I've got a 416 Rigby, but I could warm up nicely to a 416 Alaskan with a good stock switched in. Maybe a Swirlie. Can't like the Hogue stocks.

I don't see anything wrong with either cartridge, in fact I like them both. But, I wouldn't give up my H&H or my Rigby for either. But I could like owning all 4.

David