I don't know which Weaver it was, but it was a 1.5-? that I looked through recently at the range. It was a good example of how not all 1xish scopes are equal. The eyebox was horrible and the FOV was tiny. At the $250ish that the guy spent I'd've just kept shooting irons and saving up money.
The Weaver linked above has 65' FOV vs. the 97' for the Trijicon. For what a 1xish is used for, that extra 50% is a big deal to me.
Level of importance to me:
1-Eyebox
2-FOV
3-Magnification power
