I've heard nothing bad about them but as always stated, it's no Aimpoint.

Which brings up the question, does it have to be? I run a Burris Fast Fire II on my Buckmark pistol and it works fine for it's intended use, it's no RMR either but it works and is just as rugged as fiber optic sights. (Which I have broken)

I may try one on my cheap gun if irons alone don't work out.

As for the review, who knows. Would I trust my life to one? No but you have back up irons don't you?