What Paul said is pretty much on the mark. The Browning BPCRs are really going to be a notch above the Ubertis in the accuracy department. They are available used, and they hold their value. They also come with well made sights. But they are heavy, and they are even less like the original than the Italians.
That said, I think they are nice rifles.
Personally, and as Paul knows, I have a bug for original actions and then I run around getting them rebarreled, sometimes restocked etc. Half the fun of owning one like that is the joy you have when all the hassle of rebuilding one is over.
Seriously, I do enjoy the process of rebuilding an old rifle like that so I don't really know that much about the off-the shelf rifles. Even my Shiloh has been rebarreled. Heck, I have to think hard before I can come up with a rifle that I haven't rebarreled.
But Paul is spot on about the Browning/Winchester BPCRs. They are shooters.
BTW, this is a Browning you do NOT want. If you look closely, you will see that this does not have a top tang. That tells you it is no a Badger barrel rifle, is not fitted for a tang sight and probably has the wrong twist for what BPCR shooters generally want. Yes, this is confusing.
http://www.gunauction.com/buy/12432...-1885-high-wall-.45-70-single-shot-rifle