Looks to me as a crude knock-off as compared to the one I Have
I think it is a real pistol fob, although heavily worn. Does anyone know for sure if these fobs came with a strap? My guess is that they did, but I wouldn't know what one looks like.
I don't discount any of the searches folks have done, however, if that $452 is real and stands as a sale, it is an outlier.
Everything in this case was under $300. Still good money IMO, but a far cry from $400-500.
Note - the odd looking one on top is the left half of a fob cast. Backside is flat and been converted to a tie tack. Legit or not? I haven't seen another.