I don't think so, get over it...

That's fine, some people don't know the finer things in life and Dukes with a fresh tomato and light bread in the summer can't be beat. Plus it just leaves more for us from the South .

Them's fighting words.

This should easily make ten pages.

Never even heard of it up here...

That's fine, some people don't know the finer things in life and Dukes with a fresh tomato and light bread in the summer can't be beat. Plus it just leaves more for us from the South .



Did we read the same thing? They really liked Dukes.

Dukes or Miracle Whip for me.
Hellman's, flavorless grease.

After all the raves about it here, I found some and tried it. Guess my taste buds are dead. I can't tell a difference.

so much for credibility

Falling on your spear today, sse?

duke it out

Duke's and Blue Plate are all we buy.

Same here

Dukes is the only way to go. You can order it off Amazon. laughing

Never had Dukes or Blue Plate. Not opposed to either one.


Now Miricle Frap and margarine, that sh....it ain't right.

50% right is better than nuthin, spose

Thats the campfire, it would take a Miracle to Whip us into agreement!

Mann-theys always fighting around here.

Hell-Mans, they would fight over a chicken egg and earl!

Fightin' words, DB! Lol

Had Dukes at a sandwich shop when I was in the Atlanta area back in the late 90's helping close down Mervyns stores there. Asked what mayo and they said Dukes extra thick. First time I was introduced to commercial extra thick mayo or even knew of its existence.

I get Best Foods extra thick here in KOMMIEFORNIA thru a restaurant supply house.

Agree that Duke's closely followed by Blue Plate is the best.

MM,

I've heard that it's better with ice !

That crap may be!

Never had dukes, so can't comment.

For commercial, I like Hellman's, but the best is grandma's homemade aioli !

I guess me, an' Paul will just haveta' keep doin' without the Dukes. I have gotten by for 73 years, and with an ample waist line to prove it.

My mistake my comprehension skills were compromised due to Blue Agave. My apologies to any I offended, Dukes in made in my hometown by the C.F. Sauer Co. Only mayo there is , everything else is second rate.

The first nonbeliever to step up and send me your address, I will ship a quart for your perusal with tomatoes and light bread.

Sounds good, no ripe tommytoes here ed yet. Soon, I hope.

Dukes in my frig. I recently tried Blueplate. Pretty good as well if you cant get Dukes. MW is not mayo. Anymore than margarine is butter. Or Tang is orange juice. But if you like it on your sammich have at it.

I see the retards are still all here 😂

Hell, a few years back the boyz were ready ta git the gunz out over their cornbread recipes. Dukes is good stuff but I'm gonna jump ship on buying it in the future Our little country store brand mayo just blows it away.

Neighbor lady's tater salad is simply killer. She uses MW !

The hell you say!

LOL. I guess she didn't get the memo but it's really killer. Hardcore redneck WV girl and ex army ta boot. It's like talkin' to R Lee Ermey with tits.

Normally I like Hellman's. I've been trying to order from places other than Amazon as they are getting too big. Walmart (small company I know :)) has free 2 day shipping on most stuff with a minimum order and so I have some Dukes headed north for just $3.28.

https://www.walmart.com/search/?query=dukes%20mayonnaise&typeahead=dukes

OK, so I keep hearing/reading about Dukes, gonna have to see if anyone has it locally.

I have been a Hellmans kinda guy since the 70s so it will be a challenge for Dukes to satisfy me.

3 jars heading here I order pickles from Walmart and get free shipping

Put me in the "can't tell any difference" camp. Best Food/Hellman's or Miracle Whip are just about the same to me. I've never had Duke's so I can't say. I will admit that I do prefer the Hellman's with Olive Oil, but all my wife buys are "Lite" and "Low Fat" things.

Maybe I'll take up rrconductor's offer of a quart. (I'd settle for a half-pint.)

Lite mayo and lite sour cream are abominations.

yeah, 'lite' anything

Okay dvdegeorge. If you are like me, you are about to be shocked. RockyRabb, go to Walmartc.com and place an order. Those Johnny Rebs are on to something in this case....

My jar came last night. I just opened it in preparation for a couple 'mater sandwiches. I tried a spoon sample and thought "good stuff". Then I tried my beloved Hellman's...'blah" What the heck?! Compared to the Duke's, the Hellman's basically was like Miracle Whip Lite. No joke! When tasted side by side the Hellman's sweetness is more like a salad dressing. The Duke's is more pure white, tangy, and just plain better.

I have seen the light; the internet shows its worth once again!

I was in the camp of mayo is mayo is miracle whip. Could not tell the difference really. Seen Dukes at Walmart a while back. Bought a small jar. Damn it has flavor. It is not just sweet white goop like mayo or miracle whip. I must say I was more in the miracle whip camp as it had a slight flavor edge over mayo but was still more sweet than anything else. Dukes is just damn good. Cannot describe it really other than it hits sweet sour and salty perfectly. A good dose of black pepper and you got a hell of a turkey sandwich. Or a stack of thick cut bacon on coarse wheat bread toast with Dukes on both pieces of bread. I would not take a sandwich to work for lunch when I ran out of Dukes. Waited until I restocked. Bought the big jar this time.

Rocky, send me an address and I will get some coming to ya. Best thing in the world on mater sandwiches with lots of pepper, Doc took me off salt yrs ago. All my mater pies are made with Dukes.

Claude,

I had pretty much given up on the Fire. However, it's real gentlemen like you that make it worth checking into every once in awhile.

YOU Sir are a good man. When I get back to GSP we will do Adams Bistro for a little meat and 3!! Bring your lady friend. In fact, bring me one as well. :))

David Lee

PS.....while you're at it please send that same good rocket gentleman in Utah some quality SC pimento cheese as well. I'll pay for it!!!

Soon as he sends me an address it's on the way. Good to here from you David. I thought you were in the middle of trying to retire?How's Sis doing, I hope fine, cancer has now struck my SIL, lukemia , butte on the way to recovery. Her Dr.s have a 85% success rate so we are very blessed for that.

Now this I wanna make...

daily double

also another reason for coming back was to comment on this mayo testing.

FIRST of all WTH do yankees know about good mayo? Everything they put on sandwiches comes out of those little squirt package's.



SECONDLY

WTH puts mayo on fries? Especially, in a taste test???? For this they all deserve to live in Miracle Whip city!!



Dukes is so good because they use more egg yolks than many others and good apple cider vinegar. And of course it's made right there in my hometown of Greenville, SC!!

you hafta be one of the most uppity hillbillies this yankee ever saw

You ain't a Yankee in my book. But yeah no doubt I could be considered a hillbilly!

Don't know what uppity means.....

Never tried this "Dukes" stuff. Is it a good as Miracle Whip?

Probably not.

(ya teed that one up for me...LOL)

I seen Duke's in WalMart here a few years back. After hearing the comments about it here on the campfire, I thought I would give it a try. I have been buying it since. Wal-Mart is the only place that sells it locally.

I guess that is better than gravy on fries. The 1st time I was in Buffalo, and then Toronto, the lady said you want gravy on your fries , I being from the south said No Mam we put gravy on meat or catheads or rice ,none of which ya'll have here that I have seen. Needless to say she didn't find the humor. I guess they don't get good tomatoes for ketchup.

Go to Utah, they mix ketchup and mayo, call it fry sauce. You can guess the rest.


It's pretty good.

bump

well at least sse stopped hijacking my thread. Shame he could not come up with a thread name with any originality at all. lol

somebody clicked on the link