Any topwater lure in general.
Used to be the same way. Then I started fishing this frogs - they have rubber paddle tails. Get them at Fleet Farm.
Scum Frog they're called - have to have the paddle feet like this:
Fish real slow - get some bass but they're dynamite on slimers.
They'll come back for them. Cast this one into the weeds, hit it and missed. I did nothing but let it sit there, twitch twice and start a slow retrieve and it come back and freight trained it. Pulled it out of its mouth like this and with 5 minutes of untangling, went right back to fishing.
This was on High Falls Flowage 2 summers ago. I always have about 4 of these in white/red and green in my tackle box.