Home
Posted By: BrentD WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
I'm not elking this year, unfortunately.

I'm thinking of putting in for next year with my hunting partner. We have some preference points to burn, though maybe not enough.

We are pretty much do-it-yourselfers for the most part and prefer to pack in a few miles. We don't like crowds so we avoid areas with roads and we avoid opening weekends like the plague.

So, with all of those caveats, I have to add one more. My partner seems to get hit with elevation sickness every time we start camping above 10K.

So, where in Wyoming can one find elk at 9000 or less w/o getting run over by truck/atv hunters?

I keep seeing these photos, here and elsewhere, of huge bulls shot in sagebrush or ponderosa, relatively early in the seasons and at what seems like low altitudes. Maybe they are all photoshopped - but probably not.

Any suggestions?
Posted By: salsola Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
unit 79. No ATVs in the park and most folks never seems to wander more than 1/4 mile from the road.
Posted By: BrentD Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
79 - is that the Jackson Hole feedlots? Not hardly interested in that.

Posted By: salsola Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
Did you look at a map? 71 will get you away from crowds and motors too.
Posted By: Ravenr2 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
79 is not a feedlot hunt
elk are migrating to lower elevations
need COLD weather and SNOW to
work thou.
Posted By: BrentD Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
I did look at the map but may have misread it. It looked like 79 was a tiny unit in the Teton NP, but the map resolution on this laptop is crap.

Counting on cold and snow is always dicey - especially when you really need it. Did that once west of Chama, NM and got lucky even though the conditions were not favorable for migration at the time.

I'll look more closely. I see it now. 79 is a tiny unit for sure but worth investigating. Area 71 is at least 85% wilderness. Not entirely out of reach, but as a nonresident, I have to count on a third person to get us into the majority of the area and his time is limited.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/09/12
Best bet is probably the hard to draw area's like the Shirley Mtns, Green Mtn, and the west side of the Big Horns.
Other wise as a nonresident you run up against the wilderness/guide requirements, or you have to find places with some sizable "roadless" area's (21,15,13,and parts of 110) that you can be back a 1/4 mile or so from the road and loose alot of the extra hunting pressure. But the problem there comes if it does snow and the elk migrate down to the desert or get into private lands.
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
21 has roads all over it, wilderness, crowds and no elk. Stay the hell away from it.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Originally Posted by wyoelk
21 has roads all over it, wilderness, crowds and no elk. Stay the hell away from it.

You are part right, but with the majority of the Forest Service lands under the white arrow, a person can still hunt between Hiway 70 the continental divide to the Jack Creek Road, and over to the Deep creek road, and have a good chunk of country to do the pack in hunt Brents talking about. Especially since the idiot azzholes pulling all the crap on Haggarty Creek and getting that road access shut off.
Look at the head basins of Haskins,Lost, Haggarty, Mill, Savery, and Deep creek for some relatively quiet hunting.
Plus there is country along between the Battle Creek canyon and the Huston Park Wilderness that takes shoe leather to get into and therefore not alot of traffic.
I also wouldn't discount using the access on the east side of Battle Mtn, to pack across and bivouac on the north slope in the oaks.
Biggest draw back is those elk aren't reall gutsy up along the divide and 6-8 inches of snow can kick them out. We've been stuck up in there more than once when it dumped 2ft over night, and the only thing left was a couple of old buck deer and some grouse.
Posted By: BrentD Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Many thanks for the suggestions. I have access to a large map collection at the library here and can research these areas fairly well.

Sadly, my wife has two perfectly useless, but healthy horses that could make this all a lot easier. However, the wife isn't loaning them out. They are broke to bloody mule deer. But it was Tamra that I should have been training, not Rusty. But that's okay. I've got another elk or two left in these legs smile
Posted By: anie Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
have spend alot of time in 71, not very many people but u may
need a guide if non-res, its real wild up there lots of bears
and wolfs and big elk
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Brent it's just as well to leave the horses home anyway. No need to have to get up 2 hours early just to do chores, when you're sorta spozed to be semivacation and having fun.Plus they have the same troubles adjusting to altitude that we do.
Also in the region I described in 21, alot of the good places where you'll kill elk it's almost to steep and to rocky for horses , a good mule might do alright, but the chances of a major wreck are still pretty high.
One of my favored meadows is 220 yds across, if they come out on the timber on the uphill side you can hit your bull in the lower chest and bust his spine just about everytime, that's how steep it is near the top of some of those ridges.
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Originally Posted by Ranch13
Originally Posted by wyoelk
21 has roads all over it, wilderness, crowds and no elk. Stay the hell away from it.

You are part right, but with the majority of the Forest Service lands under the white arrow, a person can still hunt between Hiway 70 the continental divide to the Jack Creek Road, and over to the Deep creek road, and have a good chunk of country to do the pack in hunt Brents talking about. Especially since the idiot azzholes pulling all the crap on Haggarty Creek and getting that road access shut off.
Look at the head basins of Haskins,Lost, Haggarty, Mill, Savery, and Deep creek for some relatively quiet hunting.
Plus there is country along between the Battle Creek canyon and the Huston Park Wilderness that takes shoe leather to get into and therefore not alot of traffic.
I also wouldn't discount using the access on the east side of Battle Mtn, to pack across and bivouac on the north slope in the oaks.
Biggest draw back is those elk aren't reall gutsy up along the divide and 6-8 inches of snow can kick them out. We've been stuck up in there more than once when it dumped 2ft over night, and the only thing left was a couple of old buck deer and some grouse.


You need to send your sarcasm meter in for repair. Yours seems to be.....broken.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Well no I figured it was the typical keepem out of my hunting territory crap. Which is nonsense,2 more hunters would be almost unnoticable, but as there are probably people reading this with serious interest in getting some info they can use to work with.....
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
[Linked Image]

Monday night additional cow/calf in 21. Had 25+ square miles of mountain all to myself. Not another person around. Elk running around everywhere and most under 9000 feet.
We have an elk problem in 21.
Posted By: BrentD Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
wyoelk, your first note tickled my often insensitive sarcasm detector. So, I was prepared to investigate. These have been very helpful posts and I really appreciate them.

Looks like you have some groceries for the winter. She should be taste in the extreme. Been a few years since I have had elk in my freezer and that needs to change.

Thanks,
Brent
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Dont think that 21 is always like that. This coming monday the general season starts and to say the circus is in town will be an understatement. We backpack up into the wilderness to get away from it.

Give the clowns a few days to booze up, wear down and run out of gas for the atv's and 21 gets real nice again.

There are plenty of spots that hold elk for a person willing to put on boots and park the atv.

The area holds lots of elk but it isnt known for a trophy area. A person willin to work will see several rags, five and six point bulls to shoot.

Tag is cake to draw with one preference point.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Yup down on the stockdrive, there'll be lights strung in the trees, don't know if they still bring the collapsable dance floor so they can all line dance with each other or not... Only drove by and saw the circus once when we had to go to Savery to use the phone...
But the last couple of years up Haggerty when the screaming and shouting and loud music echo'ld up and down the canyon most of the night and the constant barrage of 9 mill target practice was going on during the day,,More and more elk carcasses just basically had the backstraps and part of the hams gone, and doe/fawn deer heads buried in the brush almost out of sight of the road, I knew that 27 years of my elk hunting spot was coming to a close. and sho nuff the road got closed...
So now I'm not sure what we're going to do, but what's left of our bunch is planning on one last hunt up there this next week.
In a number of ways I am glad that road is closed from the bottom, at least now maybe folks that haven't had heart problems and old age isn't making arthritis in knee joints, can enjoy the small clearings, and meadows, and drink from those cold cold springs in the rock slides, and enjoy what we once knew of the peace and solitude up there.And there are a few really good bulls, but they didn't get that way by hanging around when the noise started....
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Sorry to hear that Ranch. That's the reason we gave up on the little sandstone area for bulls. Way to many azzholes blasting la-bamba and 9mm at night.

Great for bow hunting and even better for cow season but that place can go to hell during the circus season.

We did our line dancing in Dixon but they closed the place down. I see it's open again this year. wink
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
Your road closure made for a long hike uphill out of the lake. I'm ok with that for now.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/10/12
I haven't been up there for a couple of years. There's 4 of us that hunted together for a long time going to rondezvous at Lost Creek, we'll see what the redgods bring, but it's not going to be the same as humping to the high meadows below Singer in time for legal shooting light.....
Funny thing once during cow season. A grandson of an old friend wanted to start elk hunting and he drew a cow tag. I had already been up the Hag and killed my bull, but we met the boy and his mother at Rawlins a day before the season opened.
I had a good camp spot with plenty of elk sign found on the ridge between Sandstone and Savery. When we got back there to that spot it was full of Nebraska vehicles and what looked like half of the photo shoot for a Cabela's catalog. Found another spot not far from where I had done the scouting. Next morning we hunted and then in the afternoon Zack went out to see what he could do on his own. About an hour later he come back leading a paint horse. I said boy we need to work on your animal identification but thank god you didn't shoot it. Had a big laugh. We carried him a bucket of water and tied him to a tree with some grass to graze, pretty quick here come a pickup from Arkansas with some paniced looking people that were severly happy that someone found their horse.... Weather kicked us out of there a couple of days later, never did get him a shot at a cow, got into some, but they were moving like greased lightning.
After that he never did the cow permit thing again, but we did turn him into quite a bull hunter/killer over the next few years.
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
Got a friend scattered back in lost creek. Don't tell the tree sheriffs. Good luck to you guys next week. We will be on top where water is cold and the bulls are still mouthy.
Posted By: chesterwy Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
I also have an additional cow tag for 21. I was planning on waiting till the first weekend in November to hunt. Do the elk pile out of there if there gets to be a lot of snow? Or should I go this weekend before the general season starts?
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
50/50 call. At times, they are very easy to shoot out near McCarty canyon. You can also be in snow up to your azz and spend most of your time chaining up, digging out and winching. If the weather is good you have your own little circus out there as that's it when the snow piles up in the trees.

I prefer hunting them in the trees wearing a t-shirt. That's just me.

Five years ago? McCarty. Now? I wouldn't bet my tag on filling it out there.
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
Wyo, I wanted to be scattered about where the spring is on that rock ridge where the warden and his girlfriend built the mansion...
Chester if you're not having to shoot horns, I'ld wait , let the crowds thin and then go find the elk where they are.The weather forecast isnt' looking like anything serious, but I've seen it go from 60 one afternoon, to snow knee deep and caving the tent roof in by 6 the next morning.
Greenridge,and out in those canyons where they built the Pot Hook can hold the elk if the snow gets deep up higher. But where ever you go on the "cow" season, you likely won't be alone..
Posted By: wyoelk Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
Lots of stories with old Ron. He is a good guy. His replacement, Kim, is a go getter.

We made Ron bounce his truck into a schithole once to bust a friend turned poacher. It was shock and awe. wink

I had planned to be scattered above a mine at 10000. That went to [bleep] last February.
Posted By: chesterwy Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
Thanks for the input guys. I think waiting till November sounds like the way to go. Should be a fun time either way.
Posted By: trouthunterdj Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
Good info in this thread. Thanks

ddj
Posted By: Ranch13 Re: WY elk below 9000 ft - 10/11/12
DAng I guess I didn't know Ron had retired.. Is Steve still deputy out of Baggs?
Looking forward to seeing that country again.

Chester , good luck and have fun, killing a cow in 21 never has been a big problem except for in the mid 80's when there was only something like 50 cow permits for a year or two. Finding horns on the other hand could be a real problem from time to time, unless it was spikes excluded and then it always seemed like there'ld be 2 or 3 of the little buggers almost follow you around...
© 24hourcampfire