Originally Posted by 4ager
Originally Posted by Just a Hunter
Originally Posted by 4ager
Originally Posted by Fireball2
Has anybody ever documented a tubular magazine detonation caused by pointy bullets?


No, and in fact, I believe that myth has been debunked several times (though few pay any attention).


I have read that the reason the Army at the time turned down the Marlin in 45-70 ( want to say the Marlin 1883) was because of tube magazine detonations.

Dave Scovill did an article some years ago showing that some calibers were less susceptible to detonation do to the way the round sat in the tube.





The Army stuck with the Trapdoor because the head of Army supply and logistics was worried about soldiers "wasting ammunition". Also, if there were detonations (and there may have been), primers then were WAY different than they are now.


Yes I know about the wasting ammo reason. The same reason for the burst mode on the M-16 in these times. However, they did test the Marlin and claimed to have had detonations at the time.