I've got a Davis, and it's a nice tent. No complaints. It got some small tears from bad wind up near the peak ends. I took it to Montana Canvas in Belgrade for repairs, as they are not far from here.
I couldn't help but look at the display tent that MT Canvas had set up in their shop/store. It seemed to be better made in my quick look. just heavier duty sewing, some design differences in the peak ends, difference in the internal frame angles, stove jack, and a few other details like rope sewn into the eaves to make it stronger along the grommet line.
I'd have to say in my opinion, the MT is the better tent. But you will pay more for it.
