I'm floppin' like a fish with this decision. I hate the obstructed view through a regular topper, so I'm considering a tonneau - but which type?

Rigid/fiberglass - This type seems to be secure and weatherproof, but carrying a object taller than the box becomes an event. I won't carry large objects often, but it will happen (Murphy's Law).

Vinyle/Roll-up - Weatherproof but not secure, easily handles a large load. Would you leave your gear protected by a thin piece of vinyl?

Fold-a-Top - Good security, handles large loads, but weatherproof? Maybe not...

Help me out here please - who has which and how do you like it?

Thanks

Forgive me my nonsense, as I also forgive the nonsense of those that think they talk sense.
Robert Frost