These two guns certainly raise some questions, I would like to actually hold them - it's really hard to give an accurate assessment from just pictures or a description. I offered my thoughts as a subject for discussion and certainly would like to get a definite answer ... but some things we may never get definite answers to. The bolt actions are not my main area of collecting so I have not paid as much attention to details - I will now be looking for serial numbers on any of these I run across to see if I can find any more that are similar.
Rick, on your gun I had thought that the lettering looked to be slightly rounded in your pictures, I took an example I have and tried to duplicate the lighting that�s in your pictures with a glare line running parallel and through the lettering; I could not get a result that I thought could be used to come to a definite conclusion. I think the lettering looks slightly sharper in the pictures I took of mine but I don't think there is enough difference to come to a definite conclusion so I did not plan on posting them, or mentioning that I thought your gun might have been reblued. I still lean toward a reblue but have not ruled out it's being original, I just don't see enough evidence either way.
You can see my example has quite a bit of wear & thinning blue, I tried with & without a flash -