Originally Posted by michiganroadkill

Burnish with some "tired" fine grit sandpaper.


Thanks Tim
After Mike's post I actually did sand the edge with some "tired" 150 grit (didn't have any 220 on hand). I had been using a coarser grit. The finer grit seems to actually remove more material than the course if that makes sense. It got rid of most of the peach-fuzz so I think I'm headed in the right direction. Just need some saddle soap and I'll get back after it.

Thanks to everyone.