyghost Re: 35 cal barrel options - 12/14/19
Put a Lilja #5 with a 1 in 12 on my STA. They'd be my #1 choice.

Phil
Posted By: fremont Re: 35 cal barrel options - 12/17/19
I guess I got lucky with my A&B from Midway on my 35 Whelen Imp.
Posted By: RinB Re: 35 cal barrel options - 12/31/19

My Benchmark 35 is excellent
Posted By: beretzs Re: 35 cal barrel options - 12/31/19
I have a CM Krieger #3 .358 1-10 twist and a Benchmark #3 1-9.5 Twist right now. One of them will become another 35 Whelen and the other will go on my 35 Newton. I can't imagine either will let me down.
Posted By: Cowboybart Re: 35 cal barrel options - 01/04/20
I have had good experiences with X Caliber and just ordered a 375 cal from them
© 24hourcampfire