There are tons of options currently and a few years back I had the same decisions to make. I ended up watching tons of youtube videos where guys shoot suppresssed guns next to a dB meter and compare different brands and models. I went with a SilencerCo Omega as a multi purpose centerfire can that can be swapped between AR's, hunting rifles, and long range bolt actions. For that purpose I have been extremely pleased and it's sound performance in relation to it's size and weight are outstanding. For the rimfire can I went with a Dead Air Mask HD. Again, the sound performance and it being rated for 17 and 22mag made it a top choice. The only can that came close to performance was the newer Thunderbeast rimfire and it wasn't available yet.
Whatever you buy, do lots of research. There are lots of good options out there, buy the best you can.
