I am not familiar with the weight of those mentioned. Weight becomes a factor for every day carry. I have a S&W Model 37 airweight that I have carried off and on since 1983. To make it even better I had the hammer bobbed, a trigger job to make the double action pull very smooth and added Spegel grips to dress it up. Carried either in a pocket or with my Mernickle Holster it is pleasure.

"When there's lead in the air, there's hope in the heart."
Patron Member, NRA
Life Member, SCI
Life Member, Whittington Center
SASS member
Life Member, National Federation of Poachers