My brother was in Cabelas in Scarborough Me they had an 95 in the gun room with a 4 digit serial # . He wasn't sure on the price thought around $1600.00

Just because it is an 1895 doesn't make it worth $1,600. Although a few years back when it was crazy it would have been grabbed up regardless. For that price it needs to be all original with some condition. So yes it might be a decent price or it may not.

I think that is likely the one with extra holes on the left side of the receiver.