I use 3 pairs of boots for elk hunting. When its warm, 50 degrees, or I'm only walking, I wear Salomon Quest 4D. For most days, about 90% of the time, I wear Danner/Cabelas Elk Hunters with 400 grams thinsulite. I've worn these boots to below zero. When its cold, I break out the Danner Canadians with 600 grams thinsulite.
The conundrum with elk hunting is that you don't want 10lb boots on your feet. You also have to trade off warm enough with light enough. The trump card is boot fit and foot/boot stability. If you hunt in steep areas, both your feet and boots will be tested. I tend to trade a couple extra ounces on my feet for a boot that will stay together, not torture my feet, and fits. Buy good boots that fit and are 'warm enough'.
